• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Packer or Flat?

kingofbother

Newbie
20
10
Joined May 1, 2009
My question is: Which is a better value; buying a packer and trimming the fat off or buying a flat already trimmed.  

I've found that the packer right now at walmart is 2.69/lb (was 1.98/lb) but at my meat market I can get a flat for 4.99/lb.  I've always wondered, by the time I trimmed off the fat before smoking and then considering the amount of fat that I don't eat after cooking, is it basically the same price. 

Has anyone done an research on this? 

Thanks. 
 

eman

Smoking Guru
Staff member
Moderator
OTBS Member
5,309
129
Joined Feb 3, 2009
I don't bother w/ flats at all any more.

 The fat is what gives you flavor. Also if you smoke the packer and seperate the point you can make burnt ends. (that's worth it on it's own).

A packer is also easier to smoke w/o drying it out.
 

alblancher

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Group Lead
4,166
62
Joined Mar 6, 2009
Eman,

Was that a flat that ShooterRick did at the gathering?  It was pretty darn good. 

I normally do packers also and trim after smoking but if I can get one to come out as good as Rick's did I'll change over to flats in a heartbeat.
 

coacher72

Smoking Fanatic
371
14
Joined Mar 16, 2010
Haven't done the research but I agree with the others. I've only done packers and I've never had one come out dry. And as they said the fat adds to the flavor.

As a guess, I would say if you catch the packers on sale for less than $2.00/lb, you would be money ahead.
 

kingofbother

Newbie
20
10
Joined May 1, 2009
how much fat do you trim off?  I usually keep 1/4 inch on the flat.  I've never separated the two pieces.  That fat in between is pretty gnarly. 
 

cowgirl

Legendary Pitmaster
OTBS Member
7,642
46
Joined Oct 2, 2007
I prefer whole packers... the fat I DO trim I set on top of the flat side to render even more flavor into the meat. 
 

alblancher

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Group Lead
4,166
62
Joined Mar 6, 2009
Before or after smoking?  I just do a rough trim on a packer before going in the smoker.  Sometimes that fat cap is an inch and a half thick.  I'll take it down to 1/4 or 1/2 inch depending on mood.  After it's smoked I'll give it a much better trim before slicing.  All depends on how much fat you want on the plate.

The food network had a bbq comp on last night and the contestants trimmed most if not all the visible fat.

I found out this morning that my wife thinks I serve my pulled pork too damp.  Not necessarily fatty just to juicy.  Everyone else loves it.  Next time I do a couple I'll take one and trim the devil out of it both before and after smoking then pull it.  Its tough when someone complains that the meat is to moist when I work so hard to keep it that way.
 

SmokinAl

SMF Hall of Fame Pitmaster
Staff member
Moderator
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
45,571
6,806
Joined Jun 22, 2009
Sorry bout dat, Al   
 

alblancher

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Group Lead
4,166
62
Joined Mar 6, 2009
Anybody that's been married a while knows how I felt. 
 

oldschoolbbq

Legendary Pitmaster
OTBS Member
9,361
200
Joined Jul 16, 2008
Kingofbother,I have it cheaper to get a whole Packer. I don't trim, but let it render down through the meat(I smoke it Flat down and Thick end toward the heat),Cowgirls way works , but me being lazy I leave it on;simple S/CBP and on @ around 220*F for 1.5hrs. per pound. It's the bomb around my neck of the woods


Have fun and remember,
 

55499

Fire Starter
30
11
Joined May 21, 2010
I think the only way to answer your question would be to weigh the whole packer after trimming it, but before smoking. Then get your calculator out.  Let me try some algebra here, might make me dizzy.

Whole Packer @$2.69/lb

Flat @4.99/lb.

PACKER  = FLAT.

   $2.69x = $4.99y.

           x = 1.85y 

So to break even you would need a trimmed, presmoked whole packer to weigh 1.85 times more than the flat that is trimmed by the supermarket.

Now here's the test. Let's say you buy a whole packer  that weighs 15lbs in the bag ($40.35).  You then trim away what fat you would prior to smoking and weigh it.  Then you need to separate the flat from this same brisket and weigh it by itself.  If the whole packer trimmed is not at least 1.85 times heavier than the flat portion you took off, (of course this is assumin your flat cutting is equal to what the butcher at the supermarket would do) then you paid too much. 

I think I got that right, my head hurts.  However, intuitively, I would say that the whole packer is a better value, you get more meat because of the point, I imagine a meat market has to grind that meat up or throw it away after separating a flat.  So in that individual flat you are paying for prep/cut work as well as discarded meat that you don't get to eat or make delicious burnt ends from.  And you get to control the amount of fat that covers your flat portion, as opposed to the butcher determining that for you.
 

arnie

Smoking Fanatic
649
14
Joined Feb 20, 2010
I agree with 55499, I think, but he gave me a head ache too
 

No one told me there would be math questions

I prefer doing packers, but I had a flat I once threw in on top of a packer.

It slowed the smoke way down which I wasn't expecting, but it turned out being one of the best I've ever done
 
Last edited:

athabaskar

Smoking Fanatic
309
11
Joined Nov 21, 2007
Two trains leave their respective stations 36 hours apart on the same track going 1mph headed toward one another. One starts a packer, the other a flat, both at 225* in identical smokers using the same rub and the same mesquite for smoke. After 18 hours they meet head to head. After the dust settles from the 2mph combined speed head-on collision, which tastes best?

I'm going with the nice, juicy, fully rendered packer. 

I'll even allow for the flat to be removed from the smoker for tasting at any point along the way. The packer still wins.

Also, the remaining fat is easily scraped away from the meat on the packer without having to do any pre-trimming.
 

oneshot

Master of the Pit
SMF Premier Member
1,322
13
Joined May 30, 2009
I prefer packers.... As a matter of fact I'm workin on one right now and will be posting it when it's finished. I'll be posting Qview of how I trim and seperate the point along with finished pics.... 
 

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
  AdBlock Detected

We noticed that you're using an ad-blocker, which could block some critical website features. For the best possible site experience please take a moment to disable your AdBlocker.