First time smoking, any suggestions?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

mware1970

Newbie
Original poster
Nov 9, 2011
11
10
Hi!

I am very new to this site and just as new to smoking. I am building my own hot smoker and am curious as to what would be a good "beginner" piece of meat? I am going to do a little more research as to smoking temps and times but any suggestions and comments are definitely welcome!

Thanks!
 
I would start with a pork butt they are hard to mess up and can take big temp swings... smoke it between 225-270 and bring the internal temp to 195 or in till you can pull the bone out clean... You will have some great pulled pork.. Hope this helped.          Have fun and happy smoking
 
Pork Butt (Boston Butt) Bone in for sure.  Hard to mess this one up.  Season as you like and take to 205-210 internal in a smoker running about 225-250 F.  Foil at about 155 F internal.  Once 205-210 hits. Put it in a cooler wrapped in old towels or any insulated container for 1hr rest or more.   With everyone watching grab the bone with tongs or gloved hand and shake lightly and pull out clean.  Your friends now think you are a BBQ god!  LOL
 
Pork Butt (Boston Butt) Bone in for sure.  Hard to mess this one up.  Season as you like and take to 205-210 internal in a smoker running about 225-250 F.  Foil at about 155 F internal.  Once 205-210 hits. Put it in a cooler wrapped in old towels or any insulated container for 1hr rest or more.   With everyone watching grab the bone with tongs or gloved hand and shake lightly and pull out clean.  Your friends now think you are a BBQ god!  LOL
X2 - Easiest thing to make in the smoker for sure
 
Mware, I'm going to suggest starting with Chicken for the first couple of times  to get use to the way your Smoker operates.
confused.gif


I agree that Butts are mostly foolproof. Try either and let us know your results(Q-view).
biggrin.gif


Have fun and...
 
You can smoke meatloaf, pre cooked hams, steaks  just about anything.    As mentioned by my friends pork butts are long slow smokes that can be very rewarding but be prepared for a 10 hour smoke.  You are taking on quite a project building a smoker with little smoking experience, good luck, can t wait to see the pics.
 
Go for the best of both worlds, butts and chicken in the same smoke. Chickens will finish early so you can eat em up while your waiting for the butts to finish.
 
I think just to be safe I should mention to season your new smoker first.  You can find many threads and opinions on how to do this but it is important.  I would not smoke IMO, anything until you first season your smoker.  Smoking a pork product first can and will enhance the seasoning of your smoker.  Pork being fatty helps mature the seasoning IMO.  Remember this is just my opinion and others may have found they had different experiences. 

Easy way to season a new smoker.

1.  Clean it well first.

2.  Spray all of inside and firebox down with Pam or similar product-basically coat inside with cooking oil

3.  Build a small fire and slowly over 3 hrs run temps up to 375 F. 

4.  Let temps come down to 200-250 F and hold for another 2 hrs.

5.  Let the fire die down on its own and smoker to cool.

Each subsequent smoke will add and mature the seasoning.  When cleaning your smoker do not remove all of the seasoning inside unless you want to season again. 

Hope this help;s.

 
I have to agree with the Pork Butt guys, but if you want to go with Beef, you could go with the good old "Chuck Roast" (AKA---Chucky).

If you want to make your first one easy, just go to my "Signature", at the bottom of any of my posts, and click on Chucky.

Then next time you can make changes, if you want to.

Bear
 
Awesome! Thanks for all the good ideas! I had wondered about seasoning the smoker first and was planning on burning some apple wood from a downed tree last spring but had not thought about spraying it with pam.

I saw a recipe for some chicken cordon bleu with a tasty rub on the outside that I am thinking will be my first adventure! COME ON SATURDAY!
 
Awesome! Thanks for all the good ideas! I had wondered about seasoning the smoker first and was planning on burning some apple wood from a downed tree last spring but had not thought about spraying it with pam.

I saw a recipe for some chicken cordon bleu with a tasty rub on the outside that I am thinking will be my first adventure! COME ON SATURDAY!
 
Pork spare ribs would be a good starter.

I'm a newbie too, so I like to smoke a few different things at once.  That way if the "main course" doesn't come out I have something else to fall back on LOL.  (That hasn't happened yet).

Throw on some extras like bacon wrapped chicken breasts, stuffed jalapenos also wrapped, or couple of kielbasa's.
 
I agree with all of the above. Great advice.

 I would also add to get a notebook and keep a log of your smokes.  For the first five or ten smokes I suggest keeping very detailed notes ie, Outside temp and conditions, hourly or half hourly temp records, where your draft(s) are set; but for sure type of meat, weather, start time, end time, rub used, mop if any, type of wood, fuel used (charcoal lump, briquettes, all wood) and leave your self plenty of room for notes after the smoke so you can write down particulars of how it turned out and what you would do differently if anything.

Hope this helps

Aaron
 
If you are still in the process of building your smoker you might want to look at the cold-smoked side of the coin.  Cold smoked fare like eggs, cheese, bacon, and lox (cured cold-smoked salmon) are not difficult to do, but deliver products that set you apart in a very tasty way from the average smoker. 

Chuck
 
Pork spare ribs would be a good starter.

I'm a newbie too, so I like to smoke a few different things at once.  That way if the "main course" doesn't come out I have something else to fall back on LOL.  (That hasn't happened yet).

Throw on some extras like bacon wrapped chicken breasts, stuffed jalapenos also wrapped, or couple of kielbasa's.
I concur, sir.  Let me tell you my story of how I got into smoking meats....

Years ago, when it was just the wife and I, I got this grand idea that I was going to smoke some brisket using the directions of the little Brinkman smoker I had.  Didn't know what the hell brisket was, just knew it tasted good.  Boy, how stupid of me.

That piece of meat was so rubbery, I could have erased a billboard with it.  Needless to say, the experience stunted my BBQ growth for quite some time. 

So I did more direct heat grilling over some years.  Did ribs on the grill, steaks, things of that nature.  Got decent with it.  Eventually, we had kids and moved from the small apartment into a nice house.  When we saw the house, it had this nice, large deck off the kitchen.  I told my wife, "Dear, we need to get a real grill!"  She concurred, and we ended up getting a Char-Griller from Lowe's.

I grilled more food for a couple of years, then my wife says to me about a year and a half ago, "You don't know it, but I'm gonna get you back to try smoking meats."  I cringed, remembering my eraser brisket.

So, for Father's Day, 2010, I awoke to a side fire box for my Char-Griller.  Put this thing on...and didn't even try smoking a damn thing until at least a month after she got it for me.

First thing I started with were a rack of spare ribs.  That's how I happened upon the SMF - doing research on how to properly do this thing called 'low and slow' cause I got two kids with hungary mouths - no need to waste food and throw it away.

Did the ribs, low and slow, for four hours.  Even documented my adventure with video.  Needless to say, I was quite pleased!  The ribs came out nice and juicy, not falling off the bone (big no no), but not chewy undercooked. 

I then worked my way up from ribs to doing pulled pork.  But before I did that, I had to find out that my smoker (that I still use) is an el cheapo that would need some mods.  That's when I added the charcoal basket, extra therms, a heat baffle, and a chimney extender.  These things alone helped me to not only do the pulled pork (which is easy peasy now), but I have done brisket and turkey as well.

So, I guess before you start smoking your meat, can you show us pics of your smoker?
 
Last edited:
All of the above are great choices but I am going with a FATTY....hard to screw those up and they are so good....
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky