Let's go! First brisket

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

tuxer

Newbie
Original poster
Sep 16, 2016
7
10
Chicagoland Area
Beautiful weather in Chicago and wanted to get at least one more smoke in before it gets too cold.  I got my first smoker (MES 30) about two months ago and have only done two smokes so far.  They turned out OK, but definitely learned a few things from each.  I've been documenting every little thing I do so I can get better.  I always planned on doing threads for my other smokes but forgot and didn't take enough pictures, this time I'm doing a little better.  Let's go on a little journey...

Unfortunately I didn't start the process until yesterday morning, so I didn't let it sit in the rub for 24 hours and things like that.  I know I should've but didn't have time.  I did let it sit in an au jus I'm going for (beef broth, wine, worcestershire, apple juice and some of the rub) for about 10 hours.  Pulled it out, started the MES at 7:30 while I rubbed the flat.


Temp got up to 225, added water to the pan, put the au jus in the bottom to catch drippings and threw the flat on at 8PM.  Using hickory chips with a little apple (AMZNPS is on my list to get soon).  Wish I had mesquite but apple is the only other I have.


Every hour I refilled and spritzed with apple juice until midnight (4 hours) at which point I did one more set of chips, removed the au jus pan and probed the meat (Maverick ET733).  IT was up to 142 at this point.


I think I should've added more water before passing out because the outside looks a little dry, but I'm also hopeful this looks normal.  Checked the IT at 3am or so and it was 149.  Woke up at 7 and IT was still 149.  Spritzed, added more water to the pan and snapped another pic.


I'll keep an eye out on it in case I need to spritz again, otherwise the door will be closed until it's ready to be pulled.  It seems it got passed the IT 149 plateau finally at 8:15am, the temp is now at 154!  I plan on removing it at 200, wrapping and throwing in a cooler for 2 hours that I've read so many times to do.  I've got all day and not in a hurry, but I'm estimating it to be at 200 around noon.  I want to slice some of it and do a few chunks to turn into burnt ends, but overall I'm going to shred it so I need it very tender.  I'll give an update and final pictures later.  Hope this turns out better than the first 2.  Brisket was good though I pulled it too early and ribs just came out a little dry, tough and way too smokey.

Bonus pics...


The brisket that turned out pretty good, definitely learned a few things for the next.


Ribs, a few wings to try and some taters.  Didn't care much for this and probably will stick to the charcoal for ribs.  I'm sure I'll give it one more attempt with some of the things I learned, but I just don't think I cared for smoked ribs.
 
Now that is looking good! Looks like the other smokes did well too.

Don't fret over rubbing and putting it in the pit, you're good. The hard dark stuff, that's bark, you'll love it if you like burnt ends!

Keep going with the plan you have, you'll nail it.

Looking forward to how this one ends!
 
What didn't you like about the ribs? With some info someone maybe able to help you out!
 
Thanks guys.  It's now 2:30, IT at 174 and I'm growing antsy.  18 hours seems like quite a bit for an 8ish lb flat.  I don't know how you guys stay patient during this.  I keep wanting to take it out and foil but I'm sticking to my guns and not touching it.

b-one, they came out dry on the outside and too smokey.  The family didn't care much for the smoke flavor but I think it was a little too thick anyways.  Next time I cook them I'll charcoal but set aside one rack for the smoker to try again.  When I do, I'll definitely post to see what I did wrong and get recommendations.  I read up, did the 3-2-1, spritzed, etc.  They even looked great, just didn't come out too tasty.
 
Thanks guys.  It's now 2:30, IT at 174 and I'm growing antsy.  18 hours seems like quite a bit for an 8ish lb flat.  I don't know how you guys stay patient during this.  I keep wanting to take it out and foil but I'm sticking to my guns and not touching it.

b-one, they came out dry on the outside and too smokey.  The family didn't care much for the smoke flavor but I think it was a little too thick anyways.  Next time I cook them I'll charcoal but set aside one rack for the smoker to try again.  When I do, I'll definitely post to see what I did wrong and get recommendations.  I read up, did the 3-2-1, spritzed, etc.  They even looked great, just didn't come out too tasty.

Stay strong, you'll be glad you did!


What smoke did you use for the ribs last time that were too smoky?
 
Stay strong, you'll be glad you did!


What smoke did you use for the ribs last time that were too smoky?
I used mostly apple but with a little hickory.  I think I was using too much, and maybe too often because after a little research I was getting a thick white smoke, not the "TBS" I recently learned.  So I found some suggestions for MES and implemented them with this beef which was much better.

------------

Final update...

It was 4:30 and the temp had only gotten to 178.  I had to pull it out and foil it, poured in some apple juice with the rub and put it back in.  Unfortunately, I felt I had to and I'm glad I did because I assume that had I left it going, it could've been even more dry on the inside.

Left it in until IT hit 200 (which was at 5:30).  Pulled it out, wrapped a towel and threw it in a cooler for an hour as we watched "Rookie of the Year" in celebration of the Chicago Cubs.  Didn't have time to cut a few chunks for burnt ends but we're OK with that for now.  Here's the end pictures...

Fat Side


Meat Side


Pulled


Overall, very happy with my third smoke.  Give it a 7/10, wish it had been a little more juicy and tender, but the taste was great.  I had some finishing sauce left over from the pork I did a few weeks ago and that was even good with this.  Thanks for the input everyone, this was a success and only makes me want to do another.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky