Smoking larger Turkeys

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jazzybiker

Newbie
Original poster
Apr 1, 2014
1
10
Hey Everybody,

Longtime reader, first time posting.  With Easter coming up, I wanted to get some thoughts on smoking larger Turkeys.  Last spring, I smoked a 27 pound bird successfully in my little upright, single-burner, propane smoker.  Given it's size and the associated internal temp risks, "low and slow" would not get the job done, so I essentially roasted it in the smoker, giving it smoke the first two hours. It was good for my first time with such a large turkey, but not perfect, and I've been waiting a whole year to try this again.  Here's what I did last time..

-Brined in water, salt, brown sugar, and whole peppercorns for 24 hours

-Stuffed w/ quartered Apples and Onions, tied legs

-Rubbed skin with olive oil, salt, paprika, pepper, garlic powder

-Pinned wings back

-Smoker set to ~325 for about 5 hours 'til internal breast temp was 165F.  I used two 2" chunks of hickory, one after the other, for smoke.

When I pulled it out, the skin was dark, almost black, and the legs had drawn back away from the ends.  Underneath it, the white meat was JUICY and had really good flavor.  Legs and thighs were good and smokey, but maybe a little over.  The biggest thing I noticed was that the lower 2/3 of the wings were way over cooked.

My questions and thoughts are this..

1. How do I get the skin brown and crispy?  Should I not grease it before I add the rub?

2. Should I have pulled it 20 mins sooner and rested it?  Maybe that would solve my issue with the overdone dark meat?

3. Should I not have pinned the wings?  They were cooking against the grate the whole time.

Lemme know your thoughts.
 
Welcome to the forum

Do you think stuffing the cavity and tying the legs may have forced you to cook it a bit longer then needed?  I would think that leaving the cavity empty and trussed open will allow the smoke and heat to cook the breasts from the inside.  

Since you are cooking at 325 I bet you can go ahead and inject the bird to help keep it moist.

I wonder why the breasts where black?  

All in all it sounds like you did a great job.  Look forward to reading about the next one.
 
I haven't tried this but I have ready about smoking the turkey at a lower temp for about three to 3 and a half hours then transferring it it a turkey fryer. That would get you crispy skin and juicy meat. Keep in ,ind this is theory and I have never actually tried it, but I really want to. 
 
Duffman,

I've done that with chicken wings for buffalo wings and they came out well.  May have to give a try with a full turkey, I have grease in the fridge that I need to use and this may be a way to do it!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky