Beef Tenderloin (Hickory Smoked for Mother's Day)

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Bearcarver

Gone but not forgotten RIP
Original poster
OTBS Member
Group Lead
Sep 12, 2009
45,243
18,192
Macungie, PA
Beef Tenderloin (Hickory Smoked for Mother's Day)

Due to normally high prices, this will be only the fourth time I’ve ever made Beef Tenderloin in my Lifetime!!
So this was what they call Australian Grass Fed Beef for $5.99 a pound. We didn’t notice a difference, so that’s fine with me. We got two full Tenderloins.

I cut a piece off of each Tenderloin, from the biggest end, just small enough to fit in a 9” X 11” Foil pan. Then I sliced the rest of the Tenderloins into small steaks for me & Mrs Bear for future Fillet Mignon Dinners.

Prepping:
I bagged & froze everything but the biggest end of the biggest Tenderloin to smoke for Supper.
So I rinsed that 4.3 pound hunk off, and patted it dry.
Then I coated it with Lea & Perrins Bold Steak Sauce, and CBP, Garlic Powder, and Onion Powder.
Then I put the roast on a wire cooling rack, in a Foil Pan.
I do this so the Smoke can still get underneath, and it also won’t be sitting in any fat or juices.
Then I put it in the fridge, covered with plastic wrap, to await the next day Smoke.

Smoking Schedule (Target Supper @ 4PM)
11:00—Pre-heat MES to 220°
11:00—Fill 2 rows of my AMNS with Hickory Dust & light one end.
11:30—Put Pan of Meat on Rack #2 of my MES, and my AMNS on the right end of the bottom rack (pull chip dumper out 2” & rotate 180°).
1:30—-Wipe Maverick Meat Probe with alcohol wipe & insert into thickest part of Meat.
1:30—-IT 113°
2:00—-IT 124°
2:30—-IT 129° Cut heat back to 205°
3:00—-IT 134°
3:30—-IT 136°—-Open Door until Heat gets down to 150°.
3:45—-IT 138°
3:50—-IT 138°—-Cover with foil & bring into kitchen.
4:00—-Slice enough for the two of us, add Potatoes Au Gratin & Green Beans.
Take final Pics & Eat.

After eating I cut the rest up into small steaks, packed it all in Vacuum Bags, and sealed for Re-heated meals for Mrs Bear & Myself. I kept two meals worth in the fridge & froze the rest.


Thanks for stopping by,

Bear

Two Beef Tenderloins (10.64 LBS):
IMG_2145.jpg


On sale @ $5.99 lb:
IMG_2146.jpg


Coated with Lea & Perrins Bold:
IMG_2148.jpg


All Seasoned before over night rest in Fridge:

IMG_2149.jpg


Two Rows of Hickory Dust, lit one end:
IMG_2161.jpg


AMNS & Maverick probe in place, waiting for Meat:
IMG_2162.jpg


Through the looking glass at the start:
IMG_2164.jpg


Waiting for yard to get dry enough to mow:
IMG_2165.jpg


Time to Bring Inside:
IMG_2166.jpg


Slicing 3 Center slices for Supper:
IMG_2168.jpg


The chosen ones:
IMG_2170.jpg


Bear's first Helping:
IMG_2173.jpg


Sliced the rest for future meals:
IMG_2175.jpg


5 future meals for freezer:
IMG_2178.jpg
 
Last edited:
What a fantastic looking meal! LIKEE!

I noticed the 5/18/18 "Sell by" date on the label. Most likely that was the reason for the deep discount. Keeping track of those when shopping can save a bunch of money.
 
$5.99/lb.:) I would have bought them all at that price. The best I ever see is $8.99. We bought one last week and broke it down into filets for the freezer. Smoked and reverse seared two for last Sunday dinner. Most excellent.

SWMBO has decided that it is time to diet (again). It is putting a real cramp in my smoking adventures.
 
That looks fantastic Bear! Another amazing plate. Amazing price too. I can see the juiciness of the meat in the bags. Those leftovers are going to be perfect for the sous vide!
 
What a fantastic looking meal! LIKEE!

I noticed the 5/18/18 "Sell by" date on the label. Most likely that was the reason for the deep discount. Keeping track of those when shopping can save a bunch of money.


Thank You Ray!!
We actually bought these last Friday, on 5-11, and this was our Mother's Day Dinner.
I forgot to mention that, but I added it to the title now.
Thanks for the reminder, and for the Like.

Bear
 
Last edited:
Wow !! Fantastic I know they had a great flavor and melt in your mouth tender.
If the rest are frozen, you could overnight me on package and it should be fine :)

Like for sure

Gary
 
Bear I always buy them an even lower price at times. Yours looks fantastic I would be all over that plate.Thanks for sharing. Likes
Richie
 
Man that looks amazing! Points on the smoke!

I wish I could find tenderloin for that price! Cheapest we get is $9.99 and that's only maybe once or twice a year!
 
$5.99/lb.:) I would have bought them all at that price. The best I ever see is $8.99. We bought one last week and broke it down into filets for the freezer. Smoked and reverse seared two for last Sunday dinner. Most excellent.

SWMBO has decided that it is time to diet (again). It is putting a real cramp in my smoking adventures.


Thank You Braz!!
Yeah, I've paid $10.99, $7.99, $6.99, and now $5.99.
I'll bet I don't see that again!
As for the Diet, it seems when I eat Steak, I lose weight. I think it's because I can't eat as much steak as I can of other things.
When I was young I would lose weight when I'd drink a lot of Beer, because when I got home I wasn't hungry, and the next day I didn't feel like eating, and the Beer would just go out the other end.

Bear
 
Holy cow Bear, those look fantastic. We can find them once in a while on sale at our little mom-n-pop store here, but they are allot smaller in size. Great job.

Point for sure.

Chris
 
That looks fantastic Bear! Another amazing plate. Amazing price too. I can see the juiciness of the meat in the bags. Those leftovers are going to be perfect for the sous vide!

Thank You Jared!
Yup---I heated a couple in the Broiler, and One in the Frying Pan, but I believe the rest are gonna be SV.

Bear


It must be . As soon as I brought up the picture , the dog came a runnin !
]

Cute!!
Is that an Aussie Dog?

Bear
 
Last edited:
Wow !! Fantastic I know they had a great flavor and melt in your mouth tender.
If the rest are frozen, you could overnight me on package and it should be fine :)

Like for sure

Gary


Thank You Gary!!
That might work up here in our 48°, but probably wouldn't make in that 98° Texas Heat.
And Thanks for the Like.

Bear
 
Bear I always buy them an even lower price at times. Yours looks fantastic I would be all over that plate.Thanks for sharing. Likes
Richie


Thank You Richie!!!
Less that $5.99---OMG !!!
And Thanks for the Like My Brother.

Bear
 
Man that looks amazing! Points on the smoke!

I wish I could find tenderloin for that price! Cheapest we get is $9.99 and that's only maybe once or twice a year!


Thank You Vol !!
These were $5.99, and right next to them were the Angus Beef Tenderloins for $15.99. (on sale down from $17.99)

Bear
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky