Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
I used Hickory for the first time in my wsm and I didn't get much of a smokey flavor . I normally use Apple wood . Is it the hickory was old or that it is not very pungent ? I bought the wood from lowes and applied it to my smoke for two hours of a 7 hour "Chuckie" smoke.
I started with red maple gathered on a friend's property. I use a lot of apple, sometimes hickory. Oak is a bit strong for my taste. Not much pecan or cherry available here.
I've heard of smoking with grapevine, but I've never tried it,
I often think about using another flavor, but come time to load my AMNPS---In goes the Hickory.
Yesterday I filled 2 rows of my AMNS with Hickory Dust. I was running out after about 6 hours, and didn't feel like going to the garage for more Hickory. I had a jug of Apple Dust in my storage bucket next to my MES, so I added about 5" in the last row of Apple to complete my CB Smoke.
If you want to really taste the smoke or get a nice "smoke ring", you'll need more than a couple hours. I like Hickory, but the Mrs. thinks it's too strong for anything but pulled pork. We use a lot of Apple and Pecan.
I also think that you need a longer smoke exposure. No one has said anything about your wood source, but it's my opinion that the bundles of wood at Lowe's, Ace, etc. are kiln dried and a lot of the flavor has been used up. I prefer to get locally cut wood and let it air cure.
Maybe someone else has a different opinion or more scientific opinion of kiln dried wood, but that's my $0.02 worth. Good luck and good smokin', joe