Great Barbeque in New York City

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

whtplainssmoker

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
Apr 9, 2011
346
15
White Plains, NY
Generally, I know that everyone here is the master of their own smoker and that our home results are better than you will find at any restaurant.  But, if you happen to be in NYC and crave some great southern Q with a cool atmosphere and didn't bring your smoker along for the trip, be sure to check out "Southern Hospitality" BBQ in Hell's Kitchen, 45th street and 9th ave in Manhattan.  I'm not going to post a link, but a simple google search will pull it up. We took our dad there this weekend for his 70th Birthday and the food was great.  I usually don't go out and post about restaurants, but we had such a great time and the food was so good, I felt I had to post something.  Good Q is hard to find in NYC.  My wife and I found a decent place "Q" in Portchester NY which is near our house that has some very good ribs and pulled pork.  As for NYC, Virgils (which is in Times Square is ok, but kind of touristy), Dallas BBQ is cheaper but mass produced.  Blue Smoke is also pretty good (been there myself) but this place was much better.    

For appetizers, we deep fried pickle chips (excellent) and catfish lollipops (delicious).  For the main course, My mom and I had fried chicken and waffles (i've always wanted to try that and knew I would be making pulled pork this weekend) it was great.  My wife tried the pan seard jumbo gulf shrimp with corn salsa and cheddar cheese grits, outstanding.  My sister tried went for the fried chicken (without the waffles).  But the big winners were my dad who tried the "Wet/Dry rib platter" which gave him Memphis Dry rubbed ribs and St. Louis Baby backs, and my brother and his wife who tried the "Over the Top Combo Platter"  which included a half rack each of Wet and Dry Memphis-Style Spareribs, a half rack of Baby Back Ribs, and 1/2 BBQ Chicken plus 4 sides.  Below are photos of my dad and brother admiring their plates.

e2de01b3_IMG_1600.jpg


506eab41_IMG_1599.jpg


Apparenlty, they smoke all their meats using a blend of Hickory and Cherry.  The results were excellent for a restuarant, but after tasting the ribs (which were very good) my wife turned to me and said, the ones you made last week were better.  So thanks again to SMF for making me the chef who outcooked a celebrity owned restaurant. 
 
You would think with all the cattle that are in New York and I would guess a good amount of pigs, there would have excellent BBQ, but maybe more out in the western part of the state.
 
I'm a downstater.  In the Subburbs of NYC.  Smoking takes time, and everyone around here is in a rush.  My guess is that is why there's not a lot of great BBQ in the immediate NYC area.
 
Great Mike thanks i will try it at my next visit to NY .i was not impressed with dallas BBQ last time. and to shlep the smoker from south africa is too much.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky