My first smoked pork tenderloin

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

bgaviator

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
May 9, 2010
418
426
Hello, though I would share the results of my first ever smoked pork tenderloin. Second time I've smoked anything really!
I brushed both with pure maple syrup and put a good amount of store bought rub on them. I wasn't sure how much rub was enough since it's my first time and all.
I then got the KJ up to 250. I wasn't sure how much wood to use, and I noticed the hickory wood chunks I bought earlier that day were quite small. So I used two small chunks of hickory and one apple chunk. The apple chunk was a huge piece though.
At 120 itt I brushed one of the tenderloins with a peach glaze I made by combining peach preserves, honey, brown sugar, and lemon juice.
The other tenderloin I decided to leave as-is, with just the rub. The tenderloin I brushed with the thick glaze I noticed removed some of the rub on that piece.
I pulled the pork at 145 itt. Brought them inside and loosely covered with foil on a sheet pan and let them rest for 30 minutes before I sliced.
My wife and I agreed that we both enjoyed the peach glazed one much better. My wife doesn't even like peach that much and she loved how the glaze tasted with the pork. We also both agreed though that the meat was too potent with smoke flavor. I'm not sure if using hickory did it, or I used too many chunks all together? I'm surprised how much smoke they took since they only cooked in just over an hours time.
I'm also not sure how much I liked the look/texture of the pork at 145 itt. I know it's technically safe, but it just looked a little too raw still. I think next time I do it I might pull it at 10'degrees higher.
Overall the meat was really good and I'm pretty proud of myself for my first real smoking session. Next time I think I need to cut back on the amount of wood, or just use apple wood only. And next time for personal preference go to 155 itt. I appreciate any suggestions. Thanks.
 
It sure looks good from here.

Are you sure of the final IT, it looks a little pink for 145.

After a rest it should have been 150+, which really isn't very pink.

I pull mine at 138, and after a 30 minute rest they are about 145.

And they don't look as pink as yours.

I would check your therm in boiling water & make sure it reads 212 or close to it.

Al
 
I checked both of them with a Thermoworks DOT thermometer. They are supposed to be very accurate. I've only used the probe one other cook. I certainly hope it's working for being a brand new probe! I checked it in multiple places too. I got at least a 142 reading or higher.
 
Hello bgaviator,

Looks great!

Al's advice on verifying the accuracy of your probe in boiling water is spot on.  It is a good practice to do this with every new cooking thermometer rather than assuming they are accurately calibrated right out of the box.

Your comments about the tenderloins being over smoked:  pork tenderloins are rather more delicate cuts of meat than other pork cuts, and its fairly easy to over smoke them.  I don't know anything about your smoker, or how you set the dampers for air flow, but those are things that might help us advise you on future smokes.  You'll dial in the correct amount of smoke as you learn your pit, with a little trial and error

Red
 
I have a Kamado Joe Classic. I used a BBQ Guru Party Q to help control the temp. I had the top daisy wheel only about 1/3 open.
 
Checked the temp probe in boiling water. 212. Perfect.
 
I have a Kamado Joe Classic. I used a BBQ Guru Party Q to help control the temp. I had the top daisy wheel only about 1/3 open.
Open the top vent all the way,the smoke needs to pass by the meat.They do look a little to pink for that temp,the juice on the cutting board seems to be quite a lot.Are the Tenderloins pre marinated?

Richie
 
No they were not. I put quite a bit of rub on them, which is reddish in color. I dunno, I temp checked them in a few places, so I'm not sure why they wouldn't have gotten cooked properly.
 
I have a Kamado Joe Classic. I used a BBQ Guru Party Q to help control the temp. I had the top daisy wheel only about 1/3 open.
 
Open the top vent all the way,the smoke needs to pass by the meat.

Richie
Agree 100% with Richie...the top vent should always be full open to allow good air flow.  The smoke should only gently kiss the meat as it passes through the smoker.

Red
 
No they were not. I put quite a bit of rub on them, which is reddish in color. I dunno, I temp checked them in a few places, so I'm not sure why they wouldn't have gotten cooked properly.
Okay the heavy rub could hold the juice in 

Richie
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky