Selling a pistol, not so easy...Thoughts

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
I can relate. Selling is not as easy as it once was. I’ve used GB with mixed results. Nothing wrong with the platform, just very difficult people. I won’t sell without an FFL transfer. I use a local shop on consignment. One shop charges a 10% fee of the final sale. Other shop is a little different. I give him my bottom line price and he keeps anything over that price. Since I do consignments with him, he allows the transfer in the store with discounted FFL fee. I know I don’t get top dollar but I’m able to sell along with some peace of mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandyut and chopsaw
PITA for sure. We have both FFL's ready. Its the money transfer that the seller is hung up on. I think its silly, but they dont. I think we have an option next week.
 
I've bought a number of firearms on Gunbroker and unless the seller is local to me in South Florida where I can do a face to face transaction I ONLY buy from a FFL dealer.

The gunshow route or if you have a local online selling route those are the best options.
 
...

So I need to get it to a shop that will relist it on their Gun Broker account so the buyer can buy it again and pay through the shops pay service. Good thing Im not in a hurry. I would walk away from this PITA, but they are willing to pay top dollar. So I'll give it a little extra effort.
USPS money order doesn't have any restriction. Just get your handgun sent to a FFL that will process for a fixed fee (mine in Minnesota was $25). Buyer can inspect purchase and hand dealer a money order properly made out to you. FFL mails you the money order.
edit to complete
After you receive and deposit money order, the FFL can release handgun to purchaser provided they cleared the background check which should be done prior to the MO. That will probably up the fee for the extra handling.
As others have said you can send direct to a FFL less magazines.
 
Last edited:
The buyer pretty much refused all options I provided. They never responded to the last email. DONE with that a** hat. I canceled the sale, requested the final sale credit from GB. For all the fees and crap for the auction, FFL, CC etc. Ill just keep it. If I get motivated again I'll just take the hit on g***(dot)c**. Sold a shotgun to them a while back. Super easy, fair but not generous price. This private sale stuff is a nightmare.
 
Shiesh. Yep, hassle. You might see if there are any local web gun sites in your state. We have "Oklahoma Shooters Association." Lots of good guys there, lots of good shooting information and a lot of other helpful stuff. Kinda a private social group. If close enough, some meet for lunch, shooting events, or just shoot the bull frequently online. You might check your state laws concerning private transfers, but we have been known to meet other members at say a Bass Pro parking lot and after making fully sure they are an instate resident and watching their reaction by asking them if they are legal to own a fire arm, made some private transfers to avoid your examples of hassles. Good Luck To You.
 
Shiesh. Yep, hassle. You might see if there are any local web gun sites in your state. We have "Oklahoma Shooters Association." Lots of good guys there, lots of good shooting information and a lot of other helpful stuff. Kinda a private social group. If close enough, some meet for lunch, shooting events, or just shoot the bull frequently online. You might check your state laws concerning private transfers, but we have been known to meet other members at say a Bass Pro parking lot and after making fully sure they are an instate resident and watching their reaction by asking them if they are legal to own a fire arm, made some private transfers to avoid your examples of hassles. Good Luck To You.
that would be ideal. I did a quick search for a PX4 group and that didnt pan out. Local group would make this all 100X easier. At this point I am just gonna keep it a while longer. I bought is 15 years ago. Today, not worth the hassle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 801driver
that would be ideal. I did a quick search for a PX4 group and that didnt pan out. Local group would make this all 100X easier. At this point I am just gonna keep it a while longer. I bought is 15 years ago. Today, not worth the hassle.
Like, 801, we have Arkansas Gun Traders. Everything from ammo to muzzleloaders and beyond.
Another place to look is local hunting and fishing forum websites. Many of them have buy and sell sub-forums.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandyut
I once sold two shotguns to Bass Pro Shops. They were very fair with me.

Both shotguns (they were in very good condition) fetched 90 cents on the dollar of brand new price.

Shotguns are not a semi-auto handgun...but it's probably worth looking into - phone call at least.
 
I once sold two shotguns to Bass Pro Shops. They were very fair with me.

Both shotguns (they were in very good condition) fetched 90 cents on the dollar of brand new price.

Shotguns are not a semi-auto handgun...but it's probably worth looking into - phone call at least.
I called a few shops, they offered consignment or well below "blue book" where ever they pulled that price. I'll just keep it in my truck as my truck gun and be happy with that.

I'll just go buy what I want anyways. I want a P396 and a Ruger Mark IV 22, one for CCW and the other for cheap fun.
 
I went to Cabela's (nee Pro Bass Shop) a few years ago with a couple rifles. I had a good idea of their worth from scanning other sources and retailers. They offered me less than half of their true value. I passed also.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandyut
I'll just go buy what I want anyways. I want a P396 and a Ruger Mark IV 22, one for CCW and the other for cheap fun.
See what they'll give you for trade in of the one you want to sell . Just know your numbers and what you're willing to do before hand .

I have a Mark IV 22 / 45 with a 4.4" bull barrel .
 
  • Like
Reactions: uncle eddie
See what they'll give you for trade in of the one you want to sell . Just know your numbers and what you're willing to do before hand .

I have a Mark IV 22 / 45 with a 4.4" bull barrel .
Its worth a shot on the trade. nothing to loose.

The Mark IX, nice gun!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 801driver
Its worth a shot on the trade. nothing to loose.
I had that work better than a straight sale to a gun shop . Gives them room on the price of the new purchase , and what they can give on the trade in .

Mines a Mark III . 2008 .
20251211_113631.jpg
20251211_113658.jpg
 
My Mark IV longer barrel is a great plunker for accurate fun shooting. I put a red dot on it at times but it works well with iron sites. It is also a PITA to reassemble after deep cleaning till you get the "hang" of it. U-Tube can be your friend. Ha Ha

Good Luck to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JIMSMOKES
My Mark IV longer barrel is a great plunker for accurate fun shooting. I put a red dot on it at times but it works well with iron sites. It is also a PITA to reassemble after deep cleaning till you get the "hang" of it. U-Tube can be your friend. Ha Ha

Good Luck to you.
First time I took my mark1 apart. I thought I was gonna have to take it to my gunsmith to get it back together. LoL
 
Woooh, Egg on my face. Guess sometimes you need to read the fine print on the barrel. Mine is a Mark III, Stainless "real metal" Target model that is like previous versions I and II with the tedious cleaning and re-assembly by using a paper clip for disassembly and then while holding your left foot up and pointing the firearm to the floor and then to the ceiling while incrimently fitting in a big pin, it slides right back together ready to go. That quirk was fixed with the Mark IV. There used to be a kit for the Mark I, II, and III for about $70 that made the re-assembly like the Mark IV easy. I had gotten pretty good with holding my left foot in the air to make it work so it was not worth it to me. Ha Now just shoot a couple thousand rounds with a little oil spray down few places and a bore snake once in a while in between and then disassemble for a real cleaning when I have nothing else to do. Like with my 1911, mine seems to run better a little dirty.

My Ruger Mark III is my "go to" fun plinker for shooting targets or shootings cans dancing out as far as I can hit them as soon as they stop moving. I am old and can no longer hit them reliably in the air with a second shot. I live out in the country and can safely do that in at least two directions.

Best things I like about Ruger III is first it has the same grip angle as my 1911 (Glocks and others are different) and it has the same safety direction as my 1911. (many pistols are different.} Up for safe, down to fire. It will not slow me down if I should want to use it in a holster out in the woods or something and have a surprise.

Just as your (OP Plans) Sig P365 should be if you plan on it being an EDC firearm if you decide to carry condition one like I do with my EDC Colt 1911 I carry only if I have pants on like now at 4AM sitting here typing. I practice thumb push down during the draw so it does not slow me down, putting my thumb in the right position to fire. Ruger III safety is smaller, so I have to work with it. #2 My Mark III just has a good solid steel feel, holds steady with little recoil for a second shot. And with a thick barrel, accuracy that does not vairy with temp in fairly rapid firing with cheap .22 cartridges that I have not found with other .22 pistols.

Myself I am not a fan of Ambi safetys. Daily carried a Colt 1911 left side only safety for over 15 years, never found it off. I got a flashy Ruger SR1911 polished stainless with an ambi safety. Tried carrying it like my old Colt 1911 for a week. Ambi got clicked off twice with two different causes. Never again, it was not acceptable with my lifestyle. It is now used for my BBQ flash firearm. (Rosewood grips with polished stainless is outstanding to view.) Out of the safe to the event, back in the safe afterward before going to bed. Part of the long story, not for here. If you want more of my story and opinion PM me.

Enjoy all the information and opinions posted and your new firearms as you acquire them and report back. You have given several of us things to think about and post. I now have to wonder what condition would my 1908 JMB Colt .380 hammerless (Colt varified it was called their 1903 model in a .380 at that time) would be if it had been made in plastic. Prob less scratches than it now has. ha I also have to wonder what FFL method was used to transfer it from an original hardware store in TX who bought a shipment of 25 of them from Colt in 1923 was used for me to purchase it legally instate in OK a few years back. I guess if it got stolen from me and used in a crime that information could be important. Right?

We had previously frozen (boat sliced) lazy pamento cheese stuffed bacon wrapped jalipelno peppers and chicken quarters on the grill, smoked a little with pecan twigs off my tree from last years wind storm I saved. They were great. I prob should post my little trick of how to keep the cheese from flowing out the end of the boat peppers for newbies who might have that problem the first time they try doing it.

Good luck to you with your firearms purchases, and to your next brisket or pork butt smoke.
 
Last edited:
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky