• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Recipe ideas for sirloin tip roast?

SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Compulsive Smoker

Meat Mopper
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Joined
Jul 17, 2026
Messages
235
Reaction score
246
Location
Mohnton PA
Hi everyone!

I picked up a sirloin tip roast yesterday for $4.99/lb. because it seemed cheap to me…
I cut it up into 6 smaller pieces and vacuum packed them and put em in the freezer.

Now I need some ideas on how to make them! What is the best IT for them to keep them from drying out? Can you make pulled beef from them or not?

Looking forward to hearing from you all…


IMG_1353.jpeg
 
At 15 plus pounds that's the whole knuckle . I was doing a bunch of those before the price went over 6 bucks here . Great cut of beef .
I break it down into it's individual muscle groups , following the connective tissue lines .
Here's a general tread I did on buying them whole , breakinging down , and how I use it .

 
Thanks Rich! That’s very helpful!

I guess I should have waited to cut it up, but I’ll do that for the next one I buy…
 
I guess I should have waited to cut it up,
I didn't know the first time either . If you cut across the sinue , roast whole and slice thin .
Post a picture of what you ended up with if you can . Just curious to see what muscle groups are involved .
I also do a beef stock reheat on these that works great for sandwiches or even knife and fork meals .
 
I have them vacuum sealed and in the freezer, so I can’t get a very good picture…

I cut it straight down from the top the whole way through… lol not very professional!
 
I cut it straight down from the top the whole way through…
That's fine . No real wrong way .
I started buying and breaking down beef primals / sub primals during Covid . Around 2019 .
I learned as I went , but used this website to know what comes from where , and how it's normally processed .
This is the whole primal section , then it shows the sub primals , and how the sub primals break out .
Scroll down the page and it shows the Knuckle / Sirloin tip .
 
I cut it straight down from the top the whole way through… lol not very professional!
@chopsaw beat me to it. Don't sweat it. Made many cuts like that and turned out just fine! Main thing on this is to pull low IT as this is a lean cut. I am gonna be running one myself for the first time.
 
That's fine . No real wrong way .
I started buying and breaking down beef primals / sub primals during Covid . Around 2019 .
I learned as I went , but used this website to know what comes from where , and how it's normally processed .
This is the whole primal section , then it shows the sub primals , and how the sub primals break out .
Scroll down the page and it shows the Knuckle / Sirloin tip .

@chopsaw beat me to it. Don't sweat it. Made many cuts like that and turned out just fine! Main thing on this is to pull low IT as this is a lean cut. I am gonna be running one myself for the first time.

cook the pieces on the rotisserie, slice thin and make italian beef or philly sammies. I like to add green chilies on mine.
Thanks guys! This is why I joined SMF!

Beef is too expensive to mess up!
 
You have a recipe?

Place meat in crock pot.
Top with 1 packet powdered Au Jus Mix
Top that with 1 packet Ranch Dip Mix
Top all that with 1/2 stick of butter cut into smaller pieces.
Add a few Pepperoncini Peppers.
Cook on low 4 to 6 hours or until it's buttery

Do NOT add any other liquid.
Do NOT add juice from the Pepperoncinis
 
Last edited:
Uncle brought this to a poker game and is always a hit:

Throw all in crock on high until boiling then low a few hours
3-4lb roast cut into 2" cubes
1 12oz beer
1 small jar pepperoncini (brine too)

Serve on buns. Squirt of horsey if wanted.
 
Place meat in crock pot.
Top with 1 packet powdered Au Jus Mix
Top that with 1 packet Ranch Dip Mix
Top all that with 1/2 stick of butter cut into smaller pieces.
Add a few Pepperoncini Peppers.
Cook on low 4 to 6 hours or until it's buttery

Do NOT add any other liquid.
Do NOT add juice from the Pepperoncinis
Thanks KC! What if you would smoke on low for an hour before going in the crockpot? Would that dry it out too much?
 
Uncle brought this to a poker game and is always a hit:

Throw all in crock on high until boiling then low a few hours
3-4lb roast cut into 2" cubes
1 12oz beer
1 small jar pepperoncini (brine too)

Serve on buns. Squirt of horsey if wanted.
Sounds good! Horsey takes any beef sammy from merely good to amazing!
 
Thanks KC! What if you would smoke on low for an hour before going in the crockpot? Would that dry it out too much?
Throw the whole thing in the smoker in a foil pan and let it ride until it's done.

I was only thinking crockpot because its raining here today haha
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Back
Top
Clicky