It's thigh time I fired up my smoker...

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Gonna Smoke

Smoking Guru
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Sep 19, 2018
South Carolina
...pun intended. Friend gave me A BUNCH of short thighs, 30 to be exact, as long as I would cook them for the gang. For those that don't know what a short thigh is, they're the ones without the back attached like a leg quarter has. At least that's what I grew up hearing. Anyway, I decided to brine them and smoke them. A few hours in a basic brine and then the rubs. Half got a Kansas City style rub and the other half got an all purpose rub. Into the refrigerator overnight last night.
thumbnail (9).jpg


Time to fire up the smoker with a mix of White Oak and Cherry. Rolling smoke.....just not the right smoke YET....
thumbnail (6).jpg

After an hour or so, the smoke looks better and the smoker is up to temperature at about 275℉-300℉. Needs to be hotter, but we got to eat sometime tonight. Can't see it, but there is smoke coming out of the stack. Instead of thin blue smoke, it's invisible clear smoke.
thumbnail (1).jpg

Time to cook.
thumbnail (5).jpg

Maybe a couple of hours or so at about 275℉-300℉ and they're ready for some sauce. Internal temps are right around 160℉. The KC rubbed thighs get a sweet red sauce and the all purpose rubbed thighs get a Carolina Sweet Heat sauce, both courtesy of Sticky Fingers. Yes, I took the easy way out. Pile on the wood, open all the doors and vents, and crank up the heat to about 375℉-400℉ to set the sauce, maybe 30 minutes at the most. Internal temps are now above 170℉, but hopefully nothing is ruined. By the way, I did leave a few thighs naked for the kids.

Next up is potatoes and onions for a side. Yellow potatoes are sliced about 1/2" thick and placed in a pot of water to start them cooking. I bring the pot up just to the point of boiling and then shut it off. Just leave the potatoes in the hot water for a while until the onions are ready. Vidalia onions are cut into chunks or wedges and put in a big skillet with EVOO and bacon grease. Now tell me, who doesn't keep a bowl of bacon grease in their refrigerator? :emoji_grinning: May not be the most healthy thing, but it adds a lot of flavor.

Let the onions soften a bit and then add the potatoes.
thumbnail (12).jpg

Let everything get happy and caramelized and crusty. Stir, but not too much or it will take forever to get crusty.
thumbnail (11).jpg

This is the color I'm looking for. Simply seasoned with coarse salt and fresh ground pepper.

So my wife always needs a vegetable, something green if you will. Well fresh local summer squash and zucchini are starting to become available. Cut them on the diagonal into 1/2"-3/4" slices and into a bowl to get tossed with EVOO and coarse salt & pepper. Put them on a pan and into a 450℉ oven just until they get soft and get a little color.
thumbnail (4).jpg

thumbnail (10).jpg

Well the gang's all here so let me go say the blessing and eat.

As a note, the chicken skin was sort of crispy, but tough. At least it was not rubbery. Hard to bite through so I need to work on that, probably higher cook temp to start? I believe thighs do better on a charcoal grill, but I don't have one big enough for 30. As for vegetables, I roast almost everything after tossing in EVOO and salt & pepper. Usually I roast in the oven, but I have been known to put whatever vegetable I'm cooking in an aluminum pan and put it on the smoker or just place it straight on the grill over hot coals to sear. I have tried to smoke vegetables not in a pan and they were not any good at all.
Last edited:
Chicken looks great! And so does that pan of taters and onions!

Nice job!
Beautiful, man!
Around here that's how thighs come. We just call them thighs.
Your simple approach with the vegetables is perfect (I need to get some Yukons).
Always a jar of bacon grease in our fridge :-)
Nice smoker!
Nice looking smoke you got there. Bet everyone had a good time.

Point for sure
I hope everyone appreciated your cooking. Mighty fine job.

I love grilled thighs. I usually de-bone so they cook faster. Thigh meat can easily take up to 180° without drying out.
disco disco led me the way to crispy chicken skin. I do a modified version of separating the skin, but leave it attached to the thigh at a corner. Scrape down the fat and flap over the thigh. Makes it easier to keep meat and skin together for flipping.

I love taters and onions. I often foil wrap with generous dash of garlic rosemary seasoning and into the heat.

I leave the squash to my wife. She doesn't smoke and I don't like squash. is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts