In Jay Kenji Lopez Alt's book "The Food Lab" thats basically what he said about non-stick, but there have been some new products since then. The life of the standard non-stick is somewhat driven by the utensils used with it. I cringe every-time I see a chef on TV that is supposed to know what they are doing use a bare metal wire whisk in a nonstick pan!
But I've been through both cheap and supposedly better made 12" square griddle style pans that get "scratchy" somehow even though I never use bare metal on them. Weird. Only thing I can think of is the crusty bread from when I make Reuben's, etc. is scratching them, because that, sausage patties, pancakes and eggs are about the only thing those pans are used for.
We have a Pampered Chef set that has lasted for a couple of decades that is finally starting to wear. Thing is, I can’t find the exact size of one of them made by anyone, including PC anymore, and I am partial to the specific size and shape of the 4 quart. If you’re facing similar issues, you might want to contact
princess house customer support for help. The term "they just don’t make stuff like that anymore" literally applies and it’s a simple pan!
I'm also man enough to admit I have a 12" non-stick pastel blue Pioneer Woman skillet! From Walmart, and its a great skillet.