• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Brisket cooking too fast?

hattsoff

Newbie
4
10
Joined Nov 8, 2014
Hey guys...I know this thread is at about a year old...but I am doing my first brisket and have the same panic...I used on online meat calculator and I told me my 10lb brisket was to go in at 2:30am and would be ready to come out 2:30pm to start a four hour rest (slicing and dinner at 6:30pm). I took out at 7:30am this morning too foil and put back in and temp was already 165...I need this for dinner not brunch.

I have a Masterbuilt electric. ..I have done two pork shoulders and a whole turkey. ..first pork was awesome the others were ok...losing confidence and my wife seems nervous about losing money on meat.

Please help.
 

geerock

Master of the Pit
SMF Premier Member
1,366
77
Joined Oct 25, 2010
A couple thoughts.... first, have you ever verified your cooking temps with a reliable therm? Masterbuilts aren't known for accurate temps. And I'm assuming that you are not using the MB meat probe for meat temp. Having said that don't panic. You probably are going to hit the stall any time now. And then, even if you do get ready early, brisket can take (and needs) a good long rest. When you hit finish temp wrap her in double foil with a little liquid and then wrap that in a towel and then drop in a cooler until ready to eat. She'll stay for hours like that way. I don't think you're that far of on times.....maybe a little early but no worries.
 

radio

Master of the Pit
1,061
376
Joined Jul 28, 2013
Good info from Geerock above.  I would also add that no two Briskets cook alike.  Two Briskets of nearly identical weight and fat ratio can be hours apart when finished, so a time chart is only a very rough guide.

A good thermometer with a probe is the only way to go when smoking meats.  I like my Brisket at or near the pulling stage, so shoot for an internal temp of 200-205°, but the true way to tell is when a probe or skewer inserted into the meat slides in in like it's going into soft butter.  If it meets resistance, it needs more time.

Don't worry about wasting the money on the meat.  It may not be perfect, but will still be very tasty
 

hattsoff

Newbie
4
10
Joined Nov 8, 2014
Thank you geerock. ..just hearing that is a huge help. Epic fail, I am using the MB temp and meat probe. Maybe I will grab a better one for future cooking attempts.
I am planning a 190-195 removal and then slice. I did a rub with a yellow mustard spread first...and to fuel the fire, I put fat down...sorry didn't know there was a debate and now I placed myself in a camp.
 

geerock

Master of the Pit
SMF Premier Member
1,366
77
Joined Oct 25, 2010
Hatsoff

190 to 195 may be too early.  Take the advice of radio and check it with a probe of some kind.  It tends to be closer to 200 IT for finish temp.  Brisket pulled too early can be tough as shoe leather.  Also, get a maverick therm to check both meat and chamber temp.  An invaluable tool for all smokers.
 
Last edited:

txrookie

Newbie
4
10
Joined Feb 27, 2015
I know this is an older post, bit where do you find a $35 brisket? I'm lucky if I can find a $50 full packer(I believe that's the term) that's small enough to fit in my MES
 

radio

Master of the Pit
1,061
376
Joined Jul 28, 2013
I know this is an older post, bit where do you find a $35 brisket? I'm lucky if I can find a $50 full packer(I believe that's the term) that's small enough to fit in my MES
Yep, beef prices have taken a huge jump and in some instances, have actually doubled compared to a year or so ago.  I used to get boneless beef short ribs for $2.99 per pound and now they go for $5.99
 

johnny booze

Newbie
13
10
Joined Jun 3, 2017
Afternoon , nana. Don't panic...it may stall yet. And remember temp is only a signpost on the road to tender brisket....no matter when it happens , when the temp gets close you have to start probing the meat for tender.....so keep watching the temp by all means , but just accept that it's done when the probe slides in like buttah!

And I will hasten to add that I am no expert brisket maker , but I just wanted to reassure you with what I think I know....others may chime in more knowledgable than I.....good luck
I'm in the same boat. Same smoker it's a 16 lb split the point from the falp due to size. Also had a 8lb pork butt in there shot up to 145 after 4 hrs. I watched a YouTube video saying it should take 20hr. Do I need to relax and have a drink or panic?
 

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Top Bottom