The Most Delicious Oxtail Ingredients: Oxtail 1/4 C Stock Salt Pepper 2 TBS Honey 1/4 Chopped Onion 4 Cloves Chopped Garlic Pinch Rosemary Pinch Thyme 1/4 C White Wine 1 Shot Brown Liqure Method: Rub all ingredients (proportions to taste) on the oxtail. Set smoker / grill to 250°F. Cook around 4 ~ 5 hours or until pull apart tender. I ended up wrapping around the 4 hour mark. They were starting to get a little on the dark side. The meat can get very tender, very much like an ultra rich pulled pork with many great levels of flavor.