• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

San Francisco Sourdough

SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

sandyut

Legendary Pitmaster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Joined
Feb 18, 2015
Messages
8,590
Reaction score
7,532
Location
Colorado
My SD is pretty good, not bragging just been told that. I bought some from a local baker and hers was nearly identical to mine in sourness, chew etc.

But there is a bread store that sells a San Francisco SD loaf that is very sour and delicious. They charge a ridiculous $18 a loaf. I dont buy it but I have been gifted some.

My question is: Is the sourness inherent to the to starter or is there some process I am not doing?
 
I'M A 4TH GENERATION SAN FRANSICO BOY, I THINK IT HAS A LOT TO DO WITH THE AREA. THE FOG ROLLS IN OVER THE HILLS COMING RIGHT OFF THE PACIFIC OCEAN, IT'S A LITLLE MICROCLIMATE. I'VE TRIED MAKING MY OWN SINCE MOVING, TRIED NUMEROUS BRANDS MADE ELSEWHERE, NOTHING COMPARES TO WHAT COMES OUT OF THE BAY AREA, JUST THE WAY IT IS.
 
IT GREW UP 25 MILES SOUTH OF SF IN REDWOOD CITY. PAISANO BAKERY WAS A LOCAL LEGEND THERE BACK IN THE DAY. COLUMBO WAS ANOTHER GREAT BRAND AS I RECALL. I THINK THEY'VE ALL GONE THE WAY OF THE DODO BIRD. THE WAY HOUSING HAS GONE WORKING FOLK CAN'T AFFORD TO LIVE THERE ANYMORE, NO ROOM FOR NEW HOUSES. NEVER NEEDED A WATER SOFTENER, IT ALL CAME FROM HETCH HETCHY RES. WATER, FOG, OCEAN, HILLS, WHO KNOWS, WAS THE BEST.
 
IT GREW UP 25 MILES SOUTH OF SF IN REDWOOD CITY. PAISANO BAKERY WAS A LOCAL LEGEND THERE BACK IN THE DAY. COLUMBO WAS ANOTHER GREAT BRAND AS I RECALL. I THINK THEY'VE ALL GONE THE WAY OF THE DODO BIRD. THE WAY HOUSING HAS GONE WORKING FOLK CAN'T AFFORD TO LIVE THERE ANYMORE, NO ROOM FOR NEW HOUSES. NEVER NEEDED A WATER SOFTENER, IT ALL CAME FROM HETCH HETCHY RES. WATER, FOG, OCEAN, HILLS, WHO KNOWS, WAS THE BEST.
I grew up in Orinda, Carmichael, Sacramento etc. My dad worked in SF and when we moved north he traveled there often for work and always brought me back a loaf of Boudin. I love that stuff!
 
I grew up in Orinda, Carmichael, Sacramento etc. My dad worked in SF and when we moved north he traveled there often for work and always brought me back a loaf of Boudin. I love that stuff!
WE MOVED TO ELK GROVE RIGHT NEXT TO SACTO WHEN THE BAY AREA GOT TOO CROWDED. WHEN THAT GOT CROWDED WITH TRAFFIC WE MOVED TO GILBERT AZ FOR SEVEN YEARS UNTIL THAT FILLED UP. FOUR MONTHS BACK WE MOVED TO ALPINE TEXAS, ONE STOPLIGHT IN TOWN. NO TRAFFIC, NO CRIME, NO HOMELESS, FRIENDLY FOLKS, LOVE IT HERE!
 
WE MOVED TO ELK GROVE RIGHT NEXT TO SACTO WHEN THE BAY AREA GOT TOO CROWDED. WHEN THAT GOT CROWDED WITH TRAFFIC WE MOVED TO GILBERT AZ FOR SEVEN YEARS UNTIL THAT FILLED UP. FOUR MONTHS BACK WE MOVED TO ALPINE TEXAS, ONE STOPLIGHT IN TOWN. NO TRAFFIC, NO CRIME, NO HOMELESS, FRIENDLY FOLKS, LOVE IT HERE!
I hear ya! We live in a small mtn town where people care about their neighbors and the community. Love it here too. these places are not the norm, sadly.
 
WOW, I like sour dough . But at $18 per poaf , or depending on how thick you slice it . Thats a couple bucks a slice , and thats US $, lol


David
I know it! I would never spend that on bread. My neighbor does and gifts it to us sometimes. Its insanity.

A couple other local bakers sell their SD for $8-$10. Swirled rye at Kroger is $5. The cost of food in general is bananas.
 
I know it! I would never spend that on bread. My neighbor does and gifts it to us sometimes. Its insanity.

A couple other local bakers sell their SD for $8-$10. Swirled rye at Kroger is $5. The cost of food in general is bananas.
You are right there Dave.

I am going to see if I can get the starter you sent me going again. There should be some still in the back of the freezer.

Love that SD.

David
 
You are right there Dave.

I am going to see if I can get the starter you sent me going again. There should be some still in the back of the freezer.

Love that SD.

David
Nice! I just keep it in a jar in the refer. Ive let it go for months then a couple feeds and discards and it fires right up.

Our temp should be dropping soon to "make bread weather". I need to get more going soon.
 
My SD is pretty good, not bragging just been told that. I bought some from a local baker and hers was nearly identical to mine in sourness, chew etc.

But there is a bread store that sells a San Francisco SD loaf that is very sour and delicious. They charge a ridiculous $18 a loaf. I dont buy it but I have been gifted some.

My question is: Is the sourness inherent to the to starter or is there some process I am not doing?
Have you tried starving your starter, Dave?
The starter I forgot north was very ripe with lactic culture and developed a serious hooch even in the fridge between feedings.
 
Have you tried starving your starter, Dave?
The starter I forgot north was very ripe with lactic culture and developed a serious hooch even in the fridge between feedings.
I generally leave it in the fridge over the summer for months at a time. Its always been pretty consistent.
 
is there some process I am not doing?
Just curious what your method is . Not suggesting you'll get San fran results by changing them , because I don't think it's possible without being in that enviroment .

I've been messing around with a dough conditioner . I did 3 split batches last week , so 6 half loaves .
First one was done the day of . No over night .
Bob's Redmill bread flour .
It was good .
20261106_180350.jpg
Next was KA ap flour . Mixed and held over night .
Next morning , let it warm up , then do some stretching / folding .
30 lid on , then lid off until I like the color .
20261108_153713.jpg
20261108_153725.jpg
The dough conditioner gives a nutty flavor to the crust .
Just overall the results I'm looking for .
20261108_182038.jpg
Next one was mixed then held in the fridge 3 days . This one went a bit long in the oven .
I was having a " Discussion " with the Amazon driver .
20261112_160529.jpg
This had an improved " tang " to it , but they all have that to some degree .
20261112_180804.jpg
These were all mixed the same day , and all had the conditioner in them .
Only difference was the flour for the first one , and length of fermenting in the fridge .
From none , to overnight , to 3 days .
 
this is the recipe I follow:
  • 100g Starter
  • 350g water
  • 500g flour
  • 10g salt

  • Mix water, starter, and salt. Add flour.
  • Autolyse at room temp about 1 hour
  • Lift and fold
  • 20-25 the first time (usually more)
  • 3 more lift and fold sessions 30-60 minutes apart
  • Bulk fermentation at room temp
  • @68 degrees this is overnight and into next day @24 hours
  • Lift and fold to make a loose ball
  • Place ball in rice floured banneton
  • Final proof in refer overnight
  • Bake: 425 covered for 25-30 minutes
  • Remove lid and bake till desired color is achieved.
  • Cool on rack at least 2 hours
 
Never heard of SD conditioner.
It's an in general dough conditioner . For breads , pizza , what ever .
Yeah , I like it . More than that I was wonderinmg if you ferment the dough at all ?

Edit : just saw the above post . The alert took me here first .
That mix is right about what I use .
I mix and go right into a container , then into the fridge overnight . Sometimes days .
I stretch and fold the next day , or the day it comes out of the fridge . Doesn't need much . Then into the basket to rise about 2/3's , then into oven . The extra time in the fridge changes the flavor in my opinion .
 
It's an in general dough conditioner . For breads , pizza , what ever .
Yeah , I like it . More than that I was wonderinmg if you ferment the dough at all ?

Edit : just saw the above post . The alert took me here first .
That mix is right about what I use .
I mix and go right into a container , then into the fridge overnight . Sometimes days .
I stretch and fold the next day , or the day it comes out of the fridge . Doesn't need much . Then into the basket to rise about 2/3's , then into oven . The extra time in the fridge changes the flavor in my opinion .
I will look for the dough conditioner. From what AI said sounds like it would be a good addition
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top
Clicky