Need opinions on logo

[smokeydrewsky]

#4 really says BBQ to me. It was a toss up between that and #3, but the smoke in #3 looks a little too much like a flower. That's just my opinion. They all look good though.

 

[got14u]

Thanks for all the opinions....I like to hear what other people think.

 

[Bearcarver]

AND !!!
Please don't shoot that cute little kitty !

My wife said that, but I agree,
Bearcarver

 

[que-ball]

It was a toss-up for me between 1 and 3. I didn't even notice the "custom..." line on 3 until I read Scarbelly's post and went back, so definitely make that larger.

IMHO put wispy smoke in the background on 1 for the whole width of the decal, separate western and smoker, and change customer to custom.

 

[Dutch]

I like #1 but change "Customer" to "Custom" and you're there.

 

[badfrog]

I like #4...it is easy to read, but I would add the smoke from #3

 

[smokeguy]

Depends...blacks, greens, purples, blues and such are terribly hard to light up at night with lights behind it, or even with lights shining on it. They just don't stand out very well. So, if you are making a sign for outside and want it lit, I'd have to go for #5. If not, I like #1 with the Custom change for Customer.

 

[rbranstner]

I like 1-4

 

[plj]

I dislike a fantastically cool & artistic logo/sign that I have to guess what the product is. IMO a sign/logo should be:
#1: extremely simple to read, fast to read. ie no fancy fonts, very few words or pictures.
#2: extremely simple to know what the company is/sells.
#3: last and least make it cool & artistic.

IMO its purpose is to communicate very quickly with your customers, its not for you. I liked #1 the best for those reasons.

FYI, I think it's important that you have the word "meat" in it. There are other kinds of smoke and smokers.

 

[polishmeat]

I think #4 would look awesome with the "custom.." wording with the font used in #1, but they look good!

 

[hernando]

I definitely dig 3 for the smoke on the label and the contrast. 4 is good too but not quite there with 3 IMO.

scarbelly, your avatar is hilariously funny and creepy all in one ;)

 

[pandemonium]

i didn't read all the replies but is it just me or does the smoke in #3 also look like bull horns? that was my first impression so that was my choice.

 

[got14u]

Well after much deliberation and all of your comments I tried putting the top three together and here is the final logo...let me know what ya think....and again thanks for ALL the in put.

 

[DougE]

Looks good to me.

 

[smokey paul]

Very well done. Good to add the different elements of the best.
Good luck on your new business...

 

[beer-b-q]

We won't be able to smoke Cheese, Fish, Nuts or Veggies in it since it is only for Meat...

Plus It needs to say "MADE IN USA" on it...


http://i63.photobucket.com/albums/h151/pkcdirect/US_Flags/gbusa41.gif

 

[got14u]

I like that Paul !

 

[caveman]

I like it. It's Smokin!

 

[nbbd]

I them all alot, Did you design them all yourself? What program? they are all very clean...