Recteq 1250 one year review

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Waiting for this to be back in stock and I'll probably pick one up. It bolts on to where the smoke stack goes and they say typically will reduce the temp by about 30-40F so that might be exactly where you want to be.

I want one too, that would really be a good addition to the 1250.
Al
Interesting to see you would have gone a size down. I've been looking at getting a new pellet grill, having previously had a Traeger Pro 575 a couple of years ago. Replaced it with a Chargriller 980. It just seems too big for *most* of what I cook. The size is nice to do two big pizzas side by side, but I rarely make efficient use of the space. I think I'd be happier with a smaller grill. But the advice you always read when asking should you go bigger or smaller is GO BIGGER.
If I did it all over again I think I still would have gone with the 1250, it is very efficient & uses very few pellets, especially at 180, which is where I cook a lot. The extra room is nice!
Al
 
Excellent review on the RT1250. I am looking at purchasing the smokebox addon. In your experience, is it worth it? Could you also please share the pro's and con's on the smokebox. Thank you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
This looks like an interesting option. I have watch people cold smoke with just a smoke tube and smoke lower then 180° using the different rack levels in the smoke box. Would be nice to have someone whom I trust give their opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
Excellent review on the RT1250. I am looking at purchasing the smokebox addon. In your experience, is it worth it? Could you also please share the pro's and con's on the smokebox. Thank you!

Al, I would second this. I would appreciate your assessment of your smokebox!

This looks like an interesting option. I have watch people cold smoke with just a smoke tube and smoke lower then 180° using the different rack levels in the smoke box. Would be nice to have someone whom I trust give their opinion.

I haven’t used the smoke box enough to give an honest opinion. It sure looks cool though! I have noticed that I’m getting more smoke & smoke flavor. Not sure why, maybe the distance to the stack keeps the smoke circulating longer in the CC. The factory therms were not accurate at all, so I replaced both of them. At 180, the bottom rack is at about 115, and the top rack is about 135. So in my opinion this would not work for cold smoking. However it is awful hot outside, so in the winter it may work just fine. At higher temps, the smoke box would work very well as a warmer, and actually am going to try that out today with some ribs & beans. When I use it a bit more, I will write a review on it.
Al
 
  • Like
Reactions: cesarschoice
When I use the top rack, the food is very close to the top too. I think that is where all the smoke is circulating, because I can tell the difference in taste & color between the 2 racks. I also try to put the food close to the stack, thinking that most of the heat & smoke will go around the meat on it’s way out the stack.
Al
Al. I started using the portable rack on top and you are right. Does get better smoke. Thanks buddy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
Well I can’t believe it but it’s been over a year since I went the pellet route. I’ve done about 30-40 cooks on the 1250 & for the most part I’m very happy with it. A few things I learned were:
1 - don’t use recteq ultimate blend pellets, they don’t give much flavor or smoke. I found that I like LJ cherry, and LJ hickory, both 100% pure, no other hardwoods.
2 - use the low smoke setting on most foods for at least 2-3 hours. On many cooks I use the low smoke setting for the whole cook.
3 - RT customer service is top notch, #4 will explain this.
4 - the 1250 cover is a POS, mine cracked & got holes in it in about 6 months, also it is a PIA to put on & take off. Sent RT an email & got a message back the same day that a new cover was on the way, no questions asked. However I found a universal cover that I like better, so I have a brand new RT 1250 cover if I ever need it.
5 - the smoker is a tank, it looks to me like it will last a lifetime. The only thing I don’t know is how long the electronics will last, but if there is a problem I’m pretty sure that RT will keep me smokin. I do know for sure that the controller is spot on & the probes are too!
6 - they say to clean the ash pot every 16 hours, but I just vacuum it out every smoke. I also shake the dust off the pellets before putting them in the hopper, this keeps the dust off the food on a long cook. I know some say to leave the dust in the bottom of the barrel for more insulation, but I vacuum it out too.
7 - put the meat directly on the grate, don’t use a pan. This was hard for me, because I used to pan just about everything. But even just putting a grate on top of a pan restricts the airflow to the meat. I have found that with the extreme smoke setting & putting the meat directly on a grate, you don’t need any auxiliary smoke tubes. A bit more cleanup, but worth it in my book. You also get a bit of added flavor from the grease sizzling on the drip tray, much like an RF plate.
8 - use the top grate if possible, The way the smoker is designed there seems to be more smoke & air flow toward the top.
9- this goes without saying, use foil on the grease pan & grease bucket.
10 - I really like the way they designed the pellet hopper, it is split, so you can put your own blend in there. I use hickory on one side & cherry on the other. I still have some of the RT pellets left so on a long cook I will put some of them on top so toward the end I’m getting rid of them.
11 - when I first got the smoker I used the high setting to see what kind of temp it would put out, and it hit 700 degrees, but I didn’t like the way the smoker reacted. It seemed to be just too hot. So when I need a high heat sear or want to make a pizza, I use the Genesis, or my pizza kettle. 275 is about as high a temp that I run it at & even at that temp, you still get some pretty good TBS.
12 - In the end it is a fantastic smoker & I give it 4 1/2 stars and am very happy to have a pellet pooper as nice as this one!
Hope this will help anyone thinking about going pellet!
Al
Hey Al how’s it going buddy? I just put together the 1100 flagship. Your tips help a lot!!!

What settings do u use for chicken
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
Thanks for the write up! I have an XL 1400 coming in this week. I was gifted a pellet smoker years ago & as soon as I became a dad it became my preferred method at home.

Good point on the pellets. I've been using BBQ Delight & had good results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokinAl
Al. I started using the portable rack on top and you are right. Does get better smoke. Thanks buddy!
You’re welcome Brian, I have OCD, and just have to tinker with things!
Al
Hey Al how’s it going buddy? I just put together the 1100 flagship. Your tips help a lot!!!

What settings do u use for chicken
Hey Brad, good to hear from you.
I have never done any chicken in the R/T that I remember.
I usually do chicken either on the gas grill or the kettle.
I think if I did chicken I would do it on the top rack at 350. Not sure if a smoke tube would work at that temp, but I would try it. No water pan, & I would inject to keep from drying out. Tony C’s works for us.
Al
Great review Al! I feel very much the same about RT and my much older RT700.
Thanks Sandy, it’s hard not to!
Thanks for the write up! I have an XL 1400 coming in this week. I was gifted a pellet smoker years ago & as soon as I became a dad it became my preferred method at home.

Good point on the pellets. I've been using BBQ Delight & had good results.
You’re welcome, & post up some pics of that new rig!
Al
 
Hey Al how’s it going buddy? I just put together the 1100 flagship. Your tips help a lot!!!

What settings do u use for chicken
I thought I would add to Al's response about chicken because I do chicken about once a week in my RT 1250. For boneless/skinless chicken breast I run it at 265 on top shelf for 1 hr 50 to 2 hours cut side up. Whole birds including turkey 335 and I do rotate one or twice just to keep the color even all around. Here are a couple of examples.....
Normal birds
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/classic-whole-roasted-bird.302978/
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/norman-rockwell-birds.313482/
This one is for a smaller bird
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/porter-road-whole-smoke-roasted-chicken.325905/
boneless/skinless
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/smoked-chicken-marsala.324752/
boneless thighs
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/comp-thighs-with-tarragon-white-wine-cream-sauce.320400/
 
I thought I would add to Al's response about chicken because I do chicken about once a week in my RT 1250. For boneless/skinless chicken breast I run it at 265 on top shelf for 1 hr 50 to 2 hours cut side up. Whole birds including turkey 335 and I do rotate one or twice just to keep the color even all around. Here are a couple of examples.....
Normal birds
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/classic-whole-roasted-bird.302978/
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/norman-rockwell-birds.313482/
This one is for a smaller bird
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/porter-road-whole-smoke-roasted-chicken.325905/
boneless/skinless
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/smoked-chicken-marsala.324752/
boneless thighs
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/comp-thighs-with-tarragon-white-wine-cream-sauce.320400/
Thanks, that's good to know. I always struggled on my stick burner with the skin so I definitely want to try chicken in the RT. I didn't even think about using the top shelf but it makes sense that it would get more smoke there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: civilsmoker
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky