Your a Man's man, John. Shad Roe is way too strong a flavor for my taste. I have enjoyed Aged Goat Cheeses that the smell could knock you over but Shad Roe is just too Fishy foe me...JJ
That's because nobody taught you how to prepare a set of Shad Roe:
You don't have to be a "Man's Man"---My brother & both of My Sisters love Shad Roe too, as does my Son.
Many Restaurants serve Shad Roe when in season, and the restaurants don't smell any more fishy than when they broil any other fish.
There's a Restaurant near here (The Sorrel Horse) that used to have a "Prime Rib" Special Night, and a "Shad Roe" Special Night, and the place got just as packed when they had Shad Roe as when they had Prime Rib. People would come from all over for their Shad Roe, after their Shad Roe was featured in a "Fine Dining" magazine.
If you would just look closer at my Step by Steps on "Shad Roe", you would know how to remedy the strength of the flavor & smell of Shad Roe. All I do is soak them in cold Salt Water for a few hours to over night. Then soak them in fresh cold water for awhile to get rid of the salt. The soaking in salt water draws the blood out of the Shad Roe. It is the blood in the Roe that bothers you, because you don't do this.
If you had Shad Roe at my house you would know what I mean, You'd love it, but the chances of that are slim, because due to the cost of Shad Roe, I can't even find any these last couple years. They have gotten so expensive, due to so many people loving them, that my stores "Giant" and "Weis" don't even carry them any more.
Eight years ago I got 25 sets from a Wholesaler near Lansdale for $7.50 a set.
Then a couple years later I paid $10 a set for 8 sets at Giant.
Since that I looked for them every Spring, and when I asked the fish guy, he said he didn't think they were gonna get any, and if they did, they would be at least $15 per set.
So seeing how I don't fish any more, I believe my Shad Roe enjoyment days are over.
Here's how to make them right, to anyone who can find any & wants to try them:
Shad Roe (Pan Fried)
Shad Roe (Broiled with Bacon on Toast)
Shad Roe (Pan Fried Loose with Bacon)
Shad Roe (Cured & Pan Fried Loose)
Bear