Steak sauce

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
I haven't seen Pickapeppa around here in years...I used to keep a bottle (LOVED it!), but it disappeared from the shelves and I haven't thought about it in a long time.

Looks like Winn Dixie has it in stock...I shall have it tomorrow! HOPEFULLY, the mfgrs haven't screwed it up!
Been seeing it at Kroger and Walmart
 
There was a time when I was a huge H-57 fan, used it on most everything. I still use it on burgers occasionally, but now I'm on the "no sauce on steak" side of the fence...
 
I'll keep some steak sauce in the fridge for burgers and etc. And sometimes I just a hankering for the taste and will use a little to dip a bite or two of steak in.
Jim
 
Country Bob's is a pretty amazing steak sauce. I use it when going to one of the "Greek" low cost steak houses or when steaks are overcooked.

It was local to us here in central Missouri but has been spreading into new markets

1676308928280.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLeonard
Been a long time since I used steak sauce but I did like it, used many posted here. Always wanted to try using A1 as a jerky marinade. Steak sauce talk reminded me of this and not sure if you guys did this but parents and in laws ran these often. We called them breakfast steaks but served at dinner. Not sure what cut they actually were but were on the thin side and pan fried in butter. Steak meets pork chop sorta. They would almost always be served with sauteed onion and mushrooms on top. Plate would typically be bfast steak, homefries or hash browns, and either baked beans or peas. Been kinda craving it actually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLeonard
It was local to us here in central Missouri but has been spreading into new markets
All the Country Bob stuff is good . You should be able to find the Andria's I talked about above . Good stuff . Used more as a brush on grilling sauce . Great on chicken thighs .
Nothing like A-1 .
 
  • Like
Reactions: JLeonard
My best friend and I have been friends for about 55 years. That's despite the fact that he drowns every steak in A-1 sauce. I will use it occasionally on a sub-par steak. (Yeah, I still produce a clunker now and then. I blame the cow.)
I have another friend that marinates chicken in Heinz 57, before putting it on the grill. That's pretty good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcam222
We like Steak Diane sauce so we make that alot. On a Chateaubriand We like a Mornay with green peppercorns. Texas Hold Em sauce for a tomato base is good too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcam222
My best friend and I have been friends for about 55 years. That's despite the fact that he drowns every steak in A-1 sauce. I will use it occasionally on a sub-par steak. (Yeah, I still produce a clunker now and then. I blame the cow.)
I have another friend that marinates chicken in Heinz 57, before putting it on the grill. That's pretty good.
Yep. This is why I still keep A1 in the fridge. I still know how to totally frig up a steak sometimes. But yea, it's the cows fault for sure. Sometimes they just don't know when to get off of the grill before they get nuclear.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Brokenhandle
I'm firmly in the no sauce group when it comes to a good steak. If anything, I occasionally add some demi glace or a compound butter when the steaks are finished.

Many years ago a friend helped me with a pretty arduous moving task. When we finished I offered him some cash, but he refused. So, I treated him at dinner at a very high end steakhouse. When the steaks arrived, he asked the server for some ketchup and I somewhat jokingly told hem that if he was going to put ketchup on a $50 steak he could pay for it himself. He passed on the ketchup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Newglide
All people's taste palettes differ in what is a good and needed to complete a meat meal.
Wife likes A1 now and then.
I love the 57 on venison and pork.

I like St Elmo’s horseradish on every 3rd or 4th bite of prime rib from time to time .
Oh a nice schmear of horseradish across a london broil is my idea of perfection
 
All people's taste palettes differ in what is a good and needed to complete a meat meal.
Wife likes A1 now and then.
I love the 57 on venison and pork.


Oh a nice schmear of horseradish across a london broil is my idea of perfection
57 on a burger was a go to for me for a long time. Sure I’d still love it
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky