Spares vs baby back vs St. Louis

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Jloewe

Newbie
Original poster
Jul 31, 2019
9
4
Massachusetts
Looking to smoke some ribs this weekend. New to smoking so need advice. What are the virtues of spares/ St Louis vs baby back? And is it worth it to just buy St. Louis if they’re available in the grocery store? What will I have to do to properly smoke spares? Thanks in advanced!
 
Jloewe Welcome there are many post on how to do ribs you can read. It will all come down to your person taste and preference as to which you like and how you cook them. So that said you will have to try the different types of ribs and the many ways to cook them.

Warren
 
There are so many methods and variations. Each one can give you awesome results. I will say that I buy full spare ribs, cut off the rib tips/brisket cut/whatever-you-want-to-call-it. That gives me St. Louis style ribs, plus the rib tips. Honestly, the rib tips are my favorite part. It's pure pork candy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: creek bottom
I'm a St. Louis snob, they are my favorites and I'll tell ya how I do them.

No need to remove the membrane, it'll basically cook off and it helps hold the racks together and retain more moisture.

Rub them with whatever ya like, no boundaries.

Fire up your grill, 225°-275°, anywhere in that range is good.
I like cherry, apple, hickory and oak for smoke, and often mix woods.

Cook bones down the whole time.

I sometimes spritz or mop, but not always.
I don't wrap, no 321, 311, 221 or anything like that, just bide my time and let'em cook.
I don't glaze unless by special request.
Average time is right about six hours give or take.

I go by the Pop, Bend and Crack test for doneness.
When I see the bones have popped out the end of the meat, and the meat has settled between the bones showing an undulating appearance like corrugated metal siding.
Then I pick the rack up with tongs and if it bends easily and the bark cracks I know they're ready to go.
Generally this method yields me a perfect Light Tug bite.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PorkBones
Looks like you got some great advice above. Since you are pretty new to it my suggestion would be to buy St. Louis cut if its available and not too expensive. Regular spares are going to require quite a bit of trimming to get them into STL style. Back ribs are great too but lately the quality I have seen in the grocery stores has been crap.

At 225ish plan on at least 5 hours for BB's and 6 hours for STL's. If you measure by temp 195 will get you tender with just a little tug 200+ will get you straight fall off the bone.

Good luck!
 
The choice is easy around here, because BabyBacks are way too expensive---ALL of the Time!!

I buy full Pork Spares & Leave them that way, because they are much juicier than if you trim all that awesome meat off into St Louis cut Ribs.

Bear
 
  • Like
Reactions: PorkBones
I buy full Pork Spares & Leave them that way, because they are much juicier than if you trim all that awesome meat off into St Louis cut Ribs.

Bear

Thanks for the tip. I might have to try not trimming sometime. I trim it off because it gives me an awesome bark and caramelization all around the meat, almost like pork burnt ends. I haven't had any issues with juiciness. But you make a good point. I'm smoking some Saturday. Perhaps I'll leave them on and compare the results.
 
All are tasty. I'd go for whichever is on sale. Many ways to make them. Keep trying until you find your favorite.
 
Pork spares straight up or trimmed to St. Louis to me are by far more forgiving than baby backs. My results from cook to cook with babybacks is inconsistent and usually ticks me off lol. Often they are dry for me. The spares are always juicy and tender.

I am going to go away from wrapping on all future smokes too. Great advice from many on here to do so and frankly wrapping 10 racks at a time is a PIA anyway :)
 
I am a Spare and ST. Louis fan, more meaty and juicy. You will have to decide which Rib camp you are in, the fall off the bone or bite off the bone. That will really help you in how to smoke/cook the ribs and if you are doing babies of spares. LOL...just search the forum and you will find 100s of ways, most popular being the 3-2-1 method where you smoke the ribs for 3 hours, then wrap for 2 hours and 1 hour unwrapped.
 
Rub them with whatever ya like, no boundaries.

Uh-oh. What'd I do now! (chuckle).

I'm an untrimmed spare rib guy. They are WAAAAY more forgiving than BBs.

No brane removal, spritzing, or wrapping. Just fire up the smoker, lightly rub my meat, load the smoker when it's spitting blue, and let them babies go, no peeking. Did two full untrimmed racks on Tuesday, 6.5 lbs each. 225F. My wife has been having a rough several months (12-15 hour days) and she likes FOTB and sauced. I let those two beauties go 6 hours, lightly sauced them, dropped the heat to 215F and took them off at 8 hours just before she got home. She loved them.

Interesting thing when you smoke untrimmed spares that long. The cartilage in the rib tips gets REAL soft. I might have gone canine and eaten one or two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Richard Foster
For me the St. Louis cut is the best. I have tried, Loins, Spares, Untrimmed, etc. I lightly dust with my rub and put the ribs in the fridge overnight if possible. I then smoke them at 250F w/o adding more rub until they bend when picked up. I let the ribs rest a couple of minutes, and then apply rub to the meat side before serving. This "Memphis Style" has become my favorite way to serve pork ribs. My rub does not have a ton of salt or sugar in it, so adding a little right rub before serving really brightens the flavors up.
 
They are all good. Buy whatever is on sale!

SPG and hickory for smoke. Never wrapped. Never remove membrane.

Baby backs finish a little quicker than STL-style. And STL-style a little quicker than the full pork spare ribs.
 
As I have said so many times it all comes down to personal preference. If you like your way then that's what you should do and just because you like it that way does not mean its the only and best way.

Warren
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hawging It
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Clicky