Who makes their own mustard (s)?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

noboundaries

Epic Pitmaster
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Sep 7, 2013
10,285
5,416
Roseville, CA, a suburb of Sacramento
My wife loves French's mustard. To me it's meh. I prefer a spicier bite. I needed to buy mustard, but wasn't thrilled about the offerings and prices available at the store.

More than 30 years ago, I used to make my own sweet-tasting but spicy hot Dijon-style mustard. It was a simple recipe to throw together that spent a week in the fridge for the flavors and textures to blend. Unfortunately, that recipe has been lost to time and memory rewrites. I remember powdered mustard, malt vinegar, honey, and white pepper, but the rest is gone.

Last night around midnight I saw a recipe on YouTube for a simple spicy mustard. I literally got out of bed and threw together a small batch (5 mins) with personal tweaks and stuck it in the fridge. It's not exactly what I remember, because I didn't have malt vinegar, but it had the sweet spicy flavor I love. I'll tweak the recipe, but I'm done buying store-bought.

If you make your own mustard, share your recipe. Here's what I threw together in the old man wee-wee hours of the night.

English Mustard - Ray's Version

This is a VERY simple mustard to make. It has a bite like dijon. Any vinegar can be used. My first attempt was with Seasoned Rice vinegar. I added the honey and turmeric to the recipe.

Powdered ginger might be another nice addition.

Ingredients
½ cup Coleman's mustard powder
1 ½ Tbs sugar
1 tsp turmeric
½ tsp salt
2 Tbs Apple cider vinegar (or vinegar of choice)
1 ½ Tbs cold water (or white wine)
1 Tbs honey

Directions
Mix dry ingredients.
Whisk in wet ingredients until smooth.
Place in a glass or plastic container and store in the refrigerator.
Makes a little more than half a cup.
 
Last edited:
Would love to try this,,,, but, I will try to source fresh mustard seeds. I am not a fan of any mustard powder I have ever tasted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: noboundaries
I've been wanting to make some too , but my favorite is Stadium Mustard . Comes out of Illinois . I order it online .
I think Foamy uses black mustard seeds ?
Watching this one .
 
Great job!

How long do you think this will last in the fridge?

Watching for future use!

Since it has vinegar in it, it should last a while. I'll probably go through this small batch in 2-3 weeks. Had it on an Evergood Pineapple sausage (Costco sourced) microwave nuked for lunch. Not picture worthy. The texture had improved significantly in 12 hours as the powdered mustard and turmeric hydrated. Great flavor. Nice heat bite.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kilo charlie
Would love to try this,,,, but, I will try to source fresh mustard seeds. I am not a fan of any mustard powder I have ever tasted.
I've always used whatever is easily available. I can always find powder.

I tried to buy mustard seeds last year when things were scarce. No luck. I put white, brown, and black mustard seeds on my shopping list last night. We'll see what I can find without running to ten stores.
 
Mrs. Wurtz and I enjoy all types of mustards, especially the "strange" ones. Here is a link to a German site that I use for making my mustards. The attachment is from the site and is for a "hot mustard." I do add about 5gr or so grated horseradish. I use this on my wurst and almost all of the recipes I make on the Carson Rodizio as a side dip or coating. The web link is written German (and is translated via your web browser translator) and shows 19 different mustard recipes. They are great fusion ideas! With all that can be done with mustards, maybe the SysOp could make a group for mustard recipes. 🍻
John
Senf selber machen: 19 Rezeptideen | Küchengötter (kuechengoetter.de)
 

Attachments

  • Spicy mustard recipe _ Kitchen gods.pdf
    276.9 KB · Views: 43
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: noboundaries
Anywhere with bulk spices should have mustard seed, or there is always Amazon. They are dirt cheap ( $4/lb at my grocery store).

All you need is an extra grinder, or ideally a mortar & pestle. Use cold water for a spicier mustard as hot water denatures that quality. I like all sorts of mustard (honey, green chile, cayenne or jalapeno powder etc.), but pretty much always use some horseradish (and consider it essential to hot deli mustard).
 
  • Like
Reactions: noboundaries
Anywhere with bulk spices should have mustard seed, or there is always Amazon. They are dirt cheap ( $4/lb at my grocery store).

All you need is an extra grinder, or ideally a mortar & pestle. Use cold water for a spicier mustard as hot water denatures that quality. I like all sorts of mustard (honey, green chile, cayenne or jalapeno powder etc.), but pretty much always use some horseradish (and consider it essential to hot deli mustard).
Winco, 5 miles away, is my preferred grocer. They have a great bulk section, but no mustard seeds, just powder. There are 3 other higher priced grocers within 1.5 miles of my house. I rarely shop them, but will give the highest end one a try for seeds. I've got everything needed to crack or pulverize.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hamdrew
Winco, 5 miles away, is my preferred grocer. They have a great bulk section, but no mustard seeds, just powder. There are 3 other higher priced grocers within 1.5 miles of my house. I rarely shop them, but will give the highest end one a try for seeds. I've got everything needed to crack or pulverize.
If you have any store that has a lot of Indian stuff, it's really prominent in Southern Indian cooking.

There's also little ~2oz bottles from McCormick, and I'm sure Spice Islands etc., but at $5+ that's way more than you should be paying
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky