Bagel wrapped hot dog

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Fueling Around

Smoking Guru
Original poster
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Dec 10, 2018
6,757
5,365
So Lake Cty, FL
Years ago Costco had Dr Stein's Bagel Dogs. They disappeared.
Since then found Nathen's Bagel Dogs in the freezer, but just not the same.

I've been making my own version for years with Costco dinner franks cut in half {or sometimes whole) depending on the eater preference.
The dinner franks come in a 14 pack and 7 either whole or cut in half fit my sheet pan to bake for a batch.

I use the King Arthur recipe for making bagels.
I augment by using 100 grams of sour dough discard which replaces 50 grams of flour and 50 grams of water and reduce the salt to 1/4 of the recipe. The salt in the hot dogs contributes a lot of salt.

I fast forward though the dough making.
After the first proof, I divide into 6-7 equal balls of dough for second proof.
dough-1.png

Each ball gets rolled out to a 14" slab and cut in half.

dough-2.png

Wrap a dog in the dough making sure to full envelope the meat.
Stretch the dough as you wrap the meat. Cut off any excess dough
dough-3.png

Boil in small batches for 2-3 minutes.
Sorry didn;t realize the photo wasn't focused. Call it steam off the pot?
dough-4.png

Place on a sheet pan covered with parchment paper and bake for around 25 minutes until the dough is browned.
Move to cooling racks.
dog-1.png

This is a typical batch. The dough may separate at the ends. My rolling and wrapping skills suck.

Where did the bagels come from?
Remember I said to stretch the dough and cut the excess?
I usually get 2 bagels from excess dough

I've been making these for 7-8 years. A typical year is 3 packages of franks or 84 dogs.
I give away most of them and never a complaint of quality
 
I like it . I've heard about the Costco dinner franks , but never had one . I get a No. 5 all beef from GFS that we like .
I was doing a pretzel wrapped polish sausage . I do a full wrap , but have seen the strip method .
I'll have to try that next time .
Nice write up and those .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fueling Around
HECK YEAH. I'd eat 3 right now. We're hot dog fools here. The thought of fresh made sourdough bagel wrapped around a dog?! DANG. I cannot remember the name of it but there is a german sausage that is baked in a bun. I think they add ketchup on the inside too.

Agree with you John, your wrapping sucks. :emoji_laughing: I had to go looking for a solution. Some folks make the center of the "rope" a little thicker to make them plump.

 
Nice work! We have a local maverick (a c-store but not a c-store cause it’s maverick) that sells a version of those…..the sausage wrap! I never complain as I consume them either……lol!!

Those are awesome!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fueling Around
Thanks everyone. Been meaning to do a write up for years.
Forgot to mention each serving is around 60¢ including the 1/2 hot dog, dough, and baking.

Man... They look good... Nice job John III ..

Myself, I don't do hot dogs unless they are homemade and I know what's in them...
That's been my goal for a number of years. Until that time the Costco frank will suffice.

Love this idea, I can see many different fillers with that dough.
And you say you give away most , see address below, as I know I could wolf down a few of those.

Can I use reg SD or is discard better.

David
You can use active SD or discard. The added yeast does all the leavening.
I starve my starter so it gets extra sour and just adds flavor.

Drop me a message next time you come to Florida. We can meet up at Old Town or somewhere and I'll bring a batch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DRKsmoking
Not sure how you go back north , but if you come through St. Louis up 55 , Gus's pretzels is right off 55 at the Arsenal exit . West of AB . They do the sausages , and deli sandwiches on a twisted pretzel . Call ahead , and grab a bag of pretzels and a couple sausage wraps for the road .
Old time store on the corner in a neighborhood .

 
You can use active SD or discard. The added yeast does all the leavening.
I starve my starter so it gets extra sour and just adds flavor.

Drop me a message next time you come to Florida. We can meet up at Old Town or somewhere and I'll bring a batch.

That is good to know as I can see hotdogs ( that in my mine are the most convenient food there is ) and sausages being in my future with this.

As for the next Florida trip , yes that would be great. I will plan that into the trip. But as of right now , not sure when that will be.

but really love the offer.

David
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fueling Around
HECK YEAH. I'd eat 3 right now. We're hot dog fools here. The thought of fresh made sourdough bagel wrapped around a dog?! DANG. I cannot remember the name of it but there is a german sausage that is baked in a bun. I think they add ketchup on the inside too.

Agree with you John, your wrapping sucks. :emoji_laughing: I had to go looking for a solution. Some folks make the center of the "rope" a little thicker to make them plump.
I suppose they could be left on the counter to proof for an hour or so to make it more bun like.
I love the crisp texture of the bagel crust.

I use my hot dog sauce on them. 1/2 mustard and 1/2 ketchup.
 
Once in awhile I buy the mini wrapped dogs from Aunt Annie’s in the malls. I’d be all over yours in a flash
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fueling Around
Not sure how you go back north , but if you come through St. Louis up 55 , Gus's pretzels is right off 55 at the Arsenal exit .
...
That looks like a fun place to visit.
I am not a pretzel fan.
We avoid StL and any large metro areas.
 
We avoid StL and any large metro areas.
I get it . I'm 40 minutes west of St.louis . Never go down there since I retired .
That's just a older southside neighborhood . You can smell the hops and barley cooking .
It's a shame really . Some great shops and good eats down there .
Looked up their menu, Wish there was on around here .
Heck you'd have no trouble making your own .
Take a shot at it next time you bake bread .
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DRKsmoking
Those look great, John!

First bagel dog I ever had came off the Schwan's home delivery trucks. A co-worker, years ago suggested I try them, and man were they good!

They were more of a cheesy sausage. I know a hotdog is a type of sausage, but these weren't quite like a traditional hotdog, probably closer to a Johnsonville beddar cheddar sausage wrapped in a bagel like dough and were awesome.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Fueling Around
Thanks Doug
Those look great, John!

First bagel dog I ever had came off the Schwan's home delivery trucks. A co-worker, years ago suggested I try them, and man were they good!

They were more of a cheesy sausage. I know a hotdog is a type of sausage, but these weren't quite like a traditional hotdog, probably closer to a Johnsonville beddar cheddar sausage wrapped in a bagel like dough and were awesome.

That sounds really good, too. Never a Schwan's shopper myself.
I tried making them with my loaded breakfast brats (breakfast sausage, cheese, and egg stuffed in hog casing) and the fat out ruined the dough. I need to remake my breakfast sausage specifically for wrapping in dough
 
  • Like
Reactions: DougE
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky