Cold Smoked - Reverse Seared Cowboy Ribeye

Discussion in 'Other' started by stewie-q, May 15, 2015.

  1. Greetings All,

    I'd been hearing a lot about the reverse sear technique on steaks lately.  All rave reviews - so naturally I had to see what all the hype was about.  This was my adventure.  

    1.8# Cowboy Ribeye - cold right out of the fridge. 

    Hit it for two hours with cold mesquite smoke.  Temps in the smoker started broaching 100 degrees, so I added another rack in the MES and put a bowl of ice directly above the AMNPS.  Kept smoker temp down @ 90 degrees. 

    Heavy dose of SnP and Garlic - Ready for the oven

    Baked on a rack @ 275 for an hour and 15 mins.  IT Goal 135

    Rested for 15 Mins

    Sear in smoking hot cast iron skillet.  1 min per side

    Ready to slice

    It came out an even medium.  Next time I'll try for 125 IT for a bit more rare. 

    Dinner is served!  Note the evenness of the finished temp.  Medium throughout. 

    Overall I was very pleased.  Smoke flavor came though nicely.  Like previously stated - I would bake a little less time and reach for a 125 degree IT.  
  2. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    looks good [​IMG]
  3. dirtsailor2003

    dirtsailor2003 Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Tasty looking smoke! I prefer my steaks to be rare- medium rare, so when I do a reverse sear I usually pull them from the smoker when they hit 115°-120° (assuming heat is being used in the smoker) then sear each side quickly. When I cold smoke then sear my smoker temps never get above 40°-42°. I do this with pork chops and steaks that we then pack ad freeze for later use. Next time you give it a whirl do a traditional cowboy grill and throw that steak right on a hot bed of coals!
  4. mdboatbum

    mdboatbum Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Nice looking steaks! I'd say next time you can save yourself a step and set your smoker to 225°, still use the pellet tray and take the steak to your target temp right in the smoker. Should take around 2 hours. Then rest and sear in the skillet just like you did. It'll take on plenty of smoke and no need to fire up the oven.

Share This Page