Slightly different take on a cheesesteak.

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

mdboatbum

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
Apr 22, 2011
4,100
472
Washington, DC
I grew up in a fairly large city in the Mid Atlantic. Since it was NOT Philadelphia, the eponymous cheesesteak from that city was not normally on the menu. We had a whole bunch of little sub shops (mostly owned and operated by Greek immigrants) where one could get such delights as Souvlaki, Gyros and my personal favorite, the steak and cheese sub. Though similar in ingredients and preparation, the steak and cheese didn't have all the silly "rules" imposed on it like our neighbors to the north. You ordered it how you wanted it, and no one judged you for it. My standing order was provolone, grilled onions, tomatoes, mushrooms, mayo and hot peppers.

Fast forward to a few days ago, and I had a package of beef shanks sitting in the refrigerator waiting their turn for the dinner table. Our local grocery regularly has them for $3.99/lb, so I'd been getting them fairly regularly. I'd done all the usuals, braised for Osso Bucco, beef stew and simply served with gravy over noodles. Frankly I was a little stumped. Then it dawned on me that I hadn't smoked any beef shanks recently, and also that I really wanted a steak and cheese sub. And I wasn't about to pay $15/lb for ribeye.

I rubbed them down with salt and coarse black pepper the night before:
cottage-1.jpg


Next day I put them on the WSM over cherry for about 3 hours of smoke:
cottage-2.jpg


cottage-3.jpg

At this point they looked pretty ugly but they were gonna be pulled, so I wasn't concerned. I put them in a foil pan with some beef broth and onion to braise for another 3 hours. Didn't get any photos of that step. In fact, the only reason I took photos at all was to send to a friend of mine. Hadn't really planned on posting anything.

Anyway, after the braise, the meat pulled pretty easily.

cottage-5.jpg


Then I fired up the griddle and sauteed some mushrooms and pickled red onion. The pickled onion gave a really nice hint of brightness and spice.

cottage-4.jpg


Then I tossed the meat on to warm it up basically and give it a little crust, then assembled the sandwiches. All I had on hand was Swiss cheese, but all in all they were pretty good sandwiches!

cottage-6.jpg
 

Attachments

  • cottage-5.jpg
    cottage-5.jpg
    342.3 KB · Views: 6
That looks killer! I eat pickled red onions on a lot of things but have never thought to saute them.... hmmmmm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
Those shanks sure make a fine Sammy!
I've been wanting to try them but can't pay the $10 lb they usually run down here 😮‍💨
But I'd stand in line for yours!

Keith
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcam222
Well done!
Shank is great meat that use to be dirt cheap. Don't see it often up here, but get it in central Florida for beef barley soup. Never thought to braise it out for sandwich.
A local dive restaurant served one of the best cheese steak sandwiches I've ever eaten. They used cube steak cooked on the flat top.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
Though similar in ingredients and preparation, the steak and cheese didn't have all the silly "rules" imposed on it like our neighbors to the north. You ordered it how you wanted it, and no one judged you for it. My standing order was provolone, grilled onions, tomatoes, mushrooms, mayo and hot peppers.
There is no way those sandwiches weren't good! Except I'm not a fan of regular Swiss cheese. Like you, I would want provolone or even a good pepper jack of some sort, but I'm also all about "cleaning out the refrigerator" using what I've got and trying to let nothing go to waste. It can make for some strange "platefellows"! Fortunately my wife isn't too picky and can eat things that dont normally go together.

The only rules that really matter are your own for yourself. Subs, pizza, hot dogs Gumbo...whatever, screw the rules others try to impose on you! I just clarify that I am not trying to be "authentic", but dang, even with that, put tomatoes in what you call Gumbo could fire up some Cajuns!

There is a really good little restaurant about 20 minutes from here...pricey but really good. They are snooty as hell though. Don't even think of asking for ketchup for your burger (I wouldn't anyway, but thats what some people want), it is served with the sauce and toppings they designed the recipe with...take it or leave it. Salt and pepper? They try to humiliate you by giving you those little paper packets, and this is the level of dining that should have salt and pepper grinders...at least upon request. That's just bieng a food snob.
That looks great!

You're not missing anything when it comes to Philly cheese steak,both Pat's and Gino's are nasty to the least.
I've only seen them on TV and they look rushed and haphazard, and it seems you better know what you want when you order, dont be indecisive! Only been to Philadelphia once for NSF credentials/test. I have no reason to return.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
You can call it what ever you want.....I'm getting in line behind these other folks for a shot at one! Looks mighty good.

Jim
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
That looks killer! I eat pickled red onions on a lot of things but have never thought to saute them.... hmmmmm.
I make them with a heavy dose of pickling spice and a little extra sugar. When sauteed and added to things like chili or curry, they add a subtle complexity that doesn't dominate the rest of the dish, but makes people go "Hmm, what is that?". I a good way, I hope. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mr_whipple
That looks great!

You're not missing anything when it comes to Philly cheese steak,both Pat's and Gino's are nasty to the least.
Can't comment on what they taste like now, but back in the mid '80s I thought both were pretty decent. I was sternly instructed by philadelphian friends to order "Wiz wit", then shut my mouth and step aside.
 
HAHA!! Old Bear and I butted heads on more than one occasion back in the good old days. He's dearly missed.
Bear was pretty particular about particules.

Boy those Sammies look and sound great.

Point for sure
Chris
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky