My Biggest Smoke for the 4th - Looking for Tips

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

islanderjsf

Newbie
Original poster
May 11, 2011
7
12
Cincinnati OH
Greetings All,

I have been planning on a large smoke for the 4th of July for some time now.  I am feeding about 25 people and will be using my Master Forge vertical smoker.   I have done 4 or 5 smokes in the smoker since purchasing and am feeling comfortable with it although for each of those smokes I only smoked one piece of meat usually a 7 pound pork butt or brisket.

For the 4th I am planning on smoking:

2 - 7 lb pork butts

2 - 7 lb briskets

I have a few questions for the group and am looking for any general advise there may be when smoking multiple meats.

Some questions that come to mind:

1) With a party of about 25 people, I assume 28 pounds of meat is plenty.  We have some big eaters but hopefully I am not even close to light on planned amount of meat.

2) I am shooting for a 3 PM eat time so to be safe I am planning to start around 11PM the night before.   1 1/2 hours has rarely been accurate for me as I seem to lock in more around 2 hours per pound...but again maybe things will differ with the amount of meat I am smoking.  I am thinking 10PM should get me done worst case around 2 PM with an hour to rest.   Is my timing reasonable? 

3) Any recommendations on how to stack this meat vertically.  I had planned on both pork butts with fat cap up on the top two racks.   The bottom most brisket with fat cap down and the one above it with fat cap up.   I am assuming this will baste the brisket quite nicely as everything falls downward and the bottom most brisket will be protected with a downward facing fat cap. 

4) Temperature wise is there anything I need to worry about with large quantities?   I am hoping temp is easier to control with all the extra meat maintaining it.   But I am also worried I may be starting too early if things may cook closer to a true 1 1/2 hours per pound.  

5) Toweling - If I end early I will towel everything and again here hoping the multiple meats will help keep temps stable.   I am planning to use only a few towels and throwing everything in the same cooler.

6) Foiling - I am concerned about managing 4 pieces of meat.  I am thinking of skipping the foiling.  Are there strong opinions on this topic?  I certainly don't want dry meat.  If I need to, I'll just do them one at a time and make it work.

7) Lastly, am I over thinking this?  I want to be as prepared as possible.  It's a big smoke with many people.  It must go off smoothly. 

Thanks to all.  I'll do my best to report back with photos after the holiday.
 
Foil securely and tight to keep in the moisture. Depends on time left until chow if you towel wrap or not.

More than an hour I would towel wrap to be safe

It may take a little longer to have the meat get to temp due to the thermal mass and the amount of meat you are cooking.

No exact figure on this one. 

It is OK if the meat is done 4 hour early. Not OK if it is done 1 hour late.
 
110.gif
Watching and learning...
 
1) With a party of about 25 people, I assume 28 pounds of meat is plenty.  We have some big eaters but hopefully I am not even close to light on planned amount of meat. Sounds perfect. Nothing wrong with having a few leftovers.

2) I am shooting for a 3 PM eat time so to be safe I am planning to start around 11PM the night before.   1 1/2 hours has rarely been accurate for me as I seem to lock in more around 2 hours per pound...but again maybe things will differ with the amount of meat I am smoking.  I am thinking 10PM should get me done worst case around 2 PM with an hour to rest.   Is my timing reasonable? Yes, if it gets done early it will stay hot in a dry cooler, wrapped in towels for hours.

3) Any recommendations on how to stack this meat vertically.  I had planned on both pork butts with fat cap up on the top two racks.   The bottom most brisket with fat cap down and the one above it with fat cap up.   I am assuming this will baste the brisket quite nicely as everything falls downward and the bottom most brisket will be protected with a downward facing fat cap. Sounds good.

4) Temperature wise is there anything I need to worry about with large quantities?   I am hoping temp is easier to control with all the extra meat maintaining it.   But I am also worried I may be starting too early if things may cook closer to a true 1 1/2 hours per pound. If you don't open up the smoker & just let it go the extra meat will not make a difference. The only difference will be in the beginning when you put it all in, it may take a little longer to come back up to temp.

5) Toweling - If I end early I will towel everything and again here hoping the multiple meats will help keep temps stable.   I am planning to use only a few towels and throwing everything in the same cooler. If you have towels on the bottom & on the top with the meat in the middle it should be fine.

6) Foiling - I am concerned about managing 4 pieces of meat.  I am thinking of skipping the foiling.  Are there strong opinions on this topic?  I certainly don't want dry meat.  If I need to, I'll just do them one at a time and make it work. I don't foil anymore, but that's a personal preference. It will take longer to cook if you don't foil. You may want to just see how everything is cooking & if it looks like you need to get it done then you can always foil.

7) Lastly, am I over thinking this?  I want to be as prepared as possible.  It's a big smoke with many people.  It must go off smoothly. No you are not over thinking, you are being very smart & very prepared. Good luck to you & let us know how it turns out with pics of course.
 
Thanks to all for the interest and the responses.   My barbeque went off very well.   I originally was hoping for 7 pound items in my smoker but my butcher had only 8 pound pork butts and 9 pound briskets for a total of about 32 pounds of meat.   I started the process around 10PM the night before and was quite upset to see a near 100 degree difference between my top rack and bottom racks as I had two thermometers going.   The temps got closer but long story short is I was probably smoking around 205 for most of my cook throughout the night.    This certainly added to the cook time.  

Briskets ended first (I assume since the flat is thinner than the rounder pork butts and they were closer to heat source) with the pork finishing only an hour behind.   Brisket cook time was 16 hours with me pulling at about 205 degrees.   Pork was 17 hours coming out at 199 and 195 respectively. 

Being that I hosted 6 family members and was up all night I was a little tired and did a poor job with my quevision.   I'll do better next time but did take a few snaps.  

Thanks again to everyone for the help.   Nothing but raves on the food so a complete success.

1ded43d0_DSC01837.jpg


Final product here.  I just totally forgot to snap pics as I was real excited to get people fed.  At least I got something before the food was eaten. 

006801a3_DSC01839.jpg


27fbd0b0_DSC01840.jpg


7072fd93_DSC01841.jpg
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky