what wood do you use to smoke?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Smoke-Chem BBQ

Meat Mopper
Aug 20, 2021
169
236
I use apple, pecan, oak, hickory, mesquite, maple, charcoal, cherry.
sometimes blends of those and sometimes just a single variety , just like to try different methods.
I do the same. I have six of those you mentioned, I think I'm lacking maple. Since I use a WSM, I just need to keep one bag each of hardwood chunks from the big box stores on hand--it doesn't take up a lot of space.

I seem to go through apple, pecan and cherry the fastest, mesquite I use quite sparingly.
 

fltsfshr

Meat Mopper
Sep 8, 2015
239
405
I am also a cherry & pecan fan. My favorite hands down when I can get it is pimenta wood. It grows locally and whenever a tree trimmer I know gets it he brings it to me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JC in GB

tallbm

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Dec 30, 2016
6,932
3,942
Texas
so... what wood does everyone use to smoke with - pellets, sticks, chunks, whatever... i've done some extensive reading online and everyone seems to like hickory, but i can't stand the smell of it when its burning or the taste it imparts to the meat. am i just weird?
Hi there and welcome!

I use pellets, my smoker is a highly modified MES40 with a PID controller.
Pellets allow me to mix/match, etc. and pair whatever wood I want with whatever food goes best with the wood flavor. This is a huge perk I get to enjoy because flavor is everything!

I enjoy hickory but not nearly in the amounts most people use it. I basically don't go over 65% Hickory in anything with the exception of doing 100% Hickory bacon.
I find that 100% Hickory on other food makes it tasted kind of like Bacon to me. If I'm making ribs, chicken, beef, etc. I want those flavors. If I want bacon flavor I'll smoke and eat bacon lol.

After lots of tinkering, here are my wood meat pairings for the best flavors I have made:

  • General go-to when not sure what to use - 65% Hickory and then Equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Favorite Mid Strength Flavor - 100% Maple pellets, not a fan of Oak because it's used way too much on everything in my area
  • Beef - 100% Mesquite pellets. Hands down, mesquite flavor with beef is the best meat/wood combo of all meat/wood combos out there!
  • Chicken or Turkey - 65% Hickory, equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Pork - 65% Hickory, equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Most Sausage - 75% Apple, 25% Hickory pellets
  • Bologna or Pastrami - 100% Maple
  • Bacon - my fave is 75% Apple, 25% Hickory pellets. HOWEVER I will do 100% Hickory on this one item if wanting pure hickory bacon
  • Salmon - 100% Alder pellets
  • Meatloaf - 25% Alder 75% Mesquite (I am using up an old bag of Alder/Mesquite blend pellets and I add more Mesquite)

Pecan wood pellets is one that I don't really care for. They are soo weak for some reason. I don't really use them on anything but may just blend them into stuff to get rid of the 40 pounds I have lol.
I have tried them plenty of ways but never find them to be better than anything else above.

As you can see I have lots of options and combos. I have really enjoyed figuring out wood and meat combos. I still pick up and try wood pellets every now and again but usually when I run low on another bag or blend that I am trying to get rid off. For example I have a bag that is a blend of Charcoal and Oak pellets and it's ok on the pork ribs I used but didn't wow me either.

Looking forward to trying Plumb and Almond wood pellets because I can get them locally. I just need to move thorugh about 40 pounds of pellets before I can add those to my collection hahaha.

I hope this info helps :)
 

jcam222

Legendary Pitmaster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jun 13, 2017
8,529
9,437
Northeast Ohio
I use fruit wood 99% of the time. I have a ton of cherry, apple and pear right now. Frankly I see very little flavor difference in those vs oak. Now if you venture into hickory or mesquite for sure I can tell. I am planning a load of hickory soon.
 

MadMax281

Meat Mopper
SMF Premier Member
Jul 15, 2017
155
84
Texas
Mini splits of White & Red Oak.
 

Attachments

  • 20221029_120843.jpg
    20221029_120843.jpg
    161.9 KB · Views: 4

1MoreFord

Smoking Fanatic
Jan 4, 2020
688
360
Arkansas
Back when I had a stick burner I mostly used Oak of any sort. Burned some Hickory and Mesquite too. Also tried a little Pecan with my Akorn.

Now that I have a pellet grill it's LumberJack Hickory mostly.
 

netspyder

Smoke Blower
Original poster
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Thread starter
Dec 18, 2022
78
87
Collinsville, IL
Hi there and welcome!

I use pellets, my smoker is a highly modified MES40 with a PID controller.
Pellets allow me to mix/match, etc. and pair whatever wood I want with whatever food goes best with the wood flavor. This is a huge perk I get to enjoy because flavor is everything!

I enjoy hickory but not nearly in the amounts most people use it. I basically don't go over 65% Hickory in anything with the exception of doing 100% Hickory bacon.
I find that 100% Hickory on other food makes it tasted kind of like Bacon to me. If I'm making ribs, chicken, beef, etc. I want those flavors. If I want bacon flavor I'll smoke and eat bacon lol.

After lots of tinkering, here are my wood meat pairings for the best flavors I have made:

  • General go-to when not sure what to use - 65% Hickory and then Equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Favorite Mid Strength Flavor - 100% Maple pellets, not a fan of Oak because it's used way too much on everything in my area
  • Beef - 100% Mesquite pellets. Hands down, mesquite flavor with beef is the best meat/wood combo of all meat/wood combos out there!
  • Chicken or Turkey - 65% Hickory, equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Pork - 65% Hickory, equal parts Maple and Cherry pellets
  • Most Sausage - 75% Apple, 25% Hickory pellets
  • Bologna or Pastrami - 100% Maple
  • Bacon - my fave is 75% Apple, 25% Hickory pellets. HOWEVER I will do 100% Hickory on this one item if wanting pure hickory bacon
  • Salmon - 100% Alder pellets
  • Meatloaf - 25% Alder 75% Mesquite (I am using up an old bag of Alder/Mesquite blend pellets and I add more Mesquite)

Pecan wood pellets is one that I don't really care for. They are soo weak for some reason. I don't really use them on anything but may just blend them into stuff to get rid of the 40 pounds I have lol.
I have tried them plenty of ways but never find them to be better than anything else above.

As you can see I have lots of options and combos. I have really enjoyed figuring out wood and meat combos. I still pick up and try wood pellets every now and again but usually when I run low on another bag or blend that I am trying to get rid off. For example I have a bag that is a blend of Charcoal and Oak pellets and it's ok on the pork ribs I used but didn't wow me either.

Looking forward to trying Plumb and Almond wood pellets because I can get them locally. I just need to move thorugh about 40 pounds of pellets before I can add those to my collection hahaha.

I hope this info helps :)
this is awesome! i never thought to use maple, i guess mostly because back in the 90's i bought some "maple syrup bacon" and it literally smelled like maple syrup in the house for weeks, and now when i see the word 'maple' it just brings back those memories. i did 25lbs of pastrami with mesquite/cherry in november, and everyone liked it - i just handed off a frozen pack to a friend, and am waiting to hear how it aged in the freezer - but the smoke flavor was very 'in your face'. not overpowering the coriander, but imo it could've been a bit more background.
 

netspyder

Smoke Blower
Original poster
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Thread starter
Dec 18, 2022
78
87
Collinsville, IL
I like hickory for Back bacon , Mostly mesquite for most meats,
or mesquite and Hickory together
will add in or only cherry or Black cherry for some great colour
If smoking desserts I will use fruit woods

But that is what I have played with so far

David
smoking desserts? i'm intrigued! what kind of desserts do you smoke?
 

DRKsmoking

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jan 27, 2021
5,868
4,674
Middle Sackville, Nova Scotia ,Canada
smoking desserts? i'm intrigued! what kind of desserts do you smoke?

Hi netspyder
I have done a few desserts in the smoker
Pecan Pie thanks to the help from Jake TNJAKE TNJAKE , i have also done bacon cheese pineapple donuts, strawberry cake and the strawberry sauce also in the smoker, Toffee Apple cake, etc

DSC_2327.JPG DSC_2328.JPG DSC_2334.JPG



Do a search in the search button in the right upper corner for some desserts done by others also


David
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TNJAKE

Dustin Dorsey

Fire Starter
SMF Premier Member
Sep 25, 2016
36
35
Depends. I cook on a WSM and an offset. On the offset I'm limited to what types of wood I can get locally. That usually falls into pecan or oak. The oak is just whatever the tree services happen to cut down, no usually a specific species like post oak. I really love both, but I'd say I use pecan the most often. On the WSM, I get a little more experimental. I've ordered wood from Fruitawood and I'll use apple, peach and cherry on pork. On beef I stick to oak and pecan. I do like hickory as well, but it's extremely rare that I get it.
 

tallbm

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Dec 30, 2016
6,932
3,942
Texas
this is awesome! i never thought to use maple, i guess mostly because back in the 90's i bought some "maple syrup bacon" and it literally smelled like maple syrup in the house for weeks, and now when i see the word 'maple' it just brings back those memories. i did 25lbs of pastrami with mesquite/cherry in november, and everyone liked it - i just handed off a frozen pack to a friend, and am waiting to hear how it aged in the freezer - but the smoke flavor was very 'in your face'. not overpowering the coriander, but imo it could've been a bit more background.
Glad you found the info helpful!

Yeah, I like Maple quite a bit. In my researching for various sandwich meats I've made it always seems that Maple is the original or most common used.

Also I really liked the Maple flavor when I had first started trying to find Mesquite pellets and the Louisiana Grills brand did like 30% Mesquite but the rest was Maple. I really liked the Maple flavor and explored from there as I also continued to look for 100% Mesquite.

Glad I discovered how much I like it and Maple quickly became my replacement for anything/everything Oak is used on.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads