Cook the Perfect Steak

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jabbo

Meat Mopper
Original poster
Oct 18, 2012
213
13
Lucas Lake, Florida
I know it is very common to sear a steak to seal in the juices and cook it until it has a perfect dark pink line across the middle, but I say different.  I prepare my steaks a little different than most and usually get some funny looks when I tell people how I do it.  The first thing I do is get the best boneless ribeye I can find.  It must be prime and it must be at least 1.25 inches thick.  When I get it home, I unwrap it and salt it liberally.  I then wrap it and let it sit for about an hour.  Meanwhile, I fire up the smoker.  That's right I said smoker.  I only use charcoal for this cook because I prefer the taste of the meat with very little smoke.  When the smoker is ready and the steak is at room temp, I insert my digital thermometer and let it ride.  once it reaches about 95 degrees internal, I flip it and fire up my grill.  When the steak finally hits 110-115, I paint one side with clarified butter and put it, butter side down, on the grill.  The grill needs to be as hot as it will go.  Fighting off flareups, I wait until the steak is a dark mahogany brown.  Then I paint the second side and flip it over.  I then sprinkle some black pepper on the  seared side and wait for the second to finish.  It shouldn't take long and I pull it off the grill, sprinkle it with pepper and cover it with foil for about 5 minutes.  When I cut into it, it is the perfect medium rare all the way through.  no little pink lines for me.  The entire steak is perfectly pink with the exception of the dark brown crust on the outside.  It is also juicier than any other method I have found.  It needs no sauce or dressing up.  In fact, I get upset and send folks home empty when they ask for it without trying the meat first.  I will put my steak up against any restaurant in the tri-state area. Try it for yourself and taste steak for the first time all over again!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jmlatt1234
A lot of "Hands on " ,yet sounds good...
drool.gif
 .  I'd try it 
biggrin.gif
 .
 
Your technique is called a " Reverse Sear "...And yes, it is the best way to cook steak when you have time to play. Your steaks would Whoop any Restaurant Steaks because the shear volume of orders does not allow time for a reverse sear. The closest we can come is to Sear the surface on a screaming hot Grill then finish cooking to the desired IT in a 350*F oven. Gets you close but not as good as you are making them...Thanks for sharing the info...JJ
 
I usually eat Steak once a week and I am going to try rapping it in foil and let it sit for awhile before eating it..
 
Alton Brown did a show where they tested the theory of searing meat to seal in the juices and , at least on his show, showed that it did not work.

Ive always had a hard time believing that, (and actually built me a gas grill with a high pressure burner just for cooking steaks at 700 ) so, I guess tonight I will be buying me a Rib Eye and testing it out myself.

Now, all you put on it first is just the salt?

What temp do you run the smoker at?
 
Now, one of my favorite meals , is to take a nice thick rare steak from left over prime rib ( its so nice to have friends with resterants) and sear  it over oak fire.  Would that be basically doing the same thing as a reverse sear?
 
Now, one of my favorite meals , is to take a nice thick rare steak from left over prime rib ( its so nice to have friends with resterants) and sear  it over oak fire.  Would that be basically doing the same thing as a reverse sear?
That would be very close. I smoked a half of a whole NY Strip for a couple of hours then sliced it and seared the steaks on a 500* grill and they were Awesome!
 
PSHAW!!!!!

The best steaks on this planet are undoubtedly made on the Big Green Egg!!!!!!!!

SPOG..wait til room temp..then into the BGE at 700!!!!!

One or two minutes on each side then close the vents for a few minutes...perfect rare!!!!



 
 Really thanks for the post......I have been buying Sirloin Steaks really reasonable, that are about 1” thick….It’s a little hard to do because of the wife, I use to do this in the house, but the wife has since made me do it outside because I smoke the house up so bad…..What I love to do is…..put a little EVOO on them, salt and pepper….. Allowing them to rest and come up to room temperature……. While waiting I get the black iron skillet as hot as I can….on a burner outside!!! It will start smoking when it ready……I will only cook 2 at a time because of temperature drop…..I want to hear them babies scream when they hit the skillet…..about a 2 minutes on each side and take it off…….I love a good caramelized color on the outside with a nice medium rare middle……Fantastic !!!!  
 
Oldschoolbbq, it sounds more labor intensive than it actually is.  Once you have the technique down it is pretty simple. 

JJ, when I lived in Texas I knew of a restaurant that would hold them in vats of oil at 110 degrees and sear them to order.  It worked just as well but they needed special equipment to do it safely.

Roller, don't let it rest for too long or the temp will start to drop and it might even dry out a bit.

Ribwizzard, searing first doesn't really work very well, but reverse searing works like a $2 hooker on pay day at the ship yard.  I slow cook everything at 225.  But as with anything else, up to 250 should be fine.  Just salt at first.  It acts like a dry brine.  Don't put pepper on until it is seared.  Pepper can be quite bitter when it is burned!  This technique works best on thick steaks over 1' thick. Under 1' and I usually just sear them over high heat until perfect.

Shoneyboy, that is how most restaurants do them and they are good.  I would encourage you to try them my way one time and see how you like them.  My experience is they are not only better but much juicier and tender.  Just my humble opinion, though.

S2k9k, I apologize.  I didn't know you had already posted this on a different thread.  And you did a much better job than me.  I feel a little foolish for not finding it sooner.  Thanks for the link, though.
 
Oldschoolbbq, it sounds more labor intensive than it actually is.  Once you have the technique down it is pretty simple. 

JJ, when I lived in Texas I knew of a restaurant that would hold them in vats of oil at 110 degrees and sear them to order.  It worked just as well but they needed special equipment to do it safely.

Roller, don't let it rest for too long or the temp will start to drop and it might even dry out a bit.

Ribwizzard, searing first doesn't really work very well, but reverse searing works like a $2 hooker on pay day at the ship yard.  I slow cook everything at 225.  But as with anything else, up to 250 should be fine.  Just salt at first.  It acts like a dry brine.  Don't put pepper on until it is seared.  Pepper can be quite bitter when it is burned!  This technique works best on thick steaks over 1' thick. Under 1' and I usually just sear them over high heat until perfect.

Shoneyboy, that is how most restaurants do them and they are good.  I would encourage you to try them my way one time and see how you like them.  My experience is they are not only better but much juicier and tender.  Just my humble opinion, though.

S2k9k, I apologize.  I didn't know you had already posted this on a different thread.  And you did a much better job than me.  I feel a little foolish for not finding it sooner.  Thanks for the link, though.
Jabbo, it's on my to do list....Thanks ShoneyBoy
 
Last edited:
This sounds really good.  I haven't had a steak in a while, price is ridiculous  here.  This sounds worth a try.

Thanks for sharing.

Wes
 
Believe it or not, I like to do my 3/4 inch 8oz steakburgers the exact same way.  They usually come out somewhere between medium and medium rare.  Absolutely to die for!
 
I tried this the other night and I gotta say, it was well worth the extra time and effort.  I had a nice think Rib Eye and the wife a chunk of Tenderloin.  Both were excellent.

Thanks for sharing.  As usual I continue to learn from all the knowledge and experience on this board.  It has dramatically reduced the learning curve for this newb.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky