Simple Herb Grilled NY

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

civilsmoker

Smoking Guru
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Jan 27, 2015
7,265
10,386
Idaho
The wife found these NYs at the local market today for 6.99/lb, so I thought just a very simple fresh and clean preparation was in order, since I got home later than planned......
1903366B-A73F-474F-9499-93CA9BE747F8.jpeg

As a person that spent many years cooking meals for many people, I have always had the desire to share how the average home cook can create hand crafted meals with minimal effort.

That said I want to share how a resultant level meal can be prepped in about 30 min. So one of the tools I also advocate for kitchen is a timer. I actually have 2 in my kitchen as well as a dial clock and digital clock. Timing is a big part of restaurant level cooking.

Step one is to fire up the grill grate out-fitted Webber, just above med heat. I’m targeting a air temp of 450 with a grate temp in the 650 deg level. This takes my grill about 15 min to reach. At this point I use a spray bottle of water to steam clean the grill grates. This a magic bullet trick to keep them oil free and clean searing!

So while the Webber is heating up, I prep the NY with my custom blend of SPOG, sugar & lemon pepper. However this time I also added fresh chopped rosemary, thyme, sage, Italian parsley, and crushed red pepper.
FD57360D-7F4A-43FB-9C6A-58F1BAD5843B.jpeg

I want the fresh herbs to stay on the surface so I dressed them with classic olive oil. Classic olive oil is better for this than virgin because it has a higher burn temp for the grill.
6DF6DEED-0C57-4CE6-A0DD-F9FAB88937AE.jpeg

Next I quarter some shrooms, and you can see the fresh chopped herds that will be used in the shrooms as well as the extra virgin olive oil for dipping bread. There is also a snapshot of my newly made BBQ knife :-).
CE465CBA-AFFC-4300-9395-74C805A7C9B8.jpeg

Ok the NYs go on at the 45 to the sear lines. Notice the clean grates have NO old oil burn off that will cause a nasty taste! Once the NYs are on I set the timer for 12 min.
269E317B-E97F-4EFB-927D-47F90DD7A657.jpeg

At 3.5 min in I turn the first turn.
95F5859D-5E7B-485D-A212-22949D6B5C6C.jpeg

At 6.5 min in they get turned for the second time at the other 45 degree.
1FDC756D-3A82-4502-982F-FE734D8AE3FA.jpeg

After the first turn I dropped some broccoli in salted (salt is a must!) boiling water to blanch them....3 to 4 min, then they get strained and put in a warm (not hot or will cause a fire) pan with 1tbs butter and 1.5tbs virgin olive oil. I want virgin cause I want the robust flavor. The broc is seasoned with the steak mix above and they wait. If you look close you can see some of the water (very little) that comes out of the broc.
DBA2D8B9-1F6D-47B5-9F8C-6E387C6BEEE4.jpeg

On the second steak turn the shrooms go into a hot pan with 1/2tbs butter & 1tbs classic olive. They are also seasoned with the steak blend.
501DA93E-D27F-485F-AAB0-D0C55A6CD3FA.jpeg

@ 9 min in the steaks are turned for the 3rd time.
2BEA5421-CE50-4A46-A204-E9FF74E9A5E5.jpeg

At 12 min (and 9min) they are checked for internal temp with a probe and are pulled to a rack to rest. There was a thinner one (wife’s IT 140) and two thicker, mine and the boys (IT 130). You want to rest on an elevated rack and not a plate because the meat will keep cooking on the plate...
B9AE7072-5E00-4F73-A511-C8A7FB5C5A4C.jpeg

As I go out to take the steaks off, I turn the shrooms on high (18k burner). Just at the last minute before they are done I toss some of the fresh chopped herbs in. You only want these to work in to release the aroma and not cook.
E9648C9A-AC55-4442-95FB-876F1E8742E0.jpeg

I also turned the broc on high to remove all the moisture that came off and very carefully baste them in the olive oil and butter. They are ready now....see no moisture or oil. It has all been infused into the broc.
3E8C68C4-E405-4C8F-A348-7C3F9D23849E.jpeg

Ok 33 min have passed and it’s time to plate.....just a simple clean herb grilled NY and pan seared veg!
4768B83E-2B56-496D-96F6-B968714F0003.jpeg

I have practiced this timing for the thickness of steak many many times and it is near 90% always on, but that is why I use a instant probe to eliminate to other 10% ....the result is a money savings cause you can’t get a steak like this for $9 at the restaurant....it’s also my reasoning for calling it NY Steak Money!
93E8A0B9-CE7D-46F3-899B-E1A757A05D29.jpeg

If you haven’t tried a fresh herb seasoned steak your in for a treat because the smell and enhanced clean flavor is a show stopper in my book!

The pan seared broccoli is also just evil good flavor!

Thanks for joining the civilsmoker 33min Herb Grilled NY Steak Dinner story.
 
LOL , I feel like a stalker replying so soon after you posted . Just sat down to post something and saw this .
Nice work again . I don't do many NY's but I'd eat that for sure .
 
LOL , I feel like a stalker replying so soon after you posted . Just sat down to post something and saw this .
Nice work again . I don't do many NY's but I'd eat that for sure .

Thanks chop!

Stalk away LOL... I think you must have a post alert....that was like bam!
 
Looking good enough to eat for sure/
Mmmm, steak and shrooms, such a classic and great pairing.
Nice method/timing.
Like!

I pride myself on often being able to bring 3-4 dishes to completion and the table at the same time.
It is all about prep and timing.
 
Looking good enough to eat for sure/
Mmmm, steak and shrooms, such a classic and great pairing.
Nice method/timing.
Like!

I pride myself on often being able to bring 3-4 dishes to completion and the table at the same time.
It is all about prep and timing.

Thanks chili!

How many minutes to the window is a very common statement in our kitchen...call it crazy but my wife has a full time table down to the min for our thanksgiving meal and we strive to have everything done at the predicted time!!!! Having more than one oven helps big time! Although I really miss having 6 burners on the range that we had in our old kitchen!!!
 
I've two ovens and a five burner gas top, it definitely helps.

:emoji_ok_hand:....we would use that extra burner! But we opted for a warming drawer....in the end it was a good trade.....it helps soften the timing thing a bit! Nice for dinner plates too!

Just for those reading, only 3 burners and one bbq grill was used.....lol....the post intention was to show its an everyday meal!!!

Edit, ps it is Wednesday so just a mid-week meal.....
 
That steak is perfection, nicely done! Everything looks absolutely delicious.

I’m the same way, I try to get everything finished at the same time. It works, but man does it get intense.

Like!
 
That is one fine looking meal!
Perfectly done steak!!
Al

Thanks Al! I like to call it the everyday meal LOL....eating beef just makes me feel better!

Awesome looking meal and a great job of a step by step meal prep.

Warren

Thanks Warren, although my wife asked me what "mistress" I was texting while I was typing it up....Now she is joining me on my up coming out of town business trip.....and cause I wanted to share a picture of a steak......LOL

That steak is perfection, nicely done! Everything looks absolutely delicious.

I’m the same way, I try to get everything finished at the same time. It works, but man does it get intense.

Like!

Thanks xray! I almost never get steak when we eat out cause the just aren't done right.

What's funny is people at work ask me all the time how I can juggle and manage multiple design projects (currently 8 valued at over 100M) at one time and I just say "cooking in the kitchen". Its all about time management and knowing how to not get flustered when its HOT......I'm not kidding, managing a kitchen and leading the line was one of the best project management training experiences I have every had!!!!...Its also why I don't do it for a living now....too much work!

That NY strip is money perfect doneness and the shrooms and broccoli look great too! LIKE!

Thanks Smokin! cooking broccoli like this is how I got me kids to eat it. My by will even request it at times.......shock I know.....If fact this meal was his request...
 
great looking meal, thanks for the step by steps they might just come in handy next time I do steaks,
 
great looking meal, thanks for the step by steps they might just come in handy next time I do steaks,

Thanks and you are welcome.....just wanted to demonstrate that it doesn’t take a huge effort to make a quick bam bam meal!
 
Nicely done - that sure is one good looking meal.

Point for sure
Chris
 
Nicely done - that sure is one good looking meal.

Point for sure
Chris

Thanks Chris! You know the rule if it looks good it tastes even better!

We will order 2 with all the available sides please!!!

Roger that Hawg, grab a chair and have a seat!

The crazy thing is 3 plates of this in our neck of the woods would be about 96 bills or so WITHOUT drinks......I call that motivation to learn how to do it at home!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky