Propane grill recommendations

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

PolishDeli

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
Oct 9, 2018
414
584
Hi all,

I'm looking to add a small propane grill to my lineup. What are you using, and what would you recommend ?

I'm looking at something along the lines of a Napoleon Freestyle or Weber Spirit.

I'd like it to be small-ish (2 or 3 burners), and a side burner would be great. I'd be using it for basic weekday dinner cooks for 3 to 4 people.

Dont need it urgently. I'll probably wait for a July 4th sale. Now I'm just doing a downselect.

A weber kettle and a heavily modified masterbuilt analog smoker are the other tools in my quiver.
 
Napoleon Freestyle or Weber Spirit.
Both good choices in my opinion . I have a Genesis 310 . 2016 , either Memorial day or 4th of July sale . Waiting for the holiday sales is the way to do it . Probably save $100.00 .
I see Lowes carries Monument grills now . No experience with one , but they seems nice .
 
The Weber Genesis E-330 or E-335 are top shelf 3 burner/w sear burner grills! They also have a E-330 stealth that is cool!

They also have a new spirit E-325 that has sear burner function that looks promising!
 
I would vote for a Weber. I have an older Genesis...probably 10+ years old at least. nothing has broken/wore out ever. Deep clean annually is all. I did add grill grates which are a great upgrade, but that was only 2 years ago.

I looked at the current models... civilsmoker civilsmoker named the one that is the closest match to mine. Have fun shopping!
 
Weber gets my vote! Have a Weber summitt for years now and one igniter has stopped working, but not bad for five burners. At minimum, eight years old.

Ryan
 
Hi all,

I'm looking to add a small propane grill to my lineup. What are you using, and what would you recommend ?

I'm looking at something along the lines of a Napoleon Freestyle or Weber Spirit.

I'd like it to be small-ish (2 or 3 burners), and a side burner would be great. I'd be using it for basic weekday dinner cooks for 3 to 4 people.

Dont need it urgently. I'll probably wait for a July 4th sale. Now I'm just doing a downselect.

A weber kettle and a heavily modified masterbuilt analog smoker are the other tools in my quiver.
Weber for sure. My two burner Silver A has lasted 23 yrs and counting (w replacement burners and flavorizer bars).
 
Another vote for Weber as well! Only reason we don't have our old Genesis is because we gifted it to another family member. Still going strong being used weekly!
 
Yes Weber for me also. I have a Summit that is 20 years old and still going strong. As ajbert ajbert said get one that is stainless steel. Will cost a bit more but will pay for itself in longevity.
 
HI! I Have a Napoleon LEX 485 NG . Very good quality unit.
Had a Weber, no comparison IMO.
Mine has a Infra Red side burner and also a rear for a Rotisserie ,which I never used? Its a 3 burner.
I like the wrap around hood on the sides, protects against the wind.
I think I need new burners, have to give it a good cleaning first ?
Got mine from BBQ Guys : Saved money and got a free cover ,free shipping.
They run sales a lot, found out mine was a discontinued model ,which is fine.
Check out BBQ GUYS .COM.
PS: I looked at yur Freestyle model, I would consider upgrading to SS? , Yes its more $ !?.
It will last longer? Mine costs more then twice that.
Obviously, that's yur choice?
Good luck shopping !
 
Last edited:
After searching for one myself I bought this one

Weber Spirit II E-310.jpg


And good thing, it doesn't even look like Weber is offering them anymore. Weber Spirit II E-310 I have only used it once, so I haven't reported back to my thread yet asking for the same advice. I'm getting ready to use it quite a bit real soon though.

The first time I used it, I encountered the idiot safety regulator. God forbid you just crack open the tank willy-nilly instead of opening it slowly like you are terrified of it, the regulator will tell you to "talk to the hand" and restrict your gas flow. If it ticks me off again I will buy an unrestricted regulator with the valve that gives you full, grownup adult control.

The main reason I bought this one is its exact size and configuration. My grill parks in a little spot just inside the garage and gets pulled out on to a gravel driveway. Tiny little wheels wont work for me...and yes some models you can invest in bigger wheels to replace them but I wanted lift on left side, two wheels on the right side, facing the "business side" of the grill.

It's hard for folks to envision your exact situation, but the good people here will recommend quality gear. You have to think about your needs. Where is this going to be used and stored? If it's going to live outside 24-7, the all stainless is a good recommendation. That wasn't something I needed to spend the money on because like my van, my grill is "garage kept" (as is my MES30 smoker). And my garage is even climate controlled in the summer. Even if you have a grill cover, a grill kept outside, depending on where you live is going to go through all kinds of temps, humidity...condensation, etc.. If you live in paradise, its not as much of a problem.

The other thing to consider is how you want to use it. Are you throwing parties and grilling for dozens of people? Need a side burner? For me, nope. I'm usually grilling for two, maybe 6 sometimes and the side burner on my old grill would not turn down low enough to simmer something so it was somewhat useless. I have a 6 burner Viking cook-top just on the other side of the garage door in the garage if I need burners...then there is the kitchen. Also my electric skillet and my deep fryer both of which can be operated on the back deck if needed. Different tools for different jobs, my grill doesn't have to be "everything". You might want yours TO be though.

So for me, configuration, type of wheels/mobility, size, simplicity and quality were my deciding factors. I'm still breaking mine in, but I'm pretty sure I'll be happy with it in the long run, even if I DO have to buy an "adult" regulator for it someday.

Happy shopping! Look for the deals, the home improvement places often have really good deals. I got mine on clearance and saved some money.
 
I'm gonna also suggest the Weber. A good friend recently bought a Charbroil and had it delivered to our house. I assembled the grill and the wife and I delivered it to her. I was shocked how cheaply made it was but mostly how unstable it was. If you're on a tight budget then these grills will serve your need but I have the 2 burner Weber Spirit and it's held up well with only 1 rebuild in 4 years of hard use.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky