TOMATO PIE

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Sowsage

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Oct 18, 2017
4,431
4,670
Maplewood OH
This is one of our favorite things to make in the summer. Its a great side dish that goes with just about any smoked or grilled meal. I did this in the oven but if you can hold your smoker at 350° you can also smoke it.

Here is all the stuff to make the pie.
0815201451.jpg


First thing is to scale the tomato to peel them

Into boiling water
0815201530.jpg


Then into an ice bath
0815201540.jpg


Peeled and ready to core and slice
0815201557a.jpg


Then I plce them onto a rack. Salt and pepper to pull out some moisture. Then I pop them in the oven at 200° to get some more moisture out. This is important so you dont have a soggy sloppy pie.
0815201606.jpg


Next blind bake a deep dish pie crust. I also crush up some Ritz crackers and put on the bottom. This will help soak up some of the juices when baking the pie.
0815201616.jpg


Then chop up some basil and some green onion
0815201731a.jpg



Tomatoe out of the oven. Lost a little moisture. Just enough to keep from having a sloppy pie.
0815201804.jpg


Time to build the pie
First the tomato
0815201807.jpg


Then the basil and the green onion
0815201808.jpg


Next is the the topping. 1cup mayo,1cup mozzarella shredded,and 1cup cheddar shredded......i forgot to take a picture of the mix. I was distracted by a spatula thief!
0815201739a.jpg


Topping spread on top.
0815201816.jpg



Baked at 350 for about 45 min
0815202046.jpg


I also had smoked a pork loin to go along with the pie.
0815202208a.jpg


All plated up. I did add a few Brussels so I would have some kind of green veggie along with it.
0815202255.jpg


This was a good meal! Hope you enjoyed the pics.
Thanks for taking a look!
 
I had never even heard of a tomato pie. It sounds, and looks fantastic.
Give it a go sometime. It's really good. I do a variation of a Paula Dean recipe. There are several recipes out there to choose from.
 
Man yeah that looks delicious. Big fan of tomato pie. Wife makes a real good one. Has bacon in it. Nice work bud
Thanks Jake!Bacon sounds good in it. That would make a meal in itself.
 
This is one of our favorite things to make in the summer. Its a great side dish that goes with just about any smoked or grilled meal. I did this in the oven but if you can hold your smoker at 350° you can also smoke it.

Here is all the stuff to make the pie.View attachment 458806

First thing is to scale the tomato to peel them

Into boiling waterView attachment 458807

Then into an ice bathView attachment 458808

Peeled and ready to core and sliceView attachment 458809

Then I plce them onto a rack. Salt and pepper to pull out some moisture. Then I pop them in the oven at 200° to get some more moisture out. This is important so you dont have a soggy sloppy pie.View attachment 458810

Next blind bake a deep dish pie crust. I also crush up some Ritz crackers and put on the bottom. This will help soak up some of the juices when baking the pie.View attachment 458811

Then chop up some basil and some green onionView attachment 458812


Tomatoe out of the oven. Lost a little moisture. Just enough to keep from having a sloppy pie.View attachment 458813

Time to build the pie
First the tomatoView attachment 458814

Then the basil and the green onionView attachment 458815

Next is the the topping. 1cup mayo,1cup mozzarella shredded,and 1cup cheddar shredded......i forgot to take a picture of the mix. I was distracted by a spatula thief!View attachment 458816

Topping spread on top.View attachment 458817


Baked at 350 for about 45 min
View attachment 458818

I also had smoked a pork loin to go along with the pie.
View attachment 458819

All plated up. I did add a few Brussels so I would have some kind of green veggie along with it. View attachment 458820

This was a good meal! Hope you enjoyed the pics.
Thanks for taking a look!
Looks like a heck of a meal! Love all that cheese!
 
Been making tomato pies for years although we use a different recipe. There were some posting on here of tomato pies before.

Warren
 
Never heard of them before either. It looks very good. Do you remove the ritz crackers before adding the toppings? I like the picture of the spatula thief!
 
That tomato pie looks pretty good Travis, I’ve heard of it but never tried it. The pie sounds delicious though!
 
The pie and meal look really good. I had never heard of tomato pie until a couple of years ago on here and it caught my attention. I made some for the last two Pa. gatherings and they seemed to go over well. I haven't made any this year so I need to remedy that - with bacon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HalfSmoked
It all looks good Travis, Ill have to try the pie.

LOL... A tow headed, blue eyed spatula thief.
That one looks like a mischievous imp if there ever was one.
Thanks chile! I'll tell ya what.....mischievievous??? Oh yea....i was a tow head when I was little. My mom always told me if I was her first I would have been her last.....i now know what she meant by that lol!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLeonard
Been making tomato pies for years although we use a different recipe. There were some posting on here of tomato pies before.

Warren
Warren , we have made a couple different kinds and this one seems to be our favorite. Would like to try a few other ways to see what they are like.
Sowsage Sowsage Looks good. May have to give it a try.
Thanks! give it a try!
 
Looks Great Travis!!
That's the only way I'll eat tomatoes cooked in any way!!!
I hate Tomato Juice & Stewed Tomatoes, but I love Tomato Pie or something similar.
That & fresh cold Maters in Sammies is about it for me.
Nice Job!!
Like.

Bear
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLeonard
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky