Smoked salmon

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Okay, the taste is great but once again, I'm disappointed with the appearance. I put a lot of effort into controllling the temperature but I still had significant albumin leakage. I'm wondering if it's a sockeye thing. This is the best looking rack.


It may also be time to use this smoker for target practice and upgrade.
 
 I have never had that experience with a bradly on fish. I did with jerky once, during winter and windy, couldn't get it up to temp and was taking a much longer time than usual, then i didn't pay attention as well as I should have and way over cooked it. Been good or lucky so far.
 
ETA:  I didn't know all of this below...  I've been on a LONG conference call and did a little research...

At temperatures of 104°F / 40°C and 122°F / 50°C: Proteins in Fish and Meat Begin to Denature (break down into liquid forms that can then seep and migrate out of the meat structure itself.)

A perfect example of this is the albumin that you are seeing on the surface of your salmon.

Some studies have been done that show that the alteration of the pH of the flesh, or soaking the flesh in a 5-10% brine solution can assist in avoiding the denaturing of the protiens.

You said that you brined the filets in a mixture of water, kosher salt, brown sugar, and maple syrup.  This mixture should have a pH of ~6-7.5 depending upon your location and it's water quality.  The pH adjustment was shown to have been best in the >8 range, but at that point, the caustic nature of the liquid would begin to structurally change your fish (slightly, but it will change over time).

So, the key would be to keep the IT of the fish at <104° f, or to use a brine solution that is >/= 5%.  Using the chart below, what was your approximate solution?


To create 8-cups of brine at 2% salinity, use 38 grams of salt.  To create 3-cups of brine at a 2% salinity, add the amount of salt called for in the columns under 1-cup (5 grams) and 2-cups (10 grams) which equals 15-grams of salt. If creating a 1% brine, simply divide the 2% salt grams by 50%.  To make a 1% brine for 2-cups of water, use half of the 5-grams, ROUND DOWN to 2 grams.

For the brine that a lot of us use, Pop's, the brine solution would be in the range of ~7%  (1-Tbs kosher salt = 16.2 grams with 16 tablespoons in a cup, = 259.2 grams of salt in a gallon of water)
 
Last edited:
 
ETA:  I didn't know all of this below...  I've been on a LONG conference call and did a little research...

At temperatures of 104°F / 40°C and 122°F / 50°C: Proteins in Fish and Meat Begin to Denature (break down into liquid forms that can then seep and migrate out of the meat structure itself.)

A perfect example of this is the albumin that you are seeing on the surface of your salmon.

Some studies have been done that show that the alteration of the pH of the flesh, or soaking the flesh in a 5-10% brine solution can assist in avoiding the denaturing of the protiens.

You said that you brined the filets in a mixture of water, kosher salt, brown sugar, and maple syrup.  This mixture should have a pH of ~6-7.5 depending upon your location and it's water quality.  The pH adjustment was shown to have been best in the >8 range, but at that point, the caustic nature of the liquid would begin to structurally change your fish (slightly, but it will change over time).

So, the key would be to keep the IT of the fish at <104° f, or to use a brine solution that is >/= 5%.  Using the chart below, what was your approximate solution?


To create 8-cups of brine at 2% salinity, use 38 grams of salt.  To create 3-cups of brine at a 2% salinity, add the amount of salt called for in the columns under 1-cup (5 grams) and 2-cups (10 grams) which equals 15-grams of salt. If creating a 1% brine, simply divide the 2% salt grams by 50%.  To make a 1% brine for 2-cups of water, use half of the 5-grams, ROUND DOWN to 2 grams.

For the brine that a lot of us use, Pop's, the brine solution would be in the range of ~7%  (1-Tbs kosher salt = 16.2 grams with 16 tablespoons in a cup, = 259.2 grams of salt in a gallon of water)
hit.gif


hit.gif


Thats way to much for my brain to try to think about. 

Hmmm

Maybe an adult beverage would help

 
Last edited:
 
ETA:  I didn't know all of this below...  I've been on a LONG conference call and did a little research...

At temperatures of 104°F / 40°C and 122°F / 50°C: Proteins in Fish and Meat Begin to Denature (break down into liquid forms that can then seep and migrate out of the meat structure itself.)

A perfect example of this is the albumin that you are seeing on the surface of your salmon.

Some studies have been done that show that the alteration of the pH of the flesh, or soaking the flesh in a 5-10% brine solution can assist in avoiding the denaturing of the protiens.

You said that you brined the filets in a mixture of water, kosher salt, brown sugar, and maple syrup.  This mixture should have a pH of ~6-7.5 depending upon your location and it's water quality.  The pH adjustment was shown to have been best in the >8 range, but at that point, the caustic nature of the liquid would begin to structurally change your fish (slightly, but it will change over time).

So, the key would be to keep the IT of the fish at <104° f, or to use a brine solution that is >/= 5%.  Using the chart below, what was your approximate solution?


To create 8-cups of brine at 2% salinity, use 38 grams of salt.  To create 3-cups of brine at a 2% salinity, add the amount of salt called for in the columns under 1-cup (5 grams) and 2-cups (10 grams) which equals 15-grams of salt. If creating a 1% brine, simply divide the 2% salt grams by 50%.  To make a 1% brine for 2-cups of water, use half of the 5-grams, ROUND DOWN to 2 grams.

For the brine that a lot of us use, Pop's, the brine solution would be in the range of ~7%  (1-Tbs kosher salt = 16.2 grams with 16 tablespoons in a cup, = 259.2 grams of salt in a gallon of water)
Good stuff! One quart of water and 1/3 cup of Morton's kosher salt when converted to grams gives me a brine right around 9%. The water here is very alkaline.

If I had to guess, I would say my problem is the result of the temperature range on the Bradley when the heating element cycles on and off. It can easily be as much as a 20 degree swing, so if it's set at 120, it can range between 110 and 130.
 
 
Good stuff! One quart of water and 1/3 cup of Morton's kosher salt when converted to grams gives me a brine right around 9%. The water here is very alkaline.

If I had to guess, I would say my problem is the result of the temperature range on the Bradley when the heating element cycles on and off. It can easily be as much as a 20 degree swing, so if it's set at 120, it can range between 110 and 130.
Were you targeting a specific internal temperature or were you going off of how the fish felt/flaked?

Before you take the Browning to the Bradley, I'd highly suggest an Auber PID controller for it.  It can really keep the temp swings down and operate at a lower temp for you when needed.
 
 
Were you targeting a specific internal temperature or were you going off of how the fish felt/flaked?

Before you take the Browning to the Bradley, I'd highly suggest an Auber PID controller for it.  It can really keep the temp swings down and operate at a lower temp for you when needed.
I'm going for appearance and feel rather than temperature. To follow the recipe I've been using requires two hours at 100, two at 120 and finishing with two hours at 140. The final product has always been exactly what I was shooting for, I just can't beat the albumin issue.

I was thinking about adding the Auber PID just to deal with this problem. Now that I have the Maverick probe in the smoker, it's obvious the temperature gauge fluctuates wildly from what the actual temperatures are. Some times it's spot on and others, like yesterday, it was showing 28 degrees cooler than the actual temperature. It's impossible to do a decent run under those circumstances.

My mind has also been working on justifying an upgrade to a Smokin-It 3D...
sausage.gif
 
 
I'm going for appearance and feel rather than temperature. To follow the recipe I've been using requires two hours at 100, two at 120 and finishing with two hours at 140. The final product has always been exactly what I was shooting for, I just can't beat the albumin issue.
You have a paradox here. If the final product is exactly what you want, using the process that you do to achieve that result will always produce albumin. It's the high heat factor involved.

Simply put, and as CrankyBuzzard referred to, as the IT increases the muscle fibers contract and basically squeeze the protein out and when they clear the surface of the fish they coagulate and turn whitish.Though it will vary by the thickness of the piece, the intensity of the cooking heat, the length of cooking time involved, etc., as a rule of thumb, I use 115F-120F as a as a break point for the albumin to initially appear. When that happens, it's essentially nature's way of telling you that the fish is entering the realm of being overcooked, and drying out. Buying a new smoker or PID will never change that.

One way to minimize the appearance of the albumin is to use a simple quick brine. I use a 10% salt water brine, and for a piece 1" thick, I brine it for 10 minutes. Obviously, for thinner, or thicker, pieces, the time involved adjusts a little downward or upward.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
Okay, the taste is great but once again, I'm disappointed with the appearance. I put a lot of effort into controllling the temperature but I still had significant albumin leakage. I'm wondering if it's a sockeye thing. This is the best looking rack.


It may also be time to use this smoker for target practice and upgrade.
I've always had trouble with sockeye.  I think it's a lot fattier than other salmons.  I ramp the temp like you and have tried many temp variances with good and not so good pellicles and it always had boogers.  So I stopped trying.  I am now getting pretty good results with farmed atlantic so I've been sticking with that.  Can't keep up with my wife's consumption.  Did 4 pounds the other day -

 
 
I've always had trouble with sockeye.  I think it's a lot fattier than other salmons.  I ramp the temp like you and have tried many temp variances with good and not so good pellicles and it always had boogers.  So I stopped trying.  I am now getting pretty good results with farmed atlantic so I've been sticking with that.  Can't keep up with my wife's consumption.  Did 4 pounds the other day -

Great looking salmon! Sockeye is actually very lean compared to Atlantic and King Salmon. I think the higher protein to fat ratio may be part of the problem. More fat means a slower rise in temperature, which means the fibers will take longer to contract and exude albumin. The frustrating part is this is what I'm shooting for and it was actually smoked at a higher temperature in a Bradley Digital:

smoked-sockeye-600px.jpg


The difference is the above salmon was brushed with syrup every hour. That's a little too sweet for me but could also mean the difference between "clean" and "snotty" salmon.
 
 
Great looking salmon! Sockeye is actually very lean compared to Atlantic and King Salmon. I think the higher protein to fat ratio may be part of the problem. More fat means a slower rise in temperature, which means the fibers will take longer to contract and exude albumin. The frustrating part is this is what I'm shooting for and it was actually smoked at a higher temperature in a Bradley Digital:

smoked-sockeye-600px.jpg


The difference is the above salmon was brushed with syrup every hour. That's a little too sweet for me but could also mean the difference between "clean" and "snotty" salmon.
Can't tell you anything other than my results.  Sockeye salmon, no matter what I did, fatted out.  My current efforts with atlantic salmon does not end in the same results.  A google search shows the atlantic with higher fat content than sockeye so it's a conundrum to me. 

I use a Bradley (modified with 1000w in elements) with a PID.  Been smoking salmon/fish for maybe 6-7 years.  But I have an idea (always a dangerous thing).  I haven't done this yet but plan to try it.  I am now using (2) 12" Amazen tubes of pellets to smoke the salmon and they last about 4 hours.  My smokes last about 5 hours to get to my temp of 135-140 IT.  I want to try finishing the salmon with sous vide.  It has the advantage of hitting the target temp no matter the thickness the fish.  I don't normally do tail pieces unless it's a presentation type of thing because they are so thin.  But in sous vide all thicknesses can hit the same temp.  Maybe if sockeye (with a good pellicle) were smoked for "x" time and then finished via sous vide it would fix the fat out issue.  The other thing is that they would already be in vac-sealed bags ready for the freezer if I sous vide them.  I will be doing this, but not for a couple of months.
 
Ah, okay. I see where you're coming from. That isn't fat, it's albumin which is a protein. That's why I was wondering if the lower fat content was the culprit.
 
Well, I guess it's a love/hate thing.  I hate it when I discover something I believed for years is wrong.  But I like it when I learn new things.  So I wondered where I went wrong and went back to my notes.  My salmon smoking process evolved mostly influenced by these 3 links -

http://forum.bradleysmoker.com/index.php?topic=107.0

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/127170/hot-smoking-salmon-throwing-down-the-gauntlet

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/122931/mr-ts-smoked-salmon-from-go-to-show-w-q-view

One calls the white discharge "fat" and the other two refer to it as "oil" or "oils".  But I discovered other links I've saved did spell it out as albumin so that's that.  The information that CrankyBuzzard posted was interesting and cause for this thread to become part of my salmon links.

I do have sockeyes available to me on a regular basis but as you pointed out they always lack in the appearance area.  When I start experimenting with a sous vide finish (for which I have high expectations) I will try sockeyes again.  I wonder if any other members have a sockeye solution.
 
[h2]Is albumin water soluble?[/h2]

All the proteins of the albumin family are water-soluble, moderately soluble in concentrated salt solutions, and experience heat denaturation. Albumins are commonly found in blood plasma and differ from other blood proteins in that they are not glycosylated.

I use a dry brine mixture of cure #1, salt, white sugar and spices to brine/cure my sockeye in.....

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/174537/sockeye-hors-drawers-for-christmas-eve

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/240017/more-sockeye-12-30-money

I'm thinking the water brine solution "may" be contributing to the albumin  leakage...  
 
 
[h2]Is albumin water soluble?[/h2]

All the proteins of the albumin family are water-soluble, moderately soluble in concentrated salt solutions, and experience heat denaturation. Albumins are commonly found in blood plasma and differ from other blood proteins in that they are not glycosylated.

I use a dry brine mixture of cure #1, salt, white sugar and spices to brine/cure my sockeye in.....

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/174537/sockeye-hors-drawers-for-christmas-eve

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/240017/more-sockeye-12-30-money

I'm thinking the water brine solution "may" be contributing to the albumin  leakage...  
You have just added to my experimentation.  Need to try some dry brined and wet brined head to head.  Also need to try the 10 minute and 8 hr wet brine head to head.  I'm seeing lots of sockeye in my future but there are worse things to experiment on.  However, I have never had sockeye come out looking anyway near as nice as that.

Dave, in the first picture in the first link the right side has discharge while the left side doesn't.  Were you experimenting there?  Thanks.  Good thread.
 
[h2]Is albumin water soluble?[/h2]





All the proteins of the albumin family are water-soluble, moderately soluble in concentrated salt solutions, and experience heat denaturation. Albumins are commonly found in blood plasma and differ from other blood proteins in that they are not glycosylated.
 
I use a dry brine mixture of cure #1, salt, white sugar and spices to brine/cure my sockeye in.....
 
http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/174537/sockeye-hors-drawers-for-christmas-eve
 
http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/240017/more-sockeye-12-30-money
 
I'm thinking the water brine solution "may" be contributing to the albumin  leakage...  

And this is why I love SMF!
 
 
 
[h2]Is albumin water soluble?[/h2]

All the proteins of the albumin family are water-soluble, moderately soluble in concentrated salt solutions, and experience heat denaturation. Albumins are commonly found in blood plasma and differ from other blood proteins in that they are not glycosylated.

I use a dry brine mixture of cure #1, salt, white sugar and spices to brine/cure my sockeye in.....

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/174537/sockeye-hors-drawers-for-christmas-eve

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/240017/more-sockeye-12-30-money

I'm thinking the water brine solution "may" be contributing to the albumin  leakage...  
You have just added to my experimentation.  Need to try some dry brined and wet brined head to head.  Also need to try the 10 minute and 8 hr wet brine head to head.  I'm seeing lots of sockeye in my future but there are worse things to experiment on.  However, I have never had sockeye come out looking anyway near as nice as that.

Dave, in the first picture in the first link the right side has discharge while the left side doesn't.  Were you experimenting there?  Thanks.  Good thread.
If we are looking at the same picture, that is the membrane from the belly cavity showing up white.... 

 

The white in this picture is from the fish getting to too high a temperature...  overcooked in my opinion...    I hate it when I mess up....  

 
Last edited:
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky