Decision crisis - smoker or weber kettle?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

mikeatrpi

Newbie
Original poster
Jul 2, 2014
10
10
I have a slightly modded masterbuilt Brinkmann clone smoker, but I have a lot of trouble maintaining stable temps.  I just got a weber kettle, so I was thinking of smoking on that.  I've done a few smaller smokes on my old smokey joe silver, so I'm familiar with the compromises of smoking on a grill.  What do the experts say - kettle or masterbuilt?  I'm smoking two small-ish butts for the Fourth.  
 

mikeatrpi

Newbie
Original poster
Thread starter
Jul 2, 2014
10
10
Awesome, thanks for talking me off the ledge!  Can't wait to get it going on Monday!
 

mikeatrpi

Newbie
Original poster
Thread starter
Jul 2, 2014
10
10
Holey SMOKES this was my best TWO ever!  I paid an arm and a leg, $3.19 lb, for boneless butts from from upscale grocer, and took home two - 4.75 and 4.78 lbs.  I tell ya what, it was worth it!  On at 6:30 this morning, snake method, hickory chips and apple chunks.  I used 50/50 brown sugar / white sugar, plus salt, pepper, and chipolte powder rub overnight.  At 5 hours in I stuck in the probe - 138 degrees.  HUH????  With the snake I was holding a solid 250 degrees till then.  Getting worried, I threw on some more charcoal and opened the vents, and got it up to 350 pretty quickly.  Once we got to 175 I threw both butts into a foil pan, covered them tightly, and put em back in till we hit 203 degrees.  I pulled them off 8 hours and 1 minute in.  They rested in the foam cooler with blankets for an hour, then I shredded them with claws.

Let me say - the BEST, the BEST I've ever done. The meat was soft, tender, flavorful, and the crust was amazing!  There was half a sandwich baggie left, and I think that's because people don't want to take the scraps from the pan.  Every year we do a party on the fourth, and I tell my wife and guests burgers and dogs are not BBQ - so I insist on smoking some pork.  Every year they rave about the it, but this year - hot dog, this was some good stuff.  I had several guests go out of their way to compliment it!

What would I do differently next time?  Maybe start a little earlier, and or run it a little bit hotter.  I did the snake 2 wide by 2 tall... maybe go three tall next time.  I bet if I did 275 all day long instead of 250, I wouldn't have had the 350 degree freakout.  

Never the less....  Hot dang that was some good 'cue.  Man.  Thanks again boys, I appreciate the advice!
 

Latest posts

Hot Threads

  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.