looking to buy my frist pellet smoker

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

jimv112563

Newbie
Original poster
Jul 6, 2013
22
10
NY
Hi all I have been on this site for about 2 yrs and been smoking meats for the same amount of time. My first smoker is a small webber barrel smoker that I love to use from march to November .I am thinking about getting a treager renegade but not sure are there any other pellet smokers for around the same price that are good I should check in to before I commit thanks
 
What are you looking to do with the smoker that is different to what you are doing now? Does it have to be a pellet smoker?
 
well was looking to smoke more then I do because of outside temps and work thought that with pellet smoker I could put larger cuts in before work and then wife could keep an eye on it its easier for her to add pellets to a hopper then coal to my webber
 
There a lot of choices out there. I've got a Green Mountain Grill, Danial Boone. I've had some minor issues that customer service handled ASAP.

Like any type of smoker, there is a learning curve. I like my GMG. Use it 2-3 times a week. Puts out great Q.
 
I have a GMG and as mowin said def has some minor issues but customer service is fantastic and you learn how to tweak your machine. Temp readings aren't great at all but I believe it's an issue with most electric machines. Get a maverick and you'll learn how to set the right temp on the machine. I chose the GMG based on a slight pitch in the barrel and higher temps compared to traeger. Good luck!
 
My Traeger Renegade Experience

After months of debating over several propane verses charcoal grills I happen to come across the Traeger Renegade Grill Infomercial. Usually I’m not a infomercial sucker believing everything I see on all the capabilities of the believe it or not commercial. So I researched and researched. After reading the heaps and heaps of positive reviews and experience with the Traeger brand I was compelled enough to drop $835.

I was hoping to get the Renegade in before the Memorial Day holiday but unfortunately the grill did arrive until 3 days later. Never the less I was excited to get it together and started. I had a 7lbs Boston Butt all ready to get started. I got the Renegade assembled, in place and primed. Only step left was to season, per the manual instructions. About 10 minutes through the process I walked out onto my deck to see the paint dripping from the bottom of the barrel. Thinking to myself, “that’s not good!” I unplugged the grill and called Traeger Renegade Customer Service. I keep saying Traeger Renegade because I’m not 100% that the Traeger and Traeger Renegade are the same company. I would venture to guess that the name was licensed to borrow the creditability of the “Traeger” name to sell the Renegade series. I make that assumption because of the actions following my experience described doesn’t match a company that has been in business as long as “Traeger”

After a 15 minute wait on hold, I finally got a CSR on the line. I explained to him the issue. His question to me was, “what was the temperature of the the thermostat when you unplugged the grill?” I told him I wasn’t sure that I was more concerned with the melting paint and my deck getting burned down, it could’ve been 425 it could’ve been 475. The CSR’s assessment was that the paint of the barrel was defective. He asked that I email support via email with pictures. I asked what the process would be, how fast would I receive a replacement, and how I would need to box the defective grill for return. The CSR informed me that their policy was to only replace the defective part. What!? The grill has only been in my procession for less then 4 hours. “How do you know its the paint? It could be the controller the thermostat, the feeder. I didn’t pay $835 for a defective grill and have to disassemble and reassemble because you think it’s defective paint. I want the grill completely replaced,” I explained. The CSR told me he didn’t have the authority to authorize a replacement and that I would need to discuss with support. Fair enough.

So I emailed support, including all of the pictures of the bottom, front and serial number plate. Rejected email was the response. After several attempts I determined that I couldn’t send more than 1 picture at a time. Sending a picture and explanation of the issue and what I excepted to remedy the issue, FULL REPLACEMENT, I received a response asking the usual information where, when and serial number of the purchase. About 10 emails later asking for more pictures and multiple angles I get this response as a resolution:

“Thank you for that information. I have put in a replacement order for a new barrel. Unfortunately, the barrels are on a little bit of a backorder. We are estimated to get some back in stock in a couple weeks and the order will ship as soon as we have them. I also included a rub for any inconvenience this may cause.”

Are you kidding me!? 

Let’s recap: 1. Spend $835 on the Traeger Renegade Grill 2. Receive Renegade grill 2 weeks later. 3. Grill over heats and paint melts off of the grill within 4 hours of taking delivery. 4. Request replacement 5. Told that they would only replace the barrel (per policy) which is 3 weeks on back order but would send me some “rub” for my inconvenience.

I requested a full refund!

After several emails I finally received a UPS notification for pick up, boxed and packed per instructions of the CSR. Two weeks after pickup, they have their defective grill and my money. I am now filing a dispute with my credit card company to reverse the charge for the $835 I paid for the Traeger Renegade grill.

End result, I did some additional research and found the Green Mountain Grill, Daniel Boone. In my opinion this is a much better grill. Construction is better, stainless steel parts verses the painted, cooking area is larger and it has wifi to control cooking and get alerts on temp, hopper and food temp from my phone or tablet. The best part, it was over $100 less expensive!

In my opinion, do yourself a favor and save lots of frustration, money and just buy the Green Mountain Grill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: darwin101
I bought a Traeger Pro 22 on 4/15/17 and with all the extras I spent 999.99 .  I have had nothing but trouble . The fire goes out in the middle of a smoke and the temps swing 78-80 degree from what it is set at . Customer service sucks . They did send me a new controller and the did not solve the problem . Finally I bought an aftermarket controller for my traeger and all my problems went away . I highly recommend a Savannah Stoker controller if you have a traeger pellet grill but its a real shame you have to spend $180 to make a $1000 pellet grill work like it is supposed to .... GRRR
 
For those guys with the "newer" Traegers, sorry for your luck.  Traeger sold out to a Chinese company a few years back, and the quality of their smokers has pretty much gone into the toilet.
I have a "pre-sale" Traeger, that has served me well going on 7 years (this is my 7th summer), but from all I have read about them now, I would not recommend a Traeger to ANYONE!.

Point is, depending on what you want to spend, and how long you want it to last, there are FAR better pellet smokers out there.  I have been checking out and researching what I want to replace my Traeger with (it's close).  If you're willing to spend the money on a superior cooking device, I would suggest a Mak or a Yoder.
Pretty sure my next pellet smoker will be a Yoder 640.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky