• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Will a rub of sage, garlic, pepper ect. clash with smoke flavor on a turkey?

bbqandfootball

Fire Starter
47
10
Joined Feb 5, 2009
I was thinking about trying a rub consisting of traditional Thanksgiving flavors, ideally sage or poultry seasoning with some other basic stuff like salt, pepper, garlic ect.

But I'm worried that if I don't use a more traditional "BBQ" based rub (paprika, chili powder, cumin), that maybe the smoke flavor won't pair well with the sage/poultry seasoning flavor.

I've smoked several turkeys, always using either a BBQ rub, or just salt and pepper. The turkey will be served at my in-laws, and several of them don't like the BBQ flavor on turkey. There will however be other turkey served there, so it's not like mine will be all that is offerred. Plain old roasted turkey will be served as well.

But I'm curious how a sage flavored bird will taste when smoked. Personally, I love sage in dressing and on roasted turkey.

Any experience with a Thanksgiving flavored rub?

Thanks.
 

northern greenhorn

Master of the Pit
SMF Premier Member
1,028
10
Joined Mar 11, 2010
I've smoked a few turkeys like this, just don't use a strong wood like mesquite, I use apple, maple or even pecan if I'm not looking for a strong smoky flavor
 

pineywoods

SMF Hall of Fame Pitmaster
Staff member
Administrator
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
OTBS Admin
Group Lead
26,632
859
Joined Mar 22, 2008
I use Sage, Garlic Powder, Salt, Pepper and it doesn't seem to compete with the wood flavor as long as the sage or the smoke is not over done. I have tried a couple of the Poultry Rubs but haven't really found one we like. I rarely use a traditional BBQ rub when doing Turkeys
 

eman

Smoking Guru
Staff member
Moderator
OTBS Member
5,309
129
Joined Feb 3, 2009
Turkeys don't need any of the red seasonings .(unless you have to add a lil cayanne)

Herbs , salt and cbp. I don't even like garlic on my turkey.

What i am saying is for seasoning the bird. You can use whatever you want in the brine
 

pit 4 brains

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Group Lead
2,222
199
Joined Dec 16, 2009
I think anything other than bbq spices will be good. This is the season for the harvest so herbs will do well with breads, white meat, white wine etc. Don't be to concerned about the smoke flavor, the first turkeys weren't cooked in a conventional oven my friend, they were roasted over a fire or in a wood-fired brick oven.

The turkey will take some time so this is where the lightest of smoke will be plenty. Remember, if you can smell the smoke, you are cooking with it. Don't give  in to adding wood at the 5 hour mark because the smoke ran clear..
 

jirodriguez

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
4,653
138
Joined Jun 5, 2009
Love me some herb smoked turkey! I usually mix my dry herbs and kosher salt with a stick of melted butter then rub it all over and under the turkey skin, gives it a nice herb flavor without being overpowering.
 

mballi3011

Epic Pitmaster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
14,478
55
Joined Mar 12, 2009


The only thing that I think that those spices will do is make the bird taste to me that is. Run with it and let us know. 
 

bbqandfootball

Fire Starter
47
10
Joined Feb 5, 2009
The Pilgrams didn't have ovens?!?!?!? You mean my school teachers were lying to me?!? Lol, just kidding Pit 4 Brains.

This isn't the first time my family or I have had smoked turkey for Thanksgiving. We've had it many times in fact. I'm just trying to tone down the BBQ flavor in the spirit of the holidays for a few of them with mild pallets, yet still have the smoked flavor, which they love.

Hence trying to decide if smoked meat will go well with traditional roasted turkey herbs.
 
Last edited:

carson627

Smoke Blower
112
11
Joined Jun 14, 2010
Why not add some dried herbs in with your wood when you smoke?  They should smoke too and should add flavor I would think.
 

native

Fire Starter
37
10
Joined Sep 19, 2010
Why not add some dried herbs in with your wood when you smoke?  They should smoke too and should add flavor I would think.
Good idea! I've not used them that way before because I thought they would burn up too fast in a regular smoke box.  Now I'm wondering if you added some here and there in the A-Maz-N Smoker what the effect would be. 
 

jirodriguez

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
4,653
138
Joined Jun 5, 2009
Good idea! I've not used them that way before because I thought they would burn up too fast in a regular smoke box.  Now I'm wondering if you added some here and there in the A-Maz-N Smoker what the effect would be. 
If you want the aroma, take whole stalks of fresh herbs and tie them together in a bouquet. Put that inside the cavity of the bird with nothing else. Works like a charm.
 

bbqandfootball

Fire Starter
47
10
Joined Feb 5, 2009
Not sure burning herbs would taste that well. Herbs, particularly fresh herbs, tend to get very bitter when burned. Kinda like garlic does.

But a bouquet of herbs in the cavity of the turkey sounds like a good idea.

I may just season the outside of the bird with salt, pepper and chopped garlic, as well as some EVOO. Then throw a bunch of fresh sage inside. maybe a cut up apple and onion in there also.
 

jirodriguez

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
4,653
138
Joined Jun 5, 2009
Not sure burning herbs would taste that well. Herbs, particularly fresh herbs, tend to get very bitter when burned. Kinda like garlic does.

But a bouquet of herbs in the cavity of the turkey sounds like a good idea.

I may just season the outside of the bird with salt, pepper and chopped garlic, as well as some EVOO. Then throw a bunch of fresh sage inside. maybe a cut up apple and onion in there also.
I have found melting some butter mixed with salt, pepper, thyme, rosemary, and poultry seasoning then rubbing that all under and over the skin gives you a great herbed turkey
 

meateater

Legendary Pitmaster
SMF Premier Member
8,984
61
Joined Oct 17, 2009
Thats all I use is citrus and T-Day herbs. The rest of the year is for concoctions. :)
 

bamaboy

Meat Mopper
SMF Premier Member
298
11
Joined Sep 26, 2010
Little bit of sage goes a long way,I use EVOO all over the bird the rub with salt and pepper,garlic and light rosemary.But i usually inject mine,have never brined anything before.just might have to try.Good luck bro....
 

bbqandfootball

Fire Starter
47
10
Joined Feb 5, 2009
Thanks for all of the input guys. I'm gonna go with the traditional sage/poultry seasoning flavor and see what happens.
 

stickyfingers

Smoking Fanatic
538
52
Joined May 23, 2009
I like the idea of using sage, might to try it. Traditionally, I use fresh rosemary and pepper. Crush it a little to release the oils of the rosemary and add it to a couple of sticks of room temp. butter- rubbed under the skin and on the skin, smoke with apple wood.

Yum, yum!
 
Last edited:

nette

Newbie
10
10
Joined Sep 12, 2009
After looking at HerkySprings link to the brine & rub, that is my choice for this year's bird.  Mission accomplished htis morning -- Thanks for sharing.
 
Top Bottom
  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.