10lb Brisket

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

burgerbob

Smoke Blower
Original poster
Feb 18, 2016
109
120
Nebraska
It's been a while since I've been on the forum and was doing a brisket I was pretty excited about so thought I would make a post about it.

I had a 10 pound brisket that I got from our university's meat department for real cheap since they had a beef special going on.  It looked like it had some really good marbling and I've been needing an excuse to cook it.  Got together with immediate family and significant others and cooked this up for everyone.  

I decided to actually take notes this time instead of mental notes which I don't think it will help me in future because I did have an issue with it that I'll get into later.

At about 10 a.m. the day before I trimmed the brisket, since the university sells it untrimmed.  Seasoned it with mainly salt and pepper, dusted it with some garlic powder and onion powder.  

Wrapped it in plastic wrap and threw it back in the fridge for the next morning.

I trimmed off about a pound and a half of fat from the brisket so I was kind of expecting it to be around 8.5 pounds.

I got my brisket on the smoker about 7 a.m. which I was thinking would be enough time to have it ready to pull off by 5 p.m. and that was my first issue.  I know that I shouldn't have put it on that late and should have figured for a minimum of 1 1/2 hours per pound.  I really wish I would have started it earlier in the morning than what I did. 

The internal temp climbed rather quickly which made me think I didn't have my thermometer probe in properly.  But it slowed down and I got a good 6.5 hours of smoke on it before I wrapped it.  This was the first time I have used butcher paper instead of aluminum foil.  I had read that it will allow some of the moisture to escape and give you a crispier bark but keeping moisture in the brisket.

I wrapped the brisket and threw it back on.  I was hoping that I would have gotten thru the stall a little bit quicker than what I did when I wrapped it and got worried I wouldn't have it done by when I needed to.  I pretty much had to kick the temp up on the smoker so I got it up to 300 about 2 hours after I had wrapped it.  I was getting pretty worried because it wasn't raising much quicker but left it alone and had it to temp around the time I needed it.  

The point turned out amazing and the flat was moist but still a little tough. I'm thinking it's because I had to crank the temp up and not keep it at the 225 that I was hoping to. This was pretty much my main issue with it even though it still had good flavor and wasn't dry. If anyone has any thoughts on why it was tough I'm all ears. The point was amazing and nearly melted in my mouth.

I had a lot of the point leftover because my family doesn't like all the fat in it. I prefer the point because I like the fat they all don't like and find the flat to be too lean.  I believe I heard Aaron Franklin say in one of his videos that the point is like a sirloin steak and the point is like a ribeye.

Here's the times for everything

0600 -  Got UDS started

0615 – Took brisket out of fridge

0700 -  Put brisket on smoker fat cap down, smoker temp 265

0800 – Smoker temp 240

0900 – Smoker temp 220, IT 115

1000 – Smoker temp 220, IT 135

1100 – Smoker temp 230, IT 143

1200 – Smoker temp 225, IT 161

1315 – IT 164, Smoker temp 240, wrapped in butcher paper

1530 – IT 170, Smoker temp 250, bumped temp up to 300

1630 – Smoker 300, IT 183

1730 – Smoker 300, IT 195 pulled from smoker and let rest

1830 – Sliced and served

Seasoned and resting before going on the smoker.


Ready to be wrapped




Finished and ready to be sliced.



Sliced, you can't really see the smoke ring very well in this picture though.

 
Boy it sure looks good from here!

It sounds to me like you didn't cook the flat quite long enough.

That is usually the case when they are a little chewy.

I've had some flats that didn't get probe tender until 210, other times they were done at 195.

Each piece of meat is different.

I still have to give you a point for a fantastic looking brisket!

Al
 
Thanks Al, I appreciate the feedback.  I guess I'll just need to go based on feel for the next one I do.
 
Nice! [emoji]128077[/emoji][emoji]127866[/emoji]

Yeah, everyone now is going 200 plus degrees it seems.. the probe for resistance..then it's in the cooler for a couple hours or more.. Good tips and tricks in here.

I know you were pressed for time.
 
looks nice 
icon14.gif
 
A lot of time I separate the point after I pull the brisket off the smoker and only wrap the flat in a towel and place into a cooler for a couple of hours....While the flat is resting and redistributing the juices, I cut the point up into 2-3 inch cubes in a pan. I throw some more rub on it, and stick the pan back out on the smoker for a few more hours. They make awesome Burnt Ends! and most of the fat will melt into the meat...making it into what I call "Meat Candy"! That will also help with the toughness. Beautiful piece of meat though! Made me hungry for Brisket! 
 
Thanks BoneDadddy. I don't believe I mentioned it earlier but that's exactly what I did with the rest of the point after I ate some of it. I made some of the best burnt ends I've ever made, I was just disappointed in the flat being tough. 
 
It's hard to cook brisket to temp.because as Al mentioned it can be done from anywhere from 195 - 210.
Your best bet for checking to see if a brisket is done...is probe tender in the thickest part of the flat.
You just have to be patient with brisket. When you pull it let sit on the counter for 10-15 to cool some, then wrap and rest for it least an hour.

Overall good looking brisket Thumbs Up
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Great deal on LEM Grinders!

Latest posts

Clicky