Bone in Butt prep help

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Brewster B

Newbie
Original poster
Sep 6, 2018
2
1
So I’m having a bunch of friends over next weekend for a bbq feast. Because my wife and I both work during the week we had to hit up our butcher today and pick up a couple of 7lb bone in butts. These are loosely bagged so my question is this: can I season them all over with my rub, vacuum seal them and refrigerate until next Saturday and will the 6 days with the rub affect my butts in any way bad? Or should I just vacuum seal them the way they are and season them Friday night?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.
 
I would think you'll be fine, as long as the butts were fresh when purchased. The spices will only permeate the meat better the longer you allow it to sit. If you use sugar it will liquefy but that's no biggie. I always rub mine down in advance, then roll 'em up in saran-wrap and toss 'em in the reefer. Between the second and third day there, you'll open the door and this wave of aroma will just roll over you and you'll be amazed it got thru the saran-wrap.

Personally I think you'll be fine as long as the meat was fresh when purchased.
 
Most food safety guides will tell you can safely store a fresh raw pork roast for 3-5 days in the refrigerator.

Just me personally, I'd brought them home and straight into the freezer for three days, then thawed three days in the refrigerator.
Putting rub on the meat won't have any adverse effects if on for several days.
For the time out of the fridge and handling I'd take a day off the time, so 2-4 days safe storage in the fridge.

Will you be likely be okay with six days? Yes, more than likely, but what if it's not and your guests get sick?
 
Last edited:
Check the temp in your fridge . I keep mine at or around 36 degrees for things like this .
 
Is the sell by or use by date later than the date you plan to cook? If so, I'd probably freeze and then thaw just to be safe. It shouldn't hurt to rub them that far in advance but if your rub has a lot of salt, a lot of liquid will be drawn out. I'm not gonna debate about the rub permeating the meat and all that, but I generally rub mine the day of while the smoker is heating up and I can't tell a difference between that and rubbing them a few days in advance.
 
Thanks for all the responses. Since I’m nor cooking just for me or the family I’ll play it safe and vacuum seal and throw in the freezer for a couple of days then thaw in fridge. Better safe than sorry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chopsaw
USDA says 5 days but that is a guideline. At 6 days that meat is not suddenly a toxic waste land. Second, the USDA assumes people are idiots with refers running at 40° and kids that stare in for an hour deciding what to eat. A 36° refer, back of the bottom shelf will hold meat very cold, if not partially freeze it. This to gives some wiggle room. Third, Rub contains Sugar and Salt as well as Blk Pepper, and Chile powder. These all have antibacterial properties that inhibit growth if not kill bacteria. Think Prosciutto or Country Ham. Raw pork rubbed in salt with or without sugar and spices, hung at 40-50° for months to years. So Rubbed, wrapped and in the back, bottom shelf of a, best case, little used refer for 6-7 days should be no issue. This is of course, barring the meat was mishandled, 2 hours in a 100° car getting home from the butcher.
Freezing a couple of days is fine as well. But...watch your timing! You gain nothing if you forget to pull the meat to defrost 3-4 days out slowly in the refer, and have to put it on the counter or water to defrost it.

Myth...Salting meat too long before cooking dries it out.

Yes and No...Yes salt sucks moisture and a pool of juice forms but this is only an issue over a short time. For best result, Salt meat immediately, seconds, before cooking, or salt an hour or more out, wrap or bag it. In the first case you get seasoning only. Salting way ahead is called Dry Brining. The salt draws and combines with the meat juices, but, it is reabsorbed over time, result in flavorful, tenderizes meat that actually Holds its juiciness better than meat that is not salted. Salting, Rubbing, etc, an hour or more out result in a better more juicy product than just Salting or Rubbing while the smoker heats up. Good luck...JJ
 
Thanks for all the responses. Since I’m nor cooking just for me or the family I’ll play it safe and vacuum seal and throw in the freezer for a couple of days then thaw in fridge. Better safe than sorry.
Just FYI, I'm cooking an eight pound butt today that was in the freezer. I put it in the fridge Tuesday and by Friday morning it was completely thawed.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky