• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

I give up

joshs

Smoke Blower
77
11
Joined Aug 4, 2008
Tried it last year nothing. I tryed to make starter with water and flower, nothing. I tryed with yeast, nothing. The one with yeast wouldn't even rise. What the heck. The yeast might have been old. I put it together the yeast one started to rise. then it went flat. Guess I will have to stick to buying mine.     
 

justpassingthru

Smoking Fanatic
OTBS Member
950
23
Joined Feb 7, 2009
Hey Josh,

Slow down and take a deep breath..., now tell us what recipe you are using, what kind of bread are you trying to  make?

What temperature is the water you are adding to the yeast, too cold and it won't grow, too hot and you will kill it, I use my Thermapen to determine water temperature and I use water at 115° for bread making.

We need more info, I'm just a novice, but there are some very good bread makers here that can help you.

Gene
 
Last edited:

boykjo

Sausage maker
Staff member
Moderator
OTBS Member
Group Lead
7,122
553
Joined Apr 28, 2010
Hey josh, as gene said hang in there. Maybe I'll learn something too here............
 

i is a moose

Smoking Fanatic
357
14
Joined Feb 14, 2011
X2!

Solutions require details!

For sourdough:

Visit Sourdoughhome.com, and learn some fun tips. I've been working with starter for the past nine years and learned stuff from that guy!

For conventional yeat breads:

Gene's hit the nail on the head! Water temp is always the first killer of breads in the making. The second is time. If the yeast is old, they won't rise, if your slurry's too young, you'll have a difficult time getting the rise needed, and if the slurry or sponge has been around for too long, then you have geriatric yeast.

Ambient temps are key too, hot weather will encourage a quick initial rise, but the yeast will eat themselves out of house and home before you develop enough flavor and gluten, colder days will require more rise-time.

How much yeast is being used, and what kind of yeast? Baker's yeast is a live culture, and has the shortest lifespan, active-dry takes the longest to revive from "cryo-sleep"; instant is the best place to start, because they will revive in minutes. For beginners, the best yeast says "for bread-machines" on the label, because they're instant yeast cultures in smaller pellets, which means they rise the fastest.

How much salt are you using? Too much salk will kill off major populations of your yeast, too little, and they will grow exponentially, uncontrolled until the dough takes over your kitchen, and they devour themselves out of a food supply.

Are you adding sugar to the warm water? Always add a bit of sugar to your yeast, and a bit of flour, they need something to eat when they revive: breakfast is the most important meal of the day!

Finally, make sure you get at least three proofs:

1. the yeast stirred into the warm water/sugar/flour slurry.

2. the first proof after mixing

3. bench proofing after kneading and before baking.

I usually get about 6 proofs out of a batch of dough, but three is the minumum to a solid texture.

Another neat trick is that I mix about 1 teaspoon of yeast per batch of dough into the flour, that way you get a second culture acting as reinforcements, it works especially well if you're in a hurry, or, if you're like me, and ferment the sponge overnight in the fridge.

Good Luck, and "Never give up, never surrender!"

 
Hey Josh,

Slow down and take a deep breath..., now tell us what recipe you are using, what kind of bread are you trying to  make?

What temperature is the water you are adding to the yeast, too cold and it won't grow, too hot and you will kill it, I use my Thermapen to determine water temperature and I use water at 115° for bread making.

We need more info, I'm just a novice, but there are some very good bread makers here that can help you.

Gene
 

alblancher

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Group Lead
4,166
62
Joined Mar 6, 2009
I is a Moose

Hope you don't mind, I saved your tips for reference.  Good post, thanks

Al 
 

bassman

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
4,322
53
Joined Dec 15, 2007
Don't give up yet, Josh.  I can send you another starter if you'd like.  Once you get the hang of it, you won't be sorry.  Let me know if you want to try mine again as I have some dried and ready to go.
 

malisaw

Fire Starter
59
10
Joined Jan 13, 2011
You can get a free sourdough starter that began life in 1847 on the Oregan Trail and is still going strong.  All you have to do is send them a self addressed stamped envelope:

http://carlsfriends.net/

It comes with instructions on how to activate it, etc.
 
Last edited:

bakerboy7

Smoke Blower
111
12
Joined Jan 10, 2011
I couldn't have said it better myself.
X2!

Solutions require details!

For sourdough:

Visit Sourdoughhome.com, and learn some fun tips. I've been working with starter for the past nine years and learned stuff from that guy!

For conventional yeat breads:

Gene's hit the nail on the head! Water temp is always the first killer of breads in the making. The second is time. If the yeast is old, they won't rise, if your slurry's too young, you'll have a difficult time getting the rise needed, and if the slurry or sponge has been around for too long, then you have geriatric yeast.

Ambient temps are key too, hot weather will encourage a quick initial rise, but the yeast will eat themselves out of house and home before you develop enough flavor and gluten, colder days will require more rise-time.

How much yeast is being used, and what kind of yeast? Baker's yeast is a live culture, and has the shortest lifespan, active-dry takes the longest to revive from "cryo-sleep"; instant is the best place to start, because they will revive in minutes. For beginners, the best yeast says "for bread-machines" on the label, because they're instant yeast cultures in smaller pellets, which means they rise the fastest.

How much salt are you using? Too much salk will kill off major populations of your yeast, too little, and they will grow exponentially, uncontrolled until the dough takes over your kitchen, and they devour themselves out of a food supply.

Are you adding sugar to the warm water? Always add a bit of sugar to your yeast, and a bit of flour, they need something to eat when they revive: breakfast is the most important meal of the day!

Finally, make sure you get at least three proofs:

1. the yeast stirred into the warm water/sugar/flour slurry.

2. the first proof after mixing

3. bench proofing after kneading and before baking.

I usually get about 6 proofs out of a batch of dough, but three is the minumum to a solid texture.

Another neat trick is that I mix about 1 teaspoon of yeast per batch of dough into the flour, that way you get a second culture acting as reinforcements, it works especially well if you're in a hurry, or, if you're like me, and ferment the sponge overnight in the fridge.

Good Luck, and "Never give up, never surrender!"

 
 

scarbelly

Epic Pitmaster
OTBS Member
14,319
71
Joined Jul 26, 2009
You can get a free sourdough starter that began life in 1847 on the Oregan Trail and is still going strong.  All you have to do is send them a self addressed stamped envelope:

http://carlsfriends.net/

It comes with instructions on how to activate it, etc.
We did this with our 4H kids and it is a good starter. Keith's is really good too. We have both going. One item no one has mentioned so far is not the temp of the water but the water itself. Our water here had too much chlorine to make bread. We use bottled water and it solved all our issues.  Dont give up - the rewards are just amazing.
 

scarbelly

Epic Pitmaster
OTBS Member
14,319
71
Joined Jul 26, 2009
Can you just post the address so we don't have to sign up?
Looks like their website has been hijacked - I will see if I can find the address when I get back to my home PC
 
Last edited:

nwdave

Master of the Pit
SMF Premier Member
1,590
20
Joined Dec 9, 2009
Hah, I can give back something.  If you're talking about the Oregon Trail Starter, here you go:

Oregon Trail Sourdough

P.O. Box 321

Jefferson, MD  21755

All they need is a stamped envelope with your address on it.  The envelope is a business one, 9 1/2 inches long. 

Mine are going nice and strong.

~Dave
 

scarbelly

Epic Pitmaster
OTBS Member
14,319
71
Joined Jul 26, 2009
Hah, I can give back something.  If you're talking about the Oregon Trail Starter, here you go:

Oregon Trail Sourdough

P.O. Box 321

Jefferson, MD  21755

All they need is a stamped envelope with your address on it.  The envelope is a business one, 9 1/2 inches long. 

Mine are going nice and strong.

~Dave
Thanks Dave
 

kjlued

Smoke Blower
76
10
Joined Mar 4, 2011
Hah, I can give back something.  If you're talking about the Oregon Trail Starter, here you go:

Oregon Trail Sourdough

P.O. Box 321

Jefferson, MD  21755

All they need is a stamped envelope with your address on it.  The envelope is a business one, 9 1/2 inches long. 

Mine are going nice and strong.

~Dave

Thanks
 

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.