Smokin-It Model 2

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
I'm thinking of this unit myself but I saw this review here on SMF. Makes sense and gives me concern. What do you think about this?

http://smokingmeatforums.com/index.php?showcase/smokin-it-model-2-electric-smoker.8699/reviews

My biggest concern with the unit however (and I have used mine for a LONG time) is the lack of damper controls. So what you end up with is something called the "burp" when smoking with this unit. The "burp" is caused by your wood source demanding oxygen inside the cook chamber and not having enough-so as a result the burning wood attempts to draw it's oxygen from the exhaust hole in the top of the unit. The manufacturer most likely does not add a damper because they want to protect the electronics/burner in the unit from extreme temperature fluctuations. This problem is well documented on the "smokin-it" forums.

There are a few solutions. 1-You can ramp up the temperature of your smoker slowly and this will extend the burn time of your wood source causing a less oxygen demanding fire 2-You can wrap your wood pieces or chips in aluminum foil and poke a few holes around them-this serves the purpose of choking oxygen at the source of the fire.

Either way you look at it, you cannot and WILL NOT get optimal smoke flow/quality with this unit. Those who cook on them are used to it. You only need anywhere from 2-5oz of wood depending on what you're cooking and regardless of what kind of wood or how much you ALWAYS END UP WITH THICK, WHITE SMOKE-NOT THE THIN, BLUE SMOKE needed for optimal BBQ. Sure, you can cook some good tasting BBQ but anyone with oxygen controls to their fire will have the upper hand over this unit.
 
I'm thinking of this unit myself but I saw this review here on SMF. Makes sense and gives me concern. What do you think about this?

http://smokingmeatforums.com/index.php?showcase/smokin-it-model-2-electric-smoker.8699/reviews

My biggest concern with the unit however (and I have used mine for a LONG time) is the lack of damper controls. So what you end up with is something called the "burp" when smoking with this unit. The "burp" is caused by your wood source demanding oxygen inside the cook chamber and not having enough-so as a result the burning wood attempts to draw it's oxygen from the exhaust hole in the top of the unit. The manufacturer most likely does not add a damper because they want to protect the electronics/burner in the unit from extreme temperature fluctuations. This problem is well documented on the "smokin-it" forums.

There are a few solutions. 1-You can ramp up the temperature of your smoker slowly and this will extend the burn time of your wood source causing a less oxygen demanding fire 2-You can wrap your wood pieces or chips in aluminum foil and poke a few holes around them-this serves the purpose of choking oxygen at the source of the fire.

Either way you look at it, you cannot and WILL NOT get optimal smoke flow/quality with this unit. Those who cook on them are used to it. You only need anywhere from 2-5oz of wood depending on what you're cooking and regardless of what kind of wood or how much you ALWAYS END UP WITH THICK, WHITE SMOKE-NOT THE THIN, BLUE SMOKE needed for optimal BBQ. Sure, you can cook some good tasting BBQ but anyone with oxygen controls to their fire will have the upper hand over this unit.

Sure, I've experienced the burp. When the smoker first gets going the smoke is a bit unpleasant in the fact that it's thick, white, and billowy. However, once the burp happens, usually after 20 minutes or so from my experience (if at all), it settles into the "thinner" smoke. Honestly, I have yet to notice any foul flavor or bitterness because of it. I've smoked on my Model #2 14 times since I received it Labor Day weekend. Long smokes (pulled pork), short smokes (swordfish steaks) and many others in between. Some with a more refined and expert palate may be able to distinguish off putting flavors, but I cannot. I'm in no way claiming to be a BBQ expert either. Far from it as a matter of fact. I still have tons to learn.

Now, I didn't decide on this unit so I could enter BBQ competitions or anything like that. I wanted a unit that was better than what I had; easier to maintain temp; turn out some good BBQ; a quality build, and would be the right size and convenience for me and my small family. Without a doubt, there are products out there that out perform the Smokin' It models, but for the price and the quality of build my Model #2 is perfect for me. I guess it really depends on what you are looking for out of your smoker.

I hope this helped somewhat. Let us know what you decide. I'm eager to hear what you pick up!!!

Happy smokes!!!
Scott
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky