Please help

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Chad Errey

Newbie
Original poster
Jan 21, 2026
5
1
Can anyone tell me what i did wrong?
3lbs single cut Brisket.
Brand new Weber Searwood.
(1) 8-hours @ 225°F
(2) 1-hour Wrapped in Butcher Paper
(3) 2 hour rest.
(4) I did not have a pan of water inside the smoker (I see people do this on YouTube)
(5) I did not spray it (unsure if needed)
It was extremely rough.
(6) Fat side down (did I need to go fat side on top to utilize the fat slowly dripping on the meat?
 
I'm no brisket expert; what was your probe temp after step 2? Or did you pull it by feel?
Yes, I prefer fat up but there are plenty of opinions with good results.

First blush, it was undercooked. (As crazy as that sounds after 8 hours.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 801driver
I'm no brisket expert; what was your probe temp after step 2? Or did you pull it by feel?
Yes, I prefer fat up but there are plenty of opinions with good results.

First blush, it was undercooked. (As crazy as that sounds after 8 hours.)
I pulled it at 185 then wrapped & threw it in till 215 then pulled.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 801driver
The two biggest mistakes folks make with brisket is relying on time and to an extent internal temp(IT) of the brisket.

Time is almost irrelevant and IT is nothing more than a guide to let you know when to start checking for doneness and that is when the meat is probe tender.Having a good thermometer is key to let you know when certain things are happening in the cook,a multi-probe is beneficial as it allows you to monitor both the meat and the smoker temp.For your first point time really doesn't matter which brings us right to the next point.You wrap the brisket when it reaches the "stall" ,without getting to scientific here it's the point in the process where the IT stops to rise.Some just let it ride others wrap to push the process,if you're gonna wrap do it at the stall.The stall can start after just a few hours up to many hours later,generally it tends to happen in 160°-170° range but each piece of meat is different and it can certainly happen outside that range.Adding a little liquid to the wrap can be done if you so desire but I personally don't.

When to start checking for doneness (probe tender)?Again the IT is a guide for this,I generally will start probing for this at 195° but again each cut of meat is different and this very could be as high as 210°+ . Probe tender is when the probe which can be a skewer,a handheld temp probe or even a toothpick goes through the meat like warm butter.Probe tender is when to pull your meat.

Resting is pretty simple.I let it sit on the counter for a short rest and then I wrap in foil,then a few towels and then into a cooler for a very minimum of an hour but you can hold up to 4 hours or more if needed.

Water pan and spritzing,for a lot of folks that depends on your smoker type and in many cases just personal preference.When I use my electric smoker I don't wrap and I personally have never spritzed my briskets.

Fat side up/down?That's a debate that's been going on for a long time,in the scheme of things I don't think it really matters.

As far as your results being tough,as stated above it's underdone.

Some advice,225° isn't a magic number,I do my briskets at 250° - 275° which shaves a few hours off the overall cook time.Get yourself a good quality multi-probe thermometer with hi/lo temp alarms,it's the best tool you can have in your arsenal especially when doing cuts of meat where the IT and pit temp are critical.
 
Last edited:
The two biggest mistakes folks make with brisket is relying on time and to an extent internal temp(IT) of the brisket.

Time is almost irrelevant and IT is nothing more than a guide to let you know when to start checking for doneness and that is when the meat is probe tender.Having a good thermometer is key to let you know when certain things are happening in the cook,a multi-probe is beneficial as it allows you to monitor both the meat and the smoker temp.For your first point time really doesn't matter which brings us right to the next point.You wrap the brisket when it reaches the "stall" ,without getting to scientific here it's the point in the process where the IT stops to rise.Some just let it ride others wrap to push the process,if you're gonna wrap do it at the stall.The stall can start after just a few hours up to many hours later,generally it tends to happen in 160°-170° range but each piece of meat is different and it can certainly happen outside that range.Adding a little liquid to the wrap can be done if you so desire but I personally don't.

When to start checking for doneness (probe tender)?Again the IT is a guide for this,I generally will start probing for this at 195° but again each cut of meat is different and this very could be as high as 210°+ . Probe tender is when the probe which can be a skewer,a handheld temp probe or even a toothpick goes through the meat like warm butter.Probe tender is when to pull your meat.

Resting is pretty simple.I let it sit on the counter until the temp drops to about 170° or so and then I wrap in foil,then a few towels and then into a cooler for a very minimum of an hour but you can hold up to 4 hours or more if needed.

Water pan and spritzing,for a lot of folks that depends on your smoker type and in many cases just personal preference.When I use my electric smoker I don't wrap and I personally have never spritzed my briskets.

Fat side up/down?That's a debate that's been going on for a long time,in the scheme of things I don't think it really matters.

As far as your results being tough,as stated above it's underdone.

Some advice,225° isn't a magic number,I do my briskets at 250° - 275° which shaves a few hours off the overall cook time.Get yourself a good quality multi-probe thermometer with hi/lo temp alarms,it's the best tool you can have in your arsenal especially when doing cuts of meat where the IT and pit temp are critical

The two biggest mistakes folks make with brisket is relying on time and to an extent internal temp(IT) of the brisket.

Time is almost irrelevant and IT is nothing more than a guide to let you know when to start checking for doneness and that is when the meat is probe tender.Having a good thermometer is key to let you know when certain things are happening in the cook,a multi-probe is beneficial as it allows you to monitor both the meat and the smoker temp.For your first point time really doesn't matter which brings us right to the next point.You wrap the brisket when it reaches the "stall" ,without getting to scientific here it's the point in the process where the IT stops to rise.Some just let it ride others wrap to push the process,if you're gonna wrap do it at the stall.The stall can start after just a few hours up to many hours later,generally it tends to happen in 160°-170° range but each piece of meat is different and it can certainly happen outside that range.Adding a little liquid to the wrap can be done if you so desire but I personally don't.

When to start checking for doneness (probe tender)?Again the IT is a guide for this,I generally will start probing for this at 195° but again each cut of meat is different and this very could be as high as 210°+ . Probe tender is when the probe which can be a skewer,a handheld temp probe or even a toothpick goes through the meat like warm butter.Probe tender is when to pull your meat.

Resting is pretty simple.I let it sit on the counter until the temp drops to about 170° or so and then I wrap in foil,then a few towels and then into a cooler for a very minimum of an hour but you can hold up to 4 hours or more if needed.

Water pan and spritzing,for a lot of folks that depends on your smoker type and in many cases just personal preference.When I use my electric smoker I don't wrap and I personally have never spritzed my briskets.

Fat side up/down?That's a debate that's been going on for a long time,in the scheme of things I don't think it really matters.

As far as your results being tough,as stated above it's underdone.

Some advice,225° isn't a magic number,I do my briskets at 250° - 275° which shaves a few hours off the overall cook time.Get yourself a good quality multi-probe thermometer with hi/lo temp alarms,it's the best tool you can have in your arsenal especially when doing cuts of meat where the IT and pit temp are critical.
In testing. Thank you for some more of the knowledge. Been cookin 12 years but up in Canada our smoke game is trash. I guess with that the Searwood 600 I got has a probe and Bluetooth to my phone the entire day. I did see don’t pull until you’re ‘happy with the bark’. I’ll get her dialed in.
 
ALL been covered above--

go by temp not time.
test with a fork as well-buttery or leathery?
Fat up :emoji_thumbsup:
Fat down :emoji_thumbsup: both are supported.
wrap? Speeds up the process IMO

spritz? I don't / some do. I think opening to spritz just lets the heat out and so the cook takes longer (heat has to 'get back to temp again). IMO.
 
This sounds like a flat, flats are difficult. SmokinAl has a flat recipe that folks say nails it every time. I'll see if i can manage the search...

That said, a couple thoughts. A full packer is much easier and more forgiving. 225 the fabled low and slow temp is trash. I run all briskets (full packers) and butts at 275, no spritz or wrap. Just cook till probe tender.
 
Good lord haha thank you! Looks good
The first couple briskets I did were flats. They were not good. Do the FP is by far easier. And you can vacuum seal the left overs for samis, tacos, chili, what ever. Just set it up, run it at 275, probe test when the IT starts to get close to 195 ish. Finish IT varies on every cook.
 
Lots of good advice, mine will be similar to "normanaj", but we each have our own "what works for us" to share for you to consider. Myself, I have never smoked a brisket that small. Mine are normally 10-12lb minimum, but I do have some extra freezer space. When I get down to 3-4 quart zip bags of sliced, it is time for smoking another one. Brisket has so many uses, like noted above. Sandwiches, tacos, chili, baked beans, on a baked potato, home made enchiladas, pizza topping, omelets, nachos, etc.

I agree that you need to practice to fine tune what you have to work with, the equipment you have and then adjust for the particular chunk of meat you have. For me, most of the time lately over the past couple years I use an electric smoker at 225' that has only 250' max but higher temp will work. Use to use a stick burner, but got tired of the 24hr tending, now throw the meat in, set it and forget it till the 200' beeper probe goes off. Find what works for you depending on what you have to work with. Any temp (within reason) will work on the outside of the chunk of meat. What you are looking for is the IT temperature on the inside long enough to make that chunk tender. My electric racks are 16X16, I have to cut a large brisket in half at times to fit two racks. Each rack is done at different times because of thickness.

Time/lb - usually will give you a general ball park within a few hour span (Or longer) of when it might be done, sometimes. Not good to use if you might have guests coming that might plan to eat with sharp forks in hand and your chunk of meat is not ready. (Always prepare the day before) I have had a 10lb brisket really done in 14 hours and another 10lb similar brisket done in 26 hours. IT Temp - will let you know when to start paying attention. I use a remote beeper at 200' to Alert me to this point to know when to start poking with the temp sensor or usually a pronged roasting fork or anything sharp and long all over to feel like butter will tell you when to let it go more at a half hour at a time until that chunk of meat is "really" done.

Each piece of me is different, but you will have a "stall" in temperature holding at 160-170'. Sometime an hour stall, sometimes 3 hour stall. That is when the heat inside that particular chunk of meat is doing its magic. Some people wrap in foil to hurry it. Me, nope, I like low and slow naked. In the past I have wrapped during and after the stall. I have used foil, butcher paper, etc. Seems not worth the trouble to me unless I need to rush it, foil is supposed to speed that up, never could tell the difference all that much. I guess foil might hold the heat in if you opened your lid a lot.

I do mine most of the time without wrapping, it depends if you want very soft mushy "bark" or a little bit dryer "bark." Most of mine gets frozen and microwave reheated which softens the bark, so it is not a big factor to me.

Note. Something I do, especially if not wrapping. Out on the end of the flat where it gets very thin, I fold that flap over (sometimes a little cut on the fold helps) and secure with tooth picks so that it does not dry out. It essentially makes a "thicker" piece of meat to have bark on just the outside.

Next, after you have a really done piece of meat that pokes well is to wrap in a couple layers of foil as you take it off. I have clean but tattered bath towels stored away. One goes in the bottom of my larger standard igloo ice chest, foil wrapped brisket, then another towel tucked around on top. 2 hour minimum, more is better. Once had a "situation" and pulled it out to slice 5 hours later. It was still at 160' and very tender. Had to use a lot if it for chopped instead of sliced brisket it was so tender.

Yep, lots of different ways to do it. Some people juggle temps up and down during cook, wrap or not, not much different than preferring different rubs or seasonings.

Most important is to make sure the IT gets it to poke tender, then It is essential to make sure it stays at that temp to "rest" so that all of the little slivers in between your poke holes stay at that temp and the juices rejuvenate in between while "resting" Good luck to you, and keep us updated with your progress.
 
In testing. Thank you for some more of the knowledge. Been cookin 12 years but up in Canada our smoke game is trash. I guess with that the Searwood 600 I got has a probe and Bluetooth to my phone the entire day. I did see don’t pull until you’re ‘happy with the bark’. I’ll get her dialed in.
In any cooker or even out on a table you could use a propane torch to sear the bark to make it look good. (That is what they do in the TV commercials for the great fast foods) Looks like a big meat patty because it has not been seared to shrink inside.

To me, the meat inside is what is much more important than the bark. Are you going to trim off the bark and only eat it, or are you going to be smoking for the meat and vary the process to make the bark as you would like as a secondary? You can do that with humidity and wrapping. To me, I want to smoke the meat till it is tender done inside with a little stiff bark. I am in Oklahoma USA, so normally I have a lot of humidity. If you are in Canada I would think you might have dryer humidity. You might need to use a water pan inside your smoker (never worked for me), or wrap in foil earlier to hold the natural humidity in after you have Your desired smoke absorption.
 
While this might not be a specific help for this situation, document your cooks so you can keep track of what works and what doesn't. You can use a note book but a lot of us use this site and include picand cook details, even the what we might do differently next time. I look back at my old cooks frequently to remember details and what may or may not have worked. Also when lobbying suggestions, careful not to try too many changes or you may not know which ones helped, I used to make that mistake all the time.
 
I can't recall anyone cooking to 215 sounds like you over did it to me. Did you confirm it was just a flat and if so, def try that link of smokenAl.

When I do a full brisket, I still haven't gotten the flat perfect but I will cut/seal/freeze the flat for chili, stroganoff, etc and the point is hard to mess up and comes out delish
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Clicky