That could very well be. I picked up a 6 probe bluetooth thermometer so I can test it compared to the built in ones.

Nice. I had a huge smoke this past weekend. Had 5 full racks of spare ribs so I had 5 shelves going. I couldn't get the internal temp over 200...even setting it to 300. I realize that when you fill your smoker up with 40 degree meat, temps will go down, but after 45 minutes I was running out of patience. I read in some other forums that others struggled with temps when there was a lot of meat in it, and the solution was to remove the water pan and just use a foil pan filled with water on the bottom rack. I did that and temps shot up quickly and stayed within 15 degrees of target the entire smoke. Toward the end it started running a little on the hotter side (as the meat was pretty much cooked). So my guess is that the internal thermometer takes into account this stock water pan in calculating temps at the grate level...just a hunch. When I used this smaller pan the next day for just one small item, the temps were running 20 degrees hotter....with stock water pan they were consistently 35 degrees cooler. I think I'm going to cut an additional air vent or 2 in the stock water tray and see if that gets me somewhere in the middle. At least I'm not getting huge swings during the cook. Once I figure this thing out I'm pretty confident I can set it and forget it.That could very well be. I picked up a 6 probe bluetooth thermometer so I can test it compared to the built in ones.
![]()
Wow that is an incredible looking brisket. Did you remove the the water pan and replace it with the foil pan?
I have misplaced the instructions for the Costco vertical smoker but I think I remember reading that it had to be prepped. Can anyone confirm this?
Alright - I need help addressing two issues. I've tried to read a 1000 forums on this for the LG Vertical Smoker...and really haven't found much.
1) Temperature swings - with the metal water pan (that came with it) at the bottom, closest to the firebox in, I see about 15-20 degrees consistently (without any meat). With a full 17 pound pork butt, swings between 40-50 degrees. *Using Thermapro thermometers)*
Question: Has the placement of the water pan affected anyone's temperatures in a positive way (less swings) --- i.e. moving it HIGHER up the racks?
Question: Has removing the metal water pan and replacing it with an aluminum one really made that big of a difference?
Question: How about not having the water pan at all? Results? Thoughts?
2) Packing Meat w/ Smoke - Smoked a pork butt last week. Wanted the smoker to stay at 250 degrees, had to switch the unit to 300 because of the 50 degree difference. Very little smoke flavor. *Used Pit Boss Pellets*
Question: Smoke mode...should I just keep it on smoke mode for 2-3 hours if this is the case?
Question: Any other thoughts about getting more smoke into it outside of using smoke mode?
3) Meat Placement & Temperature - I usually keep what I'm smoking on the top few racks (if I'm not doing that much).
Question: Any experience with where your smoker is the most accurate? Top, middle, bottom?