• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Thinking of Going Charcoal... Two Questions

maloff28

Smoke Blower
123
17
Joined Mar 21, 2011
I have a second gen MES40 and I am growing a bit frustrated with it.  I keep getting flare-ups and gray smoke.

The only way I have figured out to get around it is to add a palm full of soaked chips about every 45 minutes.  That is much more attention than I want to give my electric.

I know a lot of folks have had great success with the AMNPS, but I also see a lot of folks having to do a lot of tinkering to get that right as well.

So... I used a friends WSM 22.5 a few weekends ago and really liked it.  Most importantly, I thought it produced a better quality result. Smoke ring, bark, etc.

I am thinking of selling my MES 40.  To partially finance a charcoal smoker purchase.  Any thoughts on what I should ask?

Also, I am leaning toward the WSM 22.5, but honestly have not heard much about other options.

Any thoughts and advice on what to sell for and what to buy would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you.

Seth
 

loock28

Fire Starter
40
10
Joined Oct 9, 2012
thats what I did but got the 18.5 weber. And I love it best smoker I have ever had!
 

chef willie

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
3,199
364
Joined Dec 31, 2010
Go to you tube and check out 'pit barrel cookers' for some 'thinking outta the box alternatives' to WSM, which is quite an investment. Some can be made fairly easily, if you're of that sort, or purchased for about 200. I'm in the middle of a 'build' so to speak with mostly things I've had in the garage for years & I'm pretty challenged with things like that. I will admit, it's taken the edge off a big itch I had to buy a pellet smoker which ran $700. I'm only out about 50 bucks so far for various Home Depot stuff....Willie
 

squatch

Meat Mopper
160
52
Joined Jul 15, 2013
While researching the purchase of my first smoker I had narrowed it down to the same two possible choices... MES 40 or 22.5" WSM.

 Ultimately I decided on the WSM, and I am very happy with it! A little spendy for a coal burning bullet smoker perhaps, but the quality and consistent ease of use make it a good value IMO... I am now browsing classified ads looking for a good deal on a lightly used 18" WSM to keep the 22.5" company!
 

hagisan

Meat Mopper
180
11
Joined Jul 5, 2011
I concur with luv2putt.  WSM!  And like Squatch, I'm always hitting up CL to hopefully find another WSM at a good price.
 

dewetha

Smoking Fanatic
737
16
Joined Aug 21, 2011
you can never really go wrong with a weber product.  in the same price range you can get a Costco Vision Komodo.

i love my gas grill and smoker and make good food for  years but i going back to all charcoal(lump). having both at the same time. Charcoal adds a depth of flavor you don't get on gas.

you need more proof that Turkey Hotdogs!

the quality of smoke ring on  a brisket i get with my Kamodo vs my masterbuilt gas is no contest.
 

bama bbq

Master of the Pit
2,353
70
Joined Sep 24, 2011
My son built a UDS but I have Webers. There's a huge following on the web, repair parts from weber, amazon, and ereplacementparts, and you cannot beat Weber Customer Service.
 
Last edited:

pc farmer

Epic Pitmaster
Staff member
Administrator
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
15,285
4,760
Joined Feb 17, 2013
Uds is a cheap and great smoker.

Just need some mechanical skills to build.

Be able to read a tape measure and use a drill.
 

nodak7mm

Newbie
4
10
Joined Jun 17, 2008
Just had my masterbuilt 30 crap out after 2 yrs and 1 month.  Horrible customer service received..  Going to WSM.  Been using a weber one touch grill for 11 yrs and its still going strong..  Weber all the way for me..

Rod
 

pc farmer

Epic Pitmaster
Staff member
Administrator
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
15,285
4,760
Joined Feb 17, 2013
Not hard at all to build.

Can you read a tape?

Do you have a drill?
 

timberjet

Master of the Pit
3,542
157
Joined Jan 29, 2010
Love the idea of the UDS, but I've got no skills...
I have three webber bbq's and they are the bomb. But imho the smokey mountain is a bit pricey and all it is is a glorified UDS. There are several how to threads on this site somewhere that will take you through all the steps. I would suggest it might be fun and then you would have some skills. haha
 

pc farmer

Epic Pitmaster
Staff member
Administrator
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
15,285
4,760
Joined Feb 17, 2013
You don't need that to make a uds.

I bought their charcoal basket.

Hd and lowes has everything else you will need
 

timberjet

Master of the Pit
3,542
157
Joined Jan 29, 2010
Home depot carries the perfect size expanded metal near where they keep screen material, I know this because it took two hours for me and the guy to find when I built mine. If you keep your eyes open you can get A barrel for near free or free.I built mine with two racks and had maybe 80 bucks in it.
 

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.