Carolina (inspired) Mustard BBQ sauce

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

chef k-dude

Master of the Pit
Original poster
Mar 11, 2015
1,225
1,137
Central Virginia
I created a mustard BBQ sauce some years ago, but it was a real pain to make, pan toasting and grinding spices, etc.. Good, but didn't feel like doing it much. I always had in the back of my mind that I wanted an easier one and had printed out what was a more basic sauce I found online. Had some BBQ pork loin rising to the surface of my meal planning list and figured this was a good time to play around with this. I grilled the loin, portioned and froze it for some meals the next week or two.

I decided for an easy button meal yesterday, to pull out a portion of pulled pork (and slightly chopped) for sandwiches and make and tweak this sauce. I'm open for ideas and suggestions. Here's where my recipe is today, I will likely tweak it more but this is very good as written. You'll see that I like to weigh as much stuff as possible!:

Carolina mustard BBQ sauce

Make 2 cups plus a few ounces more.

¾ cup yellow mustard (180 grams)
½ cup honey (170 grams) (used sugar free)
½ cup apple cider vinegar (120ml/grams)
¼ cup brown sugar (48 grams) (used Swerve)
2 tablespoons ketchup (35 grams)
2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce (10ml/grams)
1 tsp Texas Pete (5ml/grams)
½ teaspoon salt, MSG and red pepper flakes
1 tsp each, coarse black pepper, mustard powder, garlic and onion granules


Combine all in a glass bowl, whisking the dry with the cider vinegar first.

Heat on high (850 watt microwave) 1 minute intervals, 3 times whisking after each time.

*Can use a pan on the stove of course, as well


My notes for the future:
*A fairly loose BBQ sauce, vinegar forward and tangy, not super sweet at all, not super spicy and not super mustard forward either.

*Could cut the vinegar in half for a slightly thicker, sweeter sauce.

*Could handle more spice/heat level (for those who like it spicy)

I know it looks a little granular in the pic but it doesn't come off that way at all even just off of a spoon.
01 the sauce.jpg


On the pulled pork
02 sauced.jpg


I decided to do something I dont usually do...onions on a PP sandwich
03 onions.jpg


On to 647 Kaiser rolls (these are lower carb rolls but very good), a slice of chipotle pepper jack (again, not a usual PP sandwich) and the onions. Plated with crispy dill slices...and that's leftover homemade thousand Island from the Reuben's I made recently for dipping those in.

04 plated.jpg


Made a great sandwich. I'm going to try thickening (probably use the Thickitup lower carb stuff) the sauce a bit for use as a sauce topping for the aforementioned sliced BBQ pork loin.
 
Your sauce recipe looks tasty. I don’t do a lot of mustard base sauce and never even been close to the Carolinas, but I copied a mustard sauce recipe from a member here, wrote his handle down but obviously wrong because I can’t pull it up in search. So I’ll just share as is, pretty close to what you have, and give credit if I can figure out his handle name.

Carolina Mustard Sauce:

3/4c yellow mustard
3/4c red wine vinegar
1/2c white sugar
3 Tbs brown sugar
2 Tbs butter
2 tsp salt
1/2 Tbs woosrsy sauce
1/2 tsp soy sauce
1 tsp hot sauce
1 1/2 tsp black pepper
1 tsp white pepper.

Combine, simmer at least 30 min cool for 1 hour before serving.

This is pretty dang tasty.
 
Smokinedge, that is same mustard sauce recipe I use. Totally agree, it is tasty, best mustard sauce ever tried. I didnt write down who shared it though. Wish I did as they deserve props.
 
Those all sound good. Im not a huge mustard sauce guy, but do like it now and then. My wife really likes it with chicken.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky