Country Short Ribs... Terrible smoke flavor..

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

daveomak

SMF Hall of Fame Pitmaster
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Nov 12, 2010
27,123
4,982
Omak,Washington,U.S.A.
Picked up some CSR's and decided to use the MES to smoke them.

We have cooked them many times before on the gas grill and also broiled them (during the winter). They have always turned out good.

Our method is to brine overnight with lots of spices in the brine. Then cook.

I did the same brine routine this time.

They were put in the smoker at 120 w/o smoke for 1 hour. Smoke applied as the temp rose to 156 internal temp. Foil wrapped and continued to 170 I.T.

The CSR's were tender and the spices were a good flavor. The bitter smoke flavor was almost inedible.

I am thinking brining allowed too much moisture to rise to the meat surface during the heating process and condense too much smoke.

I have done pork butt, buckboard bacon, brisket and strami. Never had this soured smoke flavor. Never put them in a brine either. Always a dry rub.

I believe all other things were equal except for the brine.

Should I have NOT brined the meat? Used only a dry rub? Is that my problem?

 BTW there was no smoke ring in the meat.
 
What you describe sounds like creosote. Did you have periods of billowing white smoke? The MES has a tendency to burn the chips all at once & produce too much smoke, that's why a lot of the guys use Todd's AMNS. The other thing is you won't get a smoke ring with an electric smoker.
 
Al, Morning. Boy, wish I know what changed. I used 1/2 cup of chips and they took 2 hrs to smolder. Typical of what has happened before. I am hoping they will be better today after a 24 hr rest.

I may try reheating them on the  
AR15firing.gif
    "gas grill" and see what happens.
 
I never Brine, but that shouldn't have anything to do with it.

I agree with Al----Very strange!

Bear
 
My first though was as Al said...never brine red meat only fish and poultry sometimes....
 
Last edited:
Africanmeat posted an article on wood for smoking.

Maybe, just maybe I reached into the wrong bag. I have hickory, mesquite and alder in bags in a box. If I grabbed the mesquite for a second time instead of the hickory, that could be it. I originally put about 1 tbls mesquite in and was going to finish with hickory.

Mesquite has a strong earthy flavor. It is great wood for smoking beef, fish, chicken, and game. Mesquite is one of the hottest burning woods. Some people insist that too much mesquite smoke can be a bad thing. I've heard that smoking with mesquite for too long can create a bitter flavor.


Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/6263037
 
I have seen CSR meaning country style ribs...meaning pork.

Beef short ribs that I know are flat type slabs.

Never tried smoking them as most short rib recipes call for braising and then a long low temp cook ina liquid.

I use something close to this... http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Simple-Beef-Short-Ribs/Detail.aspx  

Craig

  And BTW....
th_What_NO_QVIEW.gif
 
Last edited:
I never use Mesquite. Hickory, Pecan and sometimes the two mixed with some Apple...It may be the Mesquite that did it.
 
So far I have never used Mesquite.

Hickory is strong & I love it right the way it is.

Everyone says how strong Mesquite is, so I'm kinda shy on it.

So that could have been your problem, like Roller said.

That would explain why I can't think of any other reason.

I guess I'm a Chicken/Bear on the Mesquite.

Bear
 
I have used mesquite before with no issues. I was surprised you held off smoking until you were closing in on 156º internal. Most meats do not accept smoke once past 140º internal. Still you could get external smoke though. I would have to side with those that stated too much smoke. Can weigh in on the bringing, as I never do this.
 
Last edited:
I don't have much to offer.  However, I smoked some pork spares around Christmas time for my fiance's parents.  Everybody loved 'em except me.  I could taste something bitter.  I thought it might have been creosote.  (I did put the meat on a little early, before the white smoke died down.)  Also, I thought it might have had something to do with the outdoor temperature.  It was my first and only smoke it the winter time, and it was quite cold outside.  I was able to keep the smoker around 225 though.

I am certain that I did use hickory and mesquite.  It is possible that I used a few hunks of mesquite.  So maybe I experienced mesquite overload???

I'm glad I saw this thread.  Gonna' pay more attention to what I'm doing when adding the wood chunks to the coals from now on.

P.S. - love the quote Flash.
 
Last edited:
This ones got me stumped!

Was it bitter like tingly feeling on your tongue (like sticking your tongue on a 9 volt battery) or was it sour, huge difference in my opinion.

What was in your brine, what other spices did you use?

Did the CSR's have any off smell to them?

It doesn't sound like creosote by your explanation, but its hard to say without more information.
 
This ones got me stumped!

Was it bitter like tingly feeling on your tongue (like sticking your tongue on a 9 volt battery) or was it sour, huge difference in my opinion.

What was in your brine, what other spices did you use?

Did the CSR's have any off smell to them?

It doesn't sound like creosote by your explanation, but its hard to say without more information.
Glad I'm not the only old guy to test 9V batteries that way!

Bear
 
I have used mesquite before with no issues. I was surprised you held off smoking until you were closing in on 156º internal. Most meats do not accept smoke once past 140º internal. Still you could get external smoke though. I would have to side with those that stated too much smoke. Can weigh in on the bringing, as I never do this.
Flash, Started smoke at 120 then quit at 156. Maybe the CSR's were still too cold from the refer/brine ???

 
I don't have much to offer.  However, I smoked some pork spares around Christmas time for my fiance's parents.  Everybody loved 'em except me.  I could taste something bitter.  I thought it might have been creosote.  (I did put the meat on a little early, before the white smoke died down.)  Also, I thought it might have had something to do with the outdoor temperature.  It was my first and only smoke it the winter time, and it was quite cold outside.  I was able to keep the smoker around 225 though.

I am certain that I did use hickory and mesquite.  It is possible that I used a few hunks of mesquite.  So maybe I experienced mesquite overload???

I'm glad I saw this thread.  Gonna' pay more attention to what I'm doing when adding the wood chunks to the coals from now on.

P.S. - love the quote Flash.
My87, I think it was mesquite overload. I had a brain f*rt when putting chips in I do believe ???

 
This ones got me stumped!

Was it bitter like tingly feeling on your tongue (like sticking your tongue on a 9 volt battery) or was it sour, huge difference in my opinion.

What was in your brine, what other spices did you use?

Did the CSR's have any off smell to them?

It doesn't sound like creosote by your explanation, but its hard to say without more information.
SQWIB, I think the taste was WWWOOOWWW !!    I did not expect that !!  I think it was too much mesquite. After a few days in the fridge, the taste mellowed. Still too strong though. Covered in Sweeet Baby Rays and chowed down.

Spices were garlic, onion, chipotle, cayene, B pepper, etc.
 
Sounds like you grabbed to much mesquite. 
meateater, I think you are spot on. I do to, the more I think about it.  I really like the zing mesquite adds to the flavor of the smoke. Normally I just add a tablespoon or so. It adds a "what is that flavor" mystery to the food and I like it.

I think the magic formula when cooking CSR's is not having CRS disease. (can't remember sh*t)
 
Last edited:
Hi Dave i have read this post with interest and have one question. The wood you used wasn't green was it? What i mean was it properly dried before you smoked with it? Once i smoked some venison with green wood and it was so bitter tasting i had to throw it out. A lesson i never forgot.
icon14.gif
 
Hi Dave i have read this post with interest and have one question. The wood you used wasn't green was it? What i mean was it properly dried before you smoked with it? Once i smoked some venison with green wood and it was so bitter tasting i had to throw it out. A lesson i never forgot.
icon14.gif
Hmmmmm, good thought!

Any chance of that Dave?

Bear
 
Hi Dave i have read this post with interest and have one question. The wood you used wasn't green was it? What i mean was it properly dried before you smoked with it? Once i smoked some venison with green wood and it was so bitter tasting i had to throw it out. A lesson i never forgot.
icon14.gif
Hmmmmm, good thought!

Any chance of that Dave?

Bear
The chips were the ones W-Mart sells. Had them for a few months and they are stored in an air tight container.

I don't think so?? I do not soak my chips either. I'm convinced  I put Mesquite in the pan when I should have put in hickory or alder. Just an old man with CRS disease.
 
 
LOL---I guess we shouldn't mix our CRS with our CSRs, but at least that shouldn't make us DOA.

Bear
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky