The negative comments re: Pitmaster's is dead on as far as I'm concerned.
The show was just plain bad. It is more fun watching one of Food Network's recap of BBQ contests, like Memphis in May or the Reno's big Rib fest...
The thing that seems to be missing is a overall driving force, besides just cooking good enough for that one contest. Maybe, following 10 teams that compete on a national level, that are competing for a overall prize. after X number of events are completed. $100 K to the winner, no 2nd or 3rd just money to 1st place. You can be sure with that kind of money on the line, there would be some drama without having to manufacture it.
Still I have the DVR set to record Pitmaster's series.