BBQ Pitmasters: Season 3...Wrap up...

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
i posted this on another post

i watched season 1 of this show a couple years ago and it was great!  Season 2 turned into more of a competition reality show...like Survivor. They were forced to cook things they've never cooked like rattle snake. i was not a huge fan of this and i think they completely lost scope of thee idea of the show.

do  you know if season 3 will get back to smoking and real competitions?

sounds like S3 is back to smoking...?
 
Episode 4:  Set in Dothan, Alabama, site of the Tri State BBQ Fest, 3 pitmasters, led by Season 1 and 2 competitor Lee Ann Whippen of Wood Chicks BBQ from Chesapeake, VA, tried to wow the judges cooking bone in ham and beef ribs.  The other 2 teams were Corey Brinsons' Fat Backs BBQ Shak from North Carolina and Shane McBride of New York and his team RibDiculous BBQ Krewe.  With 11 hours to cook, McBride and Brinson chose to inject, rub and get the hams on pretty quick, while Lee Ann made up a brine she held the hams in for a few hours.  All 3 had very nice presentations on the beef ribs, but Fat Backs lacked alot to be desired in their ham box, however, in the end it was enough to impress the judges as Chris and his team won the battle and will move on to the finale.  Also, noticed Lee Ann was sporting a Jambo Pit.  Nice looking rig.  Did any of you catch the close up of the interior of the Jambo?  Looked like some kind of a diverter on the firebox end opening into the chamber.  I know he's (Jamie Geer) pretty secretive about what makes the Jambo such a good cooker.  Seen an interview on YouTube and he wouldn't open up Cool Smokes pit because he didn't want to let his build secrets out.  Anybody out there with a Jambo?  Unfortunately for all us RF smokers, for the second week in a row, a team cooking on a RF pit, finished in 3rd (or last, however you look at it), RibDiculous was using one this week after C-Dubs used one in Episode 3.  I promise you, some great and easy cooking BBQ comes off RF smokers!
 
Last edited:
Looks like they gave a lot of airtime to the Lang 36.  At least that is what I thought I saw in the background when ever they went to the judges.
 
Episode 5:  With the season finale coming up next Sunday, this was the last chance for a pitmaster to qualify to compete in the 5 team comp to decide the Kingsford BBQ Pitmaster Champion and win $50K.  Teams from this episode featured Diva Q and Danielle Dimovski from Canada, Randy of Southern Krunk out of Arkansas and Rob of 2 Worthless Nuts of Cleveland.  Pork in the Park BBQ Festival in Salisbury, Maryland was the site for this round as the teams were cooking chicken and rack of pork.  All 3 wowed the judges with their pork rack presentations, so it came down to the chicken to decide the winner.  Randy turned in a half chicken (Texas style cook) and the judges were not sure what to do with it since they have no knives or forks to get their own meat, the other 2 cooks, turned in both samples of sliced breast and legs or thighs for the dark meat.  After all the judging was done, Season 2 competitor Diva Q took this contest and moved on to compete next week in the finale.  She will be going against Johnny Trigg, Melissa Cookston, Corey Brinson and Soloman Williams, cooking pork shoulder and pork ribs in North Carolina.  I was hoping that they would use the finale to do a KCBS type cook off (chicken, ribs, pork, and brisket) to get a true measure of each ones cooking prowess and not a couple of categories that might favor 1 or 2 cooks (Melissa Cookston - pork shoulder, Johnny Trigg - ribs). 
 
Episode 5:  With the season finale coming up next Sunday, this was the last chance for a pitmaster to qualify to compete in the 5 team comp to decide the Kingsford BBQ Pitmaster Champion and win $50K.  Teams from this episode featured Diva Q and Danielle Dimovski from Canada, Randy of Southern Krunk out of Arkansas and Rob of 2 Worthless Nuts of Cleveland.  Pork in the Park BBQ Festival in Salisbury, Maryland was the site for this round as the teams were cooking chicken and rack of pork.  All 3 wowed the judges with their pork rack presentations, so it came down to the chicken to decide the winner.  Randy turned in a half chicken (Texas style cook) and the judges were not sure what to do with it since they have no knives or forks to get their own meat, the other 2 cooks, turned in both samples of sliced breast and legs or thighs for the dark meat.  After all the judging was done, Season 2 competitor Diva Q took this contest and moved on to compete next week in the finale.  She will be going against Johnny Trigg, Melissa Cookston, Corey Brinson and Soloman Williams, cooking pork shoulder and pork ribs in North Carolina.  I was hoping that they would use the finale to do a KCBS type cook off (chicken, ribs, pork, and brisket) to get a true measure of each ones cooking prowess and not a couple of categories that might favor 1 or 2 cooks (Melissa Cookston - pork shoulder, Johnny Trigg - ribs). 
The glaze Diva Q was using is made by Texas Pepper Jelly he makes real good stuff for anybody looking for a unique glaze on their products.  I have met the owner at comps here in Texas and he is a nice guy pretty friendly.  He won the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo BBQ cook off a few years ago.  
 
Episode 5:  With the season finale coming up next Sunday, this was the last chance for a pitmaster to qualify to compete in the 5 team comp to decide the Kingsford BBQ Pitmaster Champion and win $50K.  Teams from this episode featured Diva Q and Danielle Dimovski from Canada, Randy of Southern Krunk out of Arkansas and Rob of 2 Worthless Nuts of Cleveland.  Pork in the Park BBQ Festival in Salisbury, Maryland was the site for this round as the teams were cooking chicken and rack of pork.  All 3 wowed the judges with their pork rack presentations, so it came down to the chicken to decide the winner.  Randy turned in a half chicken (Texas style cook) and the judges were not sure what to do with it since they have no knives or forks to get their own meat, the other 2 cooks, turned in both samples of sliced breast and legs or thighs for the dark meat.  After all the judging was done, Season 2 competitor Diva Q took this contest and moved on to compete next week in the finale.  She will be going against Johnny Trigg, Melissa Cookston, Corey Brinson and Soloman Williams, cooking pork shoulder and pork ribs in North Carolina.  I was hoping that they would use the finale to do a KCBS type cook off (chicken, ribs, pork, and brisket) to get a true measure of each ones cooking prowess and not a couple of categories that might favor 1 or 2 cooks (Melissa Cookston - pork shoulder, Johnny Trigg - ribs). 
I totally agree the show should have a KCBS type cook off.  My only fear would be they would screw it up similar to season 2.  Everyone would turn in chicken first with an elimination round to follow ie "put out your pit."  The number of contestants would work to well for the producers to resist.
 
i would like to see better editing. stop the pre-commercial fore shadow and post-break review. lets see more of each pitmasters at work. lets see more comments from the judges.
 
Watching the show I thought it was odd that the one guy didn't cut his chicken. Also they made the canadian woman look like such a b**tch. Maybe she is who knows. I know if she talked me like she did her husband I would've walked away and told her to finish that crap herself. Plus she's talking crap to one of the guys in the beginning but when they start doing it she's all "I don't have time to smack talk I'm here to cook!"   Then make her look all humble when she wins???? PUHLEEZE!.  I saw her on the last season and she was annoying on that show too but she didn't win. I was really hoping for one of the other 2 to win.

  Has anyone noticed a pattern of their contestants? 2 fairly well known Q'ers and then a nobody and the nobody always comes in 3rd, except the 1st show. I didn't recognize any of them.

and 1 more observation....The first 2 people draw numbers so when the 3rd guy gets up there only his/her numbers are left, why make him/her draw?
 
 
Season 3 wrapped up Sunday night with the coronation of the Kingsford Cup Grand Champion.  The season finale was filmed in Lexington, North Carolina at the BBQ Capital Cook Off.  Whole pork shoulder and spare ribs were on the menu for the finale as Johnny Trigg (Smokin' Triggers), Danielle Dimovski (Diva Q), Melissa Cookston (Memphis BBQ Co.), Solomon Williams (Rib King of Carolina) and Corey Brinson of Fatbacks BBQ Shack went head to head for the $50,000 grand prize.  With 5 teams, I felt like the show should have been stretched to at least 1 1/2 hours if not 2, it seemed as if they weren't able to spend enough time with each cook giving you insights into their process for cooking and prep of each meat.  15 or so minutes into the show, Myron announced there was going to be a challenge and all I could think of was the goofy meats and challenges from season 2 that nearly kept season 3 from ever happening.  But instead of a wacky challenge, they gave them a third meat to cook, pork cheeks.  I know, that may seem pretty wacky as well, but not as bad as the rattlesnake or shrimp and oysters, catfish or side dish challenges from last season.  I still believe that a KCBS style competition would have been a better challenge and shown a better display of each cooks prowess and ability, especially since most of them (with the exception of Johnny) are all from pork country and or have heavy pork backgrounds.  In the end, judges Myron Mixon, Aaron Franklin and Tuffy Stone, narrowed it down to 2, Johnny Trigg and Corey Brinson, after all was said and done, Johnny Trigg walked away with the $50K and the title Kingsford Cup Grand Champion.  I was rooting for both Trigg and Brinson, but Brinson probably could have made better use of the money and opened a real restaurant and moved out of his roadside trailer.  All in all, I was impressed with season 3 and hopefully with a few minor alterations, season 4 comes to us early next year.  Meanwhile, I'll keep replaying seasons 1-3 on my DVR.     
 
Season 3 wrapped up Sunday night with the coronation of the Kingsford Cup Grand Champion.  The season finale was filmed in Lexington, North Carolina at the BBQ Capital Cook Off.  Whole pork shoulder and spare ribs were on the menu for the finale as Johnny Trigg (Smokin' Triggers), Danielle Dimovski (Diva Q), Melissa Cookston (Memphis BBQ Co.), Solomon Williams (Rib King of Carolina) and Corey Brinson of Fatbacks BBQ Shack went head to head for the $50,000 grand prize.  With 5 teams, I felt like the show should have been stretched to at least 1 1/2 hours if not 2, it seemed as if they weren't able to spend enough time with each cook giving you insights into their process for cooking and prep of each meat.  15 or so minutes into the show, Myron announced there was going to be a challenge and all I could think of was the goofy meats and challenges from season 2 that nearly kept season 3 from ever happening.  But instead of a wacky challenge, they gave them a third meat to cook, pork cheeks.  I know, that may seem pretty wacky as well, but not as bad as the rattlesnake or shrimp and oysters, catfish or side dish challenges from last season.  I still believe that a KCBS style competition would have been a better challenge and shown a better display of each cooks prowess and ability, especially since most of them (with the exception of Johnny) are all from pork country and or have heavy pork backgrounds.  In the end, judges Myron Mixon, Aaron Franklin and Tuffy Stone, narrowed it down to 2, Johnny Trigg and Corey Brinson, after all was said and done, Johnny Trigg walked away with the $50K and the title Kingsford Cup Grand Champion.  I was rooting for both Trigg and Brinson, but Brinson probably could have made better use of the money and opened a real restaurant and moved out of his roadside trailer.  All in all, I was impressed with season 3 and hopefully with a few minor alterations, season 4 comes to us early next year.  Meanwhile, I'll keep replaying seasons 1-3 on my DVR.     
hey bruno...appreciate all the synopsis.  i've watched every episode of season 1 and 3 at least 3 times; as many here have stated, i really didn't like season 2 and i'm glad they went away from that format.

let's hope they get more rookies in season 4.  ...all these "old" faces are making it a little ~repetitive.
 
I totally agree with needing fresh faces.  I enjoyed getting to know some of the lesser known cooks through the episodes.  There are so many BBQ teams out there that filling spots would not be a problem for the shows producers and creators.  There are a ton of teams here or on BBQ Brethrens that would love to see their name splattered across the TV.   
 
I like Johnny Trigg but really would've liked the guy from NC to win. The format I would like to see is that they change up the judges from episode to episode. I think Myron is a ____ and I also think he knew darn well which box was Triggs just because he's probably ate his stuff so much.   But the guy from NC should be proud to hold his own against Trigg. Did anyone notice that this time they didn't say "By only ?/10ths of a point our winner is"   I believe this is the only episode that they didn't.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mixon did claim in season 2 when Trigg appeared there, that it was the first time he had ever tasted Johnnys' ribs.  Not so sure about Tuffy. 
 
I thought there was a show on where they had a contest at Triggs house. It was Mixon, Tuffy (I think) Trigg, The whiney blonde chick, and I think 2 other guys and he says something about serving them ribs the night before.
 
 
I wanted Corey Brinson to win...Trigg has enough money and Trophies. Frankly I don't believe that the finally was not rigged...I don't think it is possible for Corey to cut his Rack, Two ribs are perfect and the next one as tough as if it was Raw? Im' no Grand Champion in anything but I have cooked Hundreds of racks of Ribs and not one person ever came back and said, " the Ribs were Awesome except the third one from the left was like Shoe Leather..."
th_dunno-1%5B1%5D.gif
...JJ
 
Last edited:
I wanted Corey Brinson to win...Trigg has enough money and Trophies. Frankly I don't believe that the finally was not rigged...I don't think it is possible for Corey to cut his Rack, Two ribs are perfect and the next one as tough as if it was Raw? Im' no Grand Champion in anything but I have cooked Hundreds of racks of Ribs and not one person ever came back and said, " the Ribs were Awesome except the third one from the left was like Shoe Leather..."
th_dunno-1%5B1%5D.gif
...JJ
editing is crap on the show. but in past shows it was said by some pitmaster they make more than one rack and they select the best ribs. so it's possible they came from a different rack. although i always taste a rib from each rack i cook to make sure. maybe it was an oversite and he simply missed it. who really knows.
 
editing is crap on the show. but in past shows it was said by some pitmaster they make more than one rack and they select the best ribs. so it's possible they came from a different rack. although i always taste a rib from each rack i cook to make sure. maybe it was an oversite and he simply missed it. who really knows.
 Makes sense...I just figured if he had more than one rack he would take all three from the best one...Thanks...JJ
 
I thought it was weird about the rib also. Maybe he got them mixed up and was eating someone elses?   I have never had ribs do that and I am by no means a professional. Either they all suck or they're all good.
 
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky