• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

What to do with a beef tenderloin

SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

BugHunter

Fire Starter
Joined
Jun 6, 2026
Messages
61
Reaction score
25
Location
PA
Last year, my sister went to a market where we buy a fair bit of pork and chicken, and they had beef tenderloin at some price I can't recall, but it was less than my local packing plant. I said yea, grab one, in spite of the fact I know the place sells select beef and I'm a bit of a beef snob. Usually buy from a local farmer. But I thought, how bad can a tenderloin be. Well, it's pretty dark red, and had I known, I would not have had her pick it up. It's been in the freezer. I'm not likely to make it as a roast, I generally do America's test kitchens recipe for horseradish crusted tenderloin, but I really like a better piece of beef for that. So I wondered if anybody had a recommendation for what to do with it in the smoker. I have 1/2 of a local cow brisket she gave me to make pastrami again. In the interest of using things up, what do you folks advise.

For your appetite encouragement, here's the very first one I made in 2014 if I recall correctly. (must edit with phone to add the pic).
 

Attachments

  • Beef Tenderloin.jpg
    Beef Tenderloin.jpg
    281.9 KB · Views: 7
Last year, my sister went to a market where we buy a fair bit of pork and chicken, and they had beef tenderloin at some price I can't recall, but it was less than my local packing plant. I said yea, grab one, in spite of the fact I know the place sells select beef and I'm a bit of a beef snob. Usually buy from a local farmer. But I thought, how bad can a tenderloin be. Well, it's pretty dark red, and had I known, I would not have had her pick it up. It's been in the freezer. I'm not likely to make it as a roast, I generally do America's test kitchens recipe for horseradish crusted tenderloin, but I really like a better piece of beef for that. So I wondered if anybody had a recommendation for what to do with it in the smoker. I have 1/2 of a local cow brisket she gave me to make pastrami again. In the interest of using things up, what do you folks advise.

For your appetite encouragement, here's the very first one I made in 2014 if I recall correctly. (must edit with phone to add the pic).
Here is a thread from one of great members...although I believe he is now into competition shooting and around much anymore.

 
Here is a thread from one of great members...although I believe he is now into competition shooting and around much anymore.

Cool thanks!
I use to do that, competition shooting that is... Great minds think alike!
 
Flash cook the tenderloin medallions and make a Tuscan creamy pasta. So good.
 
Flash cook the tenderloin medallions and make a Tuscan creamy pasta. So good.
Term I'm not entirely familiar with, at least not in context. Beef tenderloin medalian was the name of a dish I recall was served at a local restaurant here when I was in my 20s. The place was a family outfit where the one son went to school at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris to become a chef. Menus were hand written by his mother, and the menu of the day was never more than 6 items. Pretty much, "This is what we're having", and that was it.

That was pieces though, served it was these seared hunks of beef in this divine BC sauce, but nothing you needed to break into smaller pieces.

What exactly are you referring to? In my case, I've got the entire roast in one piece in the freezer. So, to make a medallion as I think you're saying, I'd need to thaw, cut it up and refreeze... Was hoping to do something with all of it. And I'm sure it's not choice beef where it's a quality cut. It's pretty red...
 
IMO tenderloin is going to be a very tender cut regardless of grade since its more about the lack of muscle use and not marbling. I'd personally trim off the chain for tips then cut that into 1.5-2" steaks wrap in bacon and grill. Maybe make a nice bleu cheese or gorgonzola sauce for it.
 
Reverse sear, or just sear nice thick steaks. Steak au poivre is always good.
 
For your appetite encouragement, here's the very first one I made in 2014 if I recall correctly. (must edit with phone to add the pic).

ACCORDING TO YOUR BIO YOU'D HAVE BEEN 14 YEARS OLD IN 2014, MUST HAVE BEEN MAKING PRETTY GOOD MONEY AS A TEENER TO AFFORD THAT FILLET ROAST. I'LL JUST LEAVE IT AT THAT, FOR NOW. RAY
 
ACCORDING TO YOUR BIO YOU'D HAVE BEEN 14 YEARS OLD IN 2014, MUST HAVE BEEN MAKING PRETTY GOOD MONEY AS A TEENER TO AFFORD THAT FILLET ROAST. I'LL JUST LEAVE IT AT THAT, FOR NOW. RAY
not to derail this thread but, I dont buy cut filets anymore. I have never been able to stomach buying a filet roast. The cost is too extreme
 
onally trim off the chain for tips then cut that into 1.5-2" steaks w
I was hoping to do something like use it for pastrami or some other smoked item. Thing about a tenderloin is they don't really have much flavor unless you add it to it.
not to derail this thread but, I dont buy cut filets anymore. I have never been able to stomach buying a filet roast. The cost is too extreme
I've never purchased a prime one, but choice was never too bad in the past. I could get them around 8 pounds or so for about $75. Not an everyday thing, but a real nice holiday item. Crusted and then served with a horseradish whipped cream sauce, mmm mmm.

ACCORDING TO YOUR BIO YOU'D HAVE BEEN 14 YEARS OLD IN 2014, MUST HAVE BEEN MAKING PRETTY GOOD MONEY AS A TEENER TO AFFORD THAT FILLET ROAST. I'LL JUST LEAVE IT AT THAT, FOR NOW. RAY
When I joined, had simply googled some questions and I'd never even heard of the site, so I wasn't aware that I needed to file a 4506T with my profile info. You can safely assume I wasn't 14... Sue me.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Back
Top
Clicky