Prime smoked eye of the round

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

73saint

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Mar 8, 2017
2,016
2,265
Near New Orleans La
Yesterday, when I picked up my belly for Burnt Ends, I saw this beautiful prime eye of the round roast. I’ve been wanting to smoke one, let it cool and slice for Cajun deli meat. Well yesterday be the day, and as good as the pork was, I’m sitting here having my coffee and munching on this cold sliced roast beef and whoa....sooo tasty!!

So here’s what I did. I injected the roast w a roasted garlic mix. That turned out to be only somewhat effective, as Costco blade tenderizes their meat, and injecting was almost fruitless. It was kinda funny actually, every time I injected, liquid would shoot out of the Costco blade holes. Oh well, live and learn. This roast didn’t lack flavor anyway!
04843270-DCA1-4E5D-B4D0-0653144D803E.jpeg
95755B0C-FA7B-47B9-8087-090D9941FB92.jpeg

So I decided to make a garlic butter crust. I took a whole soft stick of butter, mixed a pile of minced garlic, crushed red pepper, parsley, black pepper and Tony’s
A7CE2AB2-45DA-48CD-B266-1F5CAFD82735.jpeg
24C2F58F-E073-4467-B7FF-A9D2DDBD3C4B.jpeg
1E6973EA-DCB4-418B-88F4-E52B775C1A78.jpeg
And here’s the butter garlic crust on the roasts. I placed this back in the fridge to firm up. The end result of this crust was phenomenal.

D9C0BC41-8A67-4BB2-B65D-8524AAC5D2C7.jpeg
I cooked it uncovered in a foil pan with 250 degrees of cherry wood smoke. I would remove pan and baste every 30 minutes or so. I pulled it at 135. Didn’t take long, just under two hours.
BC4D64BC-4FF1-47CD-80F8-95A59A40EC5C.jpeg
229F6E49-CB5F-4CD9-A69E-279E6CE1C087.jpeg
It was hard not to get into it last night. But this morning the wait paid off.

2E8A7352-C547-47FF-BF83-D4396934D2F4.jpeg
E7E83A2C-547F-4097-A8F9-EA731936D017.jpeg 117E1C18-2735-451A-B58C-4BE40EC660BA.jpeg 68DD9367-04A8-4BC3-A1FE-EAE467A79077.jpeg
I see roast beef Sammie’s in our future! Man, if you haven’t smoked a roast beef to medium rare, you don’t know what your missing! I won’t be buying boars head for a while!
 
That looks great . X2 on the Boars head . Home made is cheaper and better ! Do the same with Turkey breast that they want $10 a pound for .
 
Saint, that looks absolutely incredible!! Nice job all around. I've been smoking and slicing my eye round roasts for a long time for sandwich meat and we love it. This looks like it'd beat anything I've done hands down. A couple things you may want to try that we really enjoy are French Dip sammies and Cheese Steak sammies with sauteed onions and peppers.

Looking for the "bookmark" button,
Robert
 
  • Like
Reactions: 73saint
Saint, that looks absolutely incredible!! Nice job all around. I've been smoking and slicing my eye round roasts for a long time for sandwich meat and we love it. This looks like it'd beat anything I've done hands down. A couple things you may want to try that we really enjoy are French Dip sammies and Cheese Steak sammies with sauteed onions and peppers.

Looking for the "bookmark" button,
Robert
Thanks Robert! I think we’re doing French dips tonight, but for now I can get past eating cold slices by themselves!
 
That looks great . X2 on the Boars head . Home made is cheaper and better ! Do the same with Turkey breast that they want $10 a pound for .
Thanks Chop! I can’t believe we hadn’t done it like this before. It’s incredible.
Awesome looking some great sammies on order here.

Warren
Thanks Warren no doubt!
 
I see some open faced RB and gravy sammies in your future(I hope). It looks wonderful Saint.

Point for sure
Chris
 
I see some open faced RB and gravy sammies in your future(I hope). It looks wonderful Saint.

Point for sure
Chris
Thanks Chris. Last night we did French dips w lots of melted Swiss and au jus. Incredible. What I noticed most about the roast is how melt in your mouth tender it is.
 
Thanks Chris. Last night we did French dips w lots of melted Swiss and au jus. Incredible. What I noticed most about the roast is how melt in your mouth tender it is.

Chris picks up towel and wipes drool off chin.

Chris
 
  • Like
Reactions: 73saint
tenor.gif


excellent cook! Looks amazing! LIKE! Do you think you lost some seasoning/crust due to butter melting and falling off? I guess the basting would really help that though. Did you go straight into the pan or on a rack? was the bottom soggy at all?

sorry... really interested in this and curious. On the list for sure!
 
tenor.gif


excellent cook! Looks amazing! LIKE! Do you think you lost some seasoning/crust due to butter melting and falling off? I guess the basting would really help that though. Did you go straight into the pan or on a rack? was the bottom soggy at all?

sorry... really interested in this and curious. On the list for sure!
Right in the pan, no rack. And if you look at the roast when it was finished, all the little bits of garlic and seasoning stayed on the roast, only the butter melted off. The liquid in the bottom of the pan was almost completely clear. No sogginess at all, all I did was let it cool, cover in foil and refrigerate overnight.
That looks fantastic!
Nicely done!!
Al
Thanks Al! It was super!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Misplaced Nebraskan
Right in the pan, no rack. And if you look at the roast when it was finished, all the little bits of garlic and seasoning stayed on the roast, only the butter melted off. The liquid in the bottom of the pan was almost completely clear. No sogginess at all, all I did was let it cool, cover in foil and refrigerate overnight.

Thanks Al! It was super!
Excellent. Thank you. Sounds like a fantastic rub method and want to give a whirl. Much appreciated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 73saint
That looks amazing, I'd be looking for some hard sourdough rolls and drizzling some pesto and a few slices of Provolone and grated Romano over it, all day.
I need to make this for sure.
Thanks for the great idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 73saint
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky