Actually I've got a mismatch of parts: the smoker itself has five + two pins. The original controller failed and I ended up with four pin controller that I haven't figured out how to connect.
Based on what I learned from a power board that mates with a 4 pin controller the pin ordering is the same minus the light signal. This could mean the actual pin numbers are renumbered from my 5 pin controller. Regardless, here are how the pins are labeled and ordered on the power board:
Power Board connectors
4 pin connector - connects to controller
-- +5V (to controller)
-- TEMP (back wall temp probe -- sends varying amount of voltage to controller based on temperature?)
-- GND (to controller)
-- HEAT (+5V from controller closes relay on power board, turns on 120VAC element)
2 pin connector - connects to back wall temperature probe <-- concluded in thread above
-- TEMP (back wall temp probe -- returns varying amount of voltage to power board based on temperature?)
-- +5V (out to back wall temp probe)
As mentioned previously, the power board (the copper trace can be seen) simply ties TEMP to TEMP and +5V to +5V between the 2 pin connector and 5 pin connector on the 5 pin power board. This is assumed to be the same for the 4 pin since they are nearly identical designs.
NOTE: My assumption for the back wall temp probe (or sensor) is based on our discussion above that TEMP (or STOVE-T on 5 pin) is the back wall temperature probe (not the AC thermal cutoff switch). I am going to see if I can make time to characterize this signal a bit while in operation at different temperatures.
Conclusion, I think you can wire the 4 pins directly to the the 5 pin connector (minus light signal) as long as the back wall temp probes are the same specs or at least very close.