When to replace the mailbox and pipe due to Creosote build up?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

cmayna

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Jun 23, 2012
3,971
1,697
SF Bay Area, CA
I have noticed that since I installed the mailbox mod in early 2017, everything has been running just fine, but finally started to look in the mailbox and OMG, there's a lot of black gunky stuff hanging from the ceiling of the mailbox and of course the aluminum tube has a nice dark coating on the inside.

No taste issues what so ever. Just a visual and stickiness issues of the box and tube. Maybe I should build a new mailbox mod and retire this old one? or.......if it ain't broke.......
 
I wouldn't build a new one, just scrape out your mailbox and replace the tube if your concerned, personally I would just scrape out the mailbox and call it good,(but that's me)
 
IMG_0854.JPG
Yup, i did scrape a bunch of junk off the ceiling of the box and am now smoking more Salmon. Just couldn't believe how much yuk had accumulated over the past 2.5 years. Yes a lot of yummy fish have come and gone.

Here's a pic of the mailbox doing some Salmon as we speak....
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: chopsaw
Thanks. Yeah, think I'll just kick back and relax over this issue. Knowing I have all the ingredients to make another mailbox mod sitting in the rafters of my shop is good enough for me right now.
 
Last edited:
you could run a brush down your tube also to clean it a little if you wanted, also if you want i'll try a piece of your salmon to make sure it's safe to eat:emoji_wink:
 
you could run a brush down your tube also to clean it a little if you wanted, also if you want i'll try a piece of your salmon to make sure it's safe to eat:emoji_wink:
Jim, if you lived nearby, I'd give you a bunch. I've got lots
 
Why didn't I consider that? Will do it when I get back from vacation. Thanks Holly2015.
 
Jim,
When you come to San Francisco.......... LOL! Going to Alaska this next week.

I guess I could just wait on the mailbox clean until so much creosote is built up and hanging from the ceiling that it is preventing me from sliding in the AMNPS. :emoji_blush:
 
Last edited:
You can pick up a chimney brush at your local hardware store . 3" or 4" diameter, 6" long, and made to thread on to long handle sections. Just tie a piece of cord to it, an pull it through your mailbox and pipe. Be like cleaning a very big bore shotgun.
 
My mailbox mod is a sturdy "one piece" design and I get that creosote crust build up as well. Fortunately I just grab the whole thing with 1 hand and tap it on the side of the house (brick) and that knocks the big stuff lose and I just dump that junk out. The mailbox mod is ready to go again :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: chopsaw
In my description of my external smoking box:

Mailbox (Popcorn) Mod (with a small twist)

I also described how I clean it after each smoke, using my ultrasonic cleaner. I also clean the "smoke scrubber" which is a metal mesh that traps additional creosote, beyond what condenses on the metal surface.

I also posted about my experience with how creosote build up can (and does) affect the taste of your food:

Cleanliness Is Next To Godliness ... But Does It Taste Good?

So, from my own experience, it is really important to remove creosote build up, if you have that problem. I suspect that those who use more traditional smokers, like offsets, don't have to worry about "gunk" buildup, because it is probably tasty stuff. However, shiny black creosote imparts a numbing, bitter taste to food, and you don't want any of that. Unfortunately, the really, really slow air exchange in electrics, and the nature of how smoke is produced (especially with the factory chip "burner" inside the smoker) means that they produce far more creosote.

So while my "clean after each use" is probably overkill (although my ultrasonic cleaner makes it trivial to do), my food sure tastes better now.

I also periodically clean the smoker itself which, despite using the external smoker ("mailbox mod") still gets a buildup and, when I pre-heat the smoker to 275 before each smoke, I see lots of smoke coming out of the vent, all of it from the stuff (mostly creosote) that is on the walls. That will obviously mix in with my new smoke, once I start cooking, and degrade the taste of my meal.

You can find out more about the significant limitations of using electric smokers at this excellent "science" site:

Summary of electricity as a barbecue fuel:
 
  • Like
Reactions: siege
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky