Salt Potatoes~

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

pops6927

Gone but not forgotten. RIP
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jul 23, 2008
7,245
1,225
Fort Worth, Tx.
From our NNY upbringing for a summertime favorite is Salt Potatoes.  These were started in Syracuse, NY by the Hinerwadel family; http://www.hinerwadelsinc.com/about.nxg.  Small white potatoes (1-1.5" diameter) that come in a bag with a pound of salt; if I remember correctly it's 4 lbs. of potatoes and 1 lb. of salt, total of 5 lbs.  Boil a large pan of water with the salt added, drop in the potatoes until tender, drain and enjoy with lots of butter!  These are served at family get-togethers, fairs, Firemen's Field Days, the NY State Fair, any place there's a gathering, you'll find salt potatoes in Northern NY!

Here in Texas they never heard of them.  But, there's been a resurgence of small white and red potatoes for summertime cooking, so just by adding salt to the water you can create your own.  A telltale sign that they've turned out correctly is a white coating of salt on the potatoes once drained!

We always added only half the salt; now, what with health conditions and all, we use ¼ lb. of sea salt to 4 or 5 lbs. of small red or white potatoes; they are still delicious as a great side dish and don't let me get seconds, lol!  Boil 'em up and split them in half and slather on some butter (or a lo-cal margarine subtitute) and you've got a summertime favorite from a local enterprise! 
 
Did not know it was anything special but thats the way I have cooked red potatoes all of my adult life just not with a lb of salt. Interesting !!
 
Thanks for the memories Pops..

When I was stationed at Griffiss I used to make a few extra bucks working clam bakes over at Sylvan Beach.

Made plenty of salt potatoes...

  Craig
 
Sounds great Pops!

Why didn't you tell me about it years ago, when I didn't have to stay away from too much salt?!?!  
biggrin.gif


Funny it didn't get down here to SE PA, and the PA Dutch. I never heard of it.

Bear
 
What was the shape of these potatoes? Cut or uncut?

We're seeing these more ob-longed shape, about the length of your thumb potatoes lately. Kinda expensive, but oh so very good.
 
Last edited:
What was the shape of these potatoes? Cut or uncut?

We're seeing these more ob-longed shape, about the length of your thumb potatoes lately. Kinda expensive, but oh so very good.
Flash-sounds like fingerling potatoes-new potatoes are round/oval in shape. When doing salt taters, drop the taters in whole once the water starts boiling. Cut them in half when they are done and drained.

My Sis-in-law gave me a potatoe salad recipe that called fingerling potatoes and I dang near choked when I saw the price of them in the produce dept. Think I'll just stick to the white, reds and russetts for tater salad making so my sis-in-law can have at those fingerling taters.
 
 
Last edited:
Leave it to Pops to come up with one I have never heard of.  I can't wait to try this one.  I'm thinking little red new potatoes.

Good luck and good smoking.
 
I love me some salt potatoes. I had some co-workers from Syracuse that turned me onto them. I thought they were crazy until I tased them
 
Salt potatoes are a CNY thing for sure. I grew up across the street from Hinerwadel  's in the late 50's and 60's.

I've had to take a 100 pound to Mass. for my brother wedding in the 80's  cause the carterer never heard of them, and many loads to florida for friends over the years.

Pop's has got the recipe right 4 pounds of small white taters and a 1 pound bag of salt. Ya can't beat them!!! ( although we go with a half a bag of salt  now)
 
Last edited:
I fortunatly have bee enjoying them for the last 24yrs. My wife is from ohio and  she makes them about once a month. They are awesome with butter. I can just eat them for a meal.. thanks pops

Joe
 
What was the shape of these potatoes? Cut or uncut?



We're seeing these more ob-longed shape, about the length of your thumb potatoes lately. Kinda expensive, but oh so very good.

These are round "new potatoes". Hinnerwaddels is the most prevailent around CNY, but there are a couple other brands on the market, and white or red new potatoes are equally popular.

One other tidbit about salt potatoes... leftovers chopped up with some onion make the best home-fries for breakfast the next morning!!!!!!

Pops... one other local treat that folks who have moved away often have shipped to their homes is Hoffmann's german brand franks and snappy grillers ("coneys"). A little stand in Liverpool, just outside Syracuse, called Heid's is THE place to go for a dog.
 
I know Billy Bob Thorton in Slingblade sure liked them there taters......mmmmmmm                I will be adding that to my next menu.....  
pot.gif
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky